Staci can hardly believe what a rude reception she receives from Miss Helga Grissel. After all, she was only trying to welcome Miss Grissel to Wildwood. With Miss Harbor's help, Staci learns an important lesson in showing grace to someone who's hard to live with.

When Ned refuses to part with an autographed baseball C.J. wants, C.J.'s envy threatens to get the better of him. With the help of Mr. Collins' cylinder player, C.J. hears the story of King Ahab and Naboth's Vineyard, and discovers how destructive envy can be.

Staci tells The Club shocking news—Hugh wants to join the club! Hugh is seen doing good deeds and being kind to others. His transformation even impresses Miss Harbor. But C.J. wonders how one can know if a person has really changed.

C.J. tries to bring peace between The Club and Hugh. Being a peacemaker is certainly what God would want, right? But C.J.'s idea to bring the two tribes together explodes when his methods betray his good intentions.

The local baseball team is on the brink of winning the championship when an injury sidelines their star player. But Gooz finds a lucky penny and the Calvary is on a roll. Now The Club must decide if the team's dependence on the penny is just some harmless fun or if it takes their focus off playing to please God.

A hot day drives C.J. and Staci inside to explore the cool basement of the Collins Mansion. The recovering of Mr. Collins' private journal leads them to the discovery of a lifetime! But someone lurking in the shadows will do anything to keep them from it.

When Miss Harbor teaches a lesson on King Arthur, The Club decides it should make up some rules of conduct just like Arthur and his knights did. But instead of bringing peace, The Club's rules threaten to divide them all.

When it seems that Tiffany can fire anyone who works for her father, she forces all the kids of Mr. Rockler's employees to be her personal servants... or else. C.J. decides Tiffany must be stopped. But can he carry out his plan when he learns who the next victim might be?

Marsha goes head-to-head with spelling bee champ Tiffany Rockler. When Tiffany shows her true colors, Marsha must decide if the championship is worth winning at any cost. It's a real D-I-L-E-M-M-A!

"The Fortress" is finally complete. But The Club can't agree on what to use it for! Surprised by an uninvited guest, The Club must work together to discover the fortress' true purpose.