It’s probably the most important exercise we’ve ever attempted on the podcast, finding the most cursed animation character! We debate and grade the cursed-ness of these cursed heavyweights: Hooty (The Owl House), Scratch (The Ghost and Molly McGee), Swift Wind (She-Ra and the Princesses of Power), KVN (Final Space), Tikki (Miraculous Ladybug), Lemongrab (Adventure Time), Dave (Kipo and the Age of Wonderbeasts), Woodman (Hilda), Pig Baby (Infinity Train), Glossaryck (Star vs. the Forces of Evil), Kyubey (Madoka Magica), Scrappy Doo, Onion & Ronaldo (Steven Universe), Jerry (Rick and Morty).

Hosts this week: Dylan Hysen, Michelle Anderer, & Aly Martin.

See the final grades here (SPOILERS!) https://www.overlyanimated.com/wp-content/uploads/2021/10/CursedFinalGrades.png

We go over several relationship archetypes that are frequently discussed and go through examples of notable animation ships that fall under those archetypes.

Hosts this week: Dylan Hysen, Delaney Stovall, & Beatriz Mourad.

Timestamps for the podcast:

• 0:00 – Introduction
• 8:30 – Boy Meets Girl: Adrinette, Lumity, Kataang, Troy/Benson, Yuu/Touko
• 49:00 – Best Friends to Couple: Starco, Korrasami, Connverse, Bumbleby
• 1:10:15 – Childhood Friends to Couple: Ron/Kim, Moonboon, Glimbow
• 1:19:00 – Enemies to Couple: Catradora, Raya/Namaari, Chihiro/Haku, Ashitaka/San, Lapidot
• 1:43:15 – Rivals to Couple: Diana/Akko, Hiccup/Astrid
• 1:48:15 – Opposites Attract: Zutara, Rupphire, WALL-E/EVA, Bubbline
• 1:54:45 – Love Triangles: Korra/Bolin/Mako
• 1:57:00 – Red String of Fate: Taki/Mitsuha
• 1:59:45 – Bad for Each Other: PearlRose, Makorra
• 2:03:00 – Polyamorous Relationships: Fluorite, Hollyhock’s dads
• 2:07:00 – Conclusion

Dylan Hysen & Michelle Anderer go through the basics and differences of the script-driven and storyboard-driven animation productions formats.

Happy New Year everyone! After years of moving forward with a similar format, we’re switching things up for the podcast.

The headline is: We’re going to stop doing episode recap podcasts, and we’re going to focus on more high-level discussions.

The immediate change you’ll see is no episode recap podcasts which will result in less podcasts. However, we’ll still be covering the same shows, the podcast will still generally be similar, we’ll just be structuring our discussions in different ways. We think this new structure will result in more interesting discussions, and we’ll be better equipped to cover shows with a wide variety of release formats.

Here are the types of podcasts you’ll see instead of episode recaps:

• Season recaps! We’ll still be discussing seasons as a whole when a show we cover wraps up its season. So you’ll see an Infinity Train Season 2 recap podcast but not nightly podcasts this week. When the next season of She-Ra drops we’ll have a podcast on the whole season soon after it comes out like normal (but no proceeding episode recaps).
• Podcasts at regular intervals for certain shows: This is the replacement model for episode recaps for weekly shows (or others) we still want to talk about regularly while they’re airing. We won’t discuss all the shows we cover on a regular basis, but in the short term look out for Miraculous Ladybug every-other-week podcasts starting sometime in the next two months, and Owl House podcasts monthly (after we do a special podcast for the premiere this weekend). These will be high-level discussions on anything about the show. If there are episodes to talk about we’ll talk about them generally, but we can also talk about general topics surrounding the show or any news about the show.
• Show-specific topics: If something is on our mind about a show, even if we’re not podcasting on it regularly, we might do a podcast to discuss a specific topic whenever! Likely something we’re passionate about like Bumbleby with RWBY.
• Cross-show or movie topics: This is the one we’re most excited about and hope to do a lot more: A trend in the industry, a trend in a social issue (we definitely want to do queer rep topics more than once a year), or some theme we notice across a few shows. This could really be anything involving animation.

Some exceptions to no more episode recaps: First, we still could do one if there’s an episode we’re super excited to talk about! Also, Steven Universe Future may or may not continue with episode recaps until its completion (if not we’d have every-other-week podcasts when it comes back). We’ll finish out Volume 7 recaps for RWBY since it’s almost over. We may finish out the She-Ra S4 recaps we almost finished. And we can still do pods on a single movie, whether it’s recently released or not!

We’re excited to continue to talk about a lot of awesome animated shows and movies in a format we think will work better. As always reach out with any feedback you have on the podcast!

Dylan Hysen, Delaney Stovall, Michelle Anderer, & Sarah Potter look back on the good, the bad, and overall trends in the portrayals of queer characters in 2019 animation including in Steven Universe, She-Ra and the Princesses of Power, OK K.O.! Let’s Be Heroes, Young Justice: Outsiders, Craig of the Creek, Star vs. the Forces of Evil, gen:LOCK, Arthur, Rocko’s Modern Life, RWBY, BoJack Horseman, Tuca & Bertie, The Dragon Prince, Twelve Forever, My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic, Miraculous Ladybug, Love Death + Robots, Hazbin Hotel, Big Mouth, Given, Stars Align, Sarazanmai, Carole & Tuesday, & Fruits Basket.

The results are in for our 2019 OVA-ies TV Animation Awards! After 645 votes cast, the winners in seven categories have been determined. Listen to the attached podcast to hear us announce the winners and analyze the results.

Steven Universe was the big winner of the night, taking home four of the seven awards, including the two biggest categories: Best Show and Best Episode. Infinity Train also had a big night with wins for Best New Show and Best Main Character for Tulip. She-Ra and the Princesses of Power won Best Supporting Character for Scorpia.

How the results were calculated: final placement was determined by an averaging of the percentages of the Open Vote and the Internal Vote of our patrons and staff, the latter of which was also weighed by number of shows watched in each category.

Best Animated Show of 2019

Winner: Steven Universe

Show Average% Open Vote Internal Steven Universe 38.27% 38.90% 37.63% She-Ra and the Princesses of Power 22.69% 22.80% 22.58% Tuca & Bertie 13.64% 4.70% 22.58% gen:LOCK 12.03% 9.00% 15.05% Infinity Train 8.03% 13.90% 2.15% BoJack Horseman 5.40% 10.80% 0.00%

Past winners: 2018-Steven Universe; 2017-Rick and Morty; 2016-Steven Universe

Best Animation Episode of 2019

Winner: “Change Your Mind”, Steven Universe

Episode Average% Open Vote Internal “Change Your Mind”, Steven Universe 37.74% 46.90% 28.57% “The Jelly Lakes”, Tuca & Bertie 20.90% 7.10% 34.69% “The Only Me I Know”, gen:LOCK 14.43% 10.50% 18.37% “121045” (Episode 1), The Promised Neverland 12.13% 11.00% 13.27% “Remember”, She-Ra and the Princesses of Power 9.95% 14.80% 5.10% “Cleaved”, Star vs. the Forces of Evil 4.85% 9.70% 0.00%

Past winners: 2018-“A Single Pale Rose”, Steven Universe; 2017-”Tales from the Citadel”, Rick and Morty; 2016-“Weirdmageddon 3: Take Back The Falls”, Gravity Falls

Best Animation Main Character of 2019

Winner: Tulip, Infinity Train

Character Average% Open Vote Internal Tulip, Infinity Train 28.05% 15.90% 40.21% Steven, Steven Universe 23.11% 28.70% 17.53% Marinette, Miraculous Ladybug 19.55% 25.70% 13.40% Bertie, Tuca & Bertie 13.31% 6.00% 20.62% Ruby, RWBY 11.31% 18.50% 4.12% Glimmer, She-Ra and the Princesses of Power 4.66% 5.20% 4.12%

Past winners: 2018-Marinette, Miraculous Ladybug; 2017-Star Butterfly, Star vs. the Forces of Evil; 2016-Pearl, Steven Universe

Best Animation Supporting Character of 2019

Winner: Scorpia, She-Ra and the Princesses of Power

Character Average% Open Vote Internal Scorpia, She-Ra and the Princesses of Power 41.65% 24.20% 59.09% Spinel, Steven Universe 22.71% 35.20% 10.23% Amaya, The Dragon Prince 12.20% 15.30% 9.09% Speckle, Tuca & Bertie 9.74% 4.70% 14.77% Venomous, OK K.O.! Let’s Be Heroes 8.66% 10.50% 6.82% One-One, Infinity Train 5.05% 10.10% 0.00%

Past winners: 2018-Lotor, Voltron: Legendary Defender; 2017-Diana Cavendish, Little Witch Academia; 2016-Peridot, Steven Universe

Best New Animated Show of 2019

Winner: Infinity Train

Show Average% Open Vote Internal Infinity Train 32.28% 40.20% 24.36% Tuca & Bertie 18.13% 11.90% 24.36% gen:LOCK 17.77% 16.30% 19.23% Carmen Sandiego 11.01% 15.60% 6.41% The Promised Neverland 10.99% 13.00% 8.97% Undone 9.83% 3.00% 16.67%

Past winners: 2018-She-Ra and the Princesses of Power

Best Visuals for an Animated Show of 2019

Winner: Steven Universe

Show Average% Open Vote Internal Steven Universe 27.14% 35.30% 18.99% Undone 19.95% 3.20% 36.71% Carmen Sandiego 17.81% 14.10% 21.52% Love, Death + Robots 12.15% 12.90% 11.39% Hazbin Hotel 11.91% 17.50% 6.33% RWBY 11.08% 17.10% 5.06%

Past winners: 2017-Little Witch Academia & Samurai Jack

Best Music for an Animated Show of 2019

Winner: Steven Universe

Show Average% Open Vote Internal Steven Universe 44.37% 50.80% 37.93% RWBY 20.92% 22.30% 19.54% Carole & Tuesday 11.65% 7.20% 16.09% The Promised Neverland 8.67% 4.70% 12.64% Infinity Train 8.30% 7.40% 9.20% Hazbin Hotel 6.10% 7.60% 4.60%

Here are the nominees for the 2019 OVA-ies Awards, celebrating the best in television animation from the year. Listen to the nominations announcement podcast accompanying this post and check out the nominations below!

Vote for your favorites in 7 categories. Winners are chosen 50% by an open vote, 50% from our internal community of patrons & staff weighed by shows watched. Nominees were chosen internally by our patrons & staff, and you can see the nominations below! Winners will be revealed in a podcast at the end of December.

Steven Universe leads with 6 nominations, one in every category it was eligible for. Followed by Tuca & Bertie and Infinity Train with 5 nominations, and She-Ra and the Princesses of Power with 4 nominations. gen:LOCK, The Promised Neverland, and RWBY had 3 nominations each.

Vote Here Now!

Voting closes at noon on Sunday December 29th. Google sign-in is required for voting. Voting is anonymous, the sign-in is just required to restrict voting to 1 per person.

Best Animated Show of 2019

• BoJack Horseman
• gen:LOCK
• Infinity Train
• She-Ra and the Princesses of Power
• Steven Universe
• Tuca & Bertie

Best Animation Episode of 2019

• “121045” (Episode 1), The Promised Neverland
• “Change Your Mind”, Steven Universe
• “Cleaved”, Star vs. the Forces of Evil
• “The Jelly Lakes”, Tuca & Bertie
• “The Only Me I Know”, gen:LOCK
• “Remember”, She-Ra and the Princesses of Power

Best Animation Main Character of 2019

• Bertie, Tuca & Bertie
• Glimmer, She-Ra and the Princesses of Power
• Marinette, Miraculous Ladybug
• Ruby, RWBY
• Steven, Steven Universe
• Tulip, Infinity Train

Best Animation Supporting Character of 2019

• Amaya, The Dragon Prince
• One-One, Infinity Train
• Scorpia, She-Ra and the Princesses of Power
• Speckle, Tuca & Bertie
• Spinel, Steven Universe
• Venomous, OK K.O.! Let’s Be Heroes

Best New Animated Show of 2019

• Carmen Sandiego
• gen:LOCK
• Infinity Train
• The Promised Neverland
• Tuca & Bertie
• Undone

Best Visuals for an Animated Show of 2019

• Carmen Sandiego
• Hazbin Hotel
• Love, Death + Robots
• RWBY
• Steven Universe
• Undone

Best Music for an Animated Show of 2019

• Carole & Tuesday
• Hazbin Hotel
• Infinity Train
• The Promised Neverland
• RWBY
• Steven Universe

Alex Bonilla talks with Brian H. Kim, lead composer on Disney’s Star vs. The Forces of Evil about his work on the show, the deeper meanings behind the musical choices made during the program’s run, and what he’s learned along the way.

Here’s some selected moments from the interview, which you can listen to in full below.

Condensed and edited for clarity

As someone who has been very involved with the show for its entire run, how does it feel to see the last piece of your work go public?

It’s really bittersweet. I started working on the show five years ago, and it was the first time a television show had hired me as the lead composer on a show, and it wasn’t just my first show, it was on Disney, which for me was a big deal. I’d grown up watching Disney cartoons, and as an adult watching stuff like Gravity Falls, thinking what a cool place it’d be to work. So to see the show go through so much and develop such a huge, passionate fanbase, and see the show’s evolution over the seasons, to see that all come to a close, it’s really happy for me because I’m glad what we made, and glad that the public gets to see what we made, but I’m sad. It’s weird to not have this show to work on. Each episode takes me two to three weeks to do, so that’s a year-round gig. So, when I was done working on the show, it was literally the first time in five years I could wake up that morning and not think about what I had to do on the show that day. That was so weird.

In general, how would you describe the responsibilities of the lead composer of the show?

When I first started on the show, there was a lot of discussion about what the show was going to sound like. It took a few episodes for me to lock it down, but a lot of it was meeting with Daron [Nefcy], Dominic [Bisignano] and Aaron [Hammersley], the three producers I worked with the most, having lunch, talking about things, sending me MP3s and playlists to get a feel for what clicked, and then taking all those things they sent me and try to mush them all into one sound.

Once that got laid down, the episode-to-episode duties are… I go in when the edit of the episode is done—I’m one of the last people to see it—I sit down with Daron and very often Dominic and Aaron as well, we watch the whole episode and we talk about every scene, where we want the music to come in and out. They obviously have their ideas of what they want, but they were always interested in hearing what I thought as well. I take all those notes, I go home and I work for a couple of weeks and I write all the music that I can, I finish the episode, I bring it in. We meet again, we sit down and watch the episode again with all the music in it, they take notes, we discuss, I go home and revise, I send for final mix and Daron gives final approval.

In regards to character themes, how do you deal with character shifts in their music? How do you tweak the themes as we learn more about the character?

Moon’s a really good example for that. When I wrote her theme in Season 2, I didn’t know where she was going in following seasons. I knew a handful of facts about her: I knew she was going to have a sad backstory, which we got into in The Battle For Mewni, and I knew her relationship with Star was her core relationship on the show. And I knew she was a badass; the first time I used her theme was when she was suiting up in armor, so I knew there was a fighter element to her. I didn’t know morally where she was going to be later. But because the things I knew about her were conflicting, I wrote a melody that was kind of conflicting. It switches from major to minor a lot, and at will I can change the chord progression. So later when things get fishier with her, I was thankful I made a melody that was somewhat ambiguous.

Have fan reactions ever affected decisions you made in scoring later episodes, knowing how fans have reacted to certain moments in the past?

It mattered more when I would get a scene I knew fans would have a large reaction to. For example, when Star and Tom have that big dance, I knew it was going to make waves and people would have strong opinions about it. Because I knew that, I spent a little extra time on that cue making sure it was big and grand and something that, even if you disagreed with the pairing, you would still feel empathetic towards them because of the music, because it was this big, sweeping romantic thing. In the fourth season, “Curse of the Blood Moon”, I get to reuse the Blood Moon Waltz in its entirety, and I knew that was going to be another moment the fans were going to react to, so I made sure the cue could stand on its own.

There are two big musical cues in the series finale: when the magic dimension is collapsing, and the final moments when Star and Marco are running towards the portals. What did you want the music to transmit in those scenes?

When the magic dimension is about to explode, and Star and Marco are holding each other not knowing what’s going to happen… that music starts a few minutes before when Marco asks Star, “What’s the plan?” and Star does not want to admit there isn’t a plan. I knew that I didn’t need to make this cue sound like the rest of the show. A lot of times I would shy away from using traditional string orchestration, I wanted to make sure we stayed in that retro synth world. But this felt different than the rest of the show. This felt apocalyptic, end-of-the-world stuff where we don’t know for sure if the heroes are going to come out OK. It needed to feel bleak, like this could be the end of everything. Instead of going big, I reduced everything to strings and piano. It moves slowly and builds slowly, as the audience realizes what Star is doing. Until the very end, when she sees Marco and they sit with each other, that’s when I begin to let it crescendo and swell all the way to the cut to black. With that one, I was happy to let it be its own thing without direct relation to other cues in the show.

Now, when they’re running to the portals, I did want that to sound like the rest of the show, but I wanted a cue that had some finality to it. I have this repeating string figure that I use through it. I wanted a central string to push it from start to finish, to give the cue momentum. It had to be fast and flexible based on what was going on the screen. It starts in minor key, and I knew I was going to switch to major at some point. I knew I wanted it to feel like a big heroic moment for these two characters we’ve been with for years. I wanted it to have some suspense, so I don’t switch until halfway through the cue, I think when she’s bursting through the corn, and you go, “Oh! This is that thing that happens at the end of big romantic movies!” This is endgame, this is what we’ve been leading up to all these years.

Now that Star is over, what’s the biggest thing that you’ve gotten out of this experience that’s helped you in other jobs?

I’m not as afraid. When I first got the show and was handed these reins, I hadn’t written so much for one project before. At the end of Season 4, I tallied all the music I’d written for Star. I’ve written between 20 and 21 hours of music for the show. Before I moved to Los Angeles, I think I’d only written 40 minutes of music in my entire life. Looking back, having worked with all these themes and manipulating them over the years, if given that task again, I will have this knowledge that I did that before, that I had a project I wrote every note for and feel very proud of at the end. Most of the work I’ve gotten since Star has been nothing like Star; I’ve done a ton of comedy work, indie films, documentaries. Each time I do one of those projects, it feels like a testing ground. The job should never be rote, it should never feel repetitive, it should never feel really easy. So when I’m brought on to a new project, my portfolio is diverse and I’m happy about that. I never feel like when I’m hired for something, I’m getting hired to do the same thing over and over.

I said to a producer on my last day, “I look forward to looking back fondly on all of this.” It was a very magical experience for me, it was a lovely job. It’s definitely going to be something I’ll miss.

 

Listen to the full interview with Brian H. Kim on the Overly Animated Podcast!

 

Dylan Hysen, Michelle Anderer, Alex Bonilla, & Sam Quattro recap the Star vs. the Forces of Evil series finale, “Cleaved”.

Dylan Hysen, Delaney Stovall, April Collins, & Andy Potter give their reactions to the Star vs. the Forces of Evil series finale, “Cleaved”.

Dylan Hysen, April Collins, Michelle Anderer, & Andy Potter recap the May 12th episodes of Star vs. the Forces of Evil, “The Right Way”, “Here to Help”, “Pizza Party”, & “The Tavern at the End of the Multiverse”.