God Finally Shows His Face: Chuck Returns in Supernatural's "Don't Call Me Shurley"

In this eye-opening episode of Gank That Drank, hosts Krissy Lenz and Nate McWhortor dive deep into one of Supernatural's most pivotal episodes - Season 11, Episode 20, "Don't Call Me Shurley." This game-changing installment finally confirms what fans had long suspected: Chuck is God, and he's been hiding in plain sight all along.

The episode masterfully balances two parallel storylines. While Sam and Dean deal with a mysterious fog that's turning people violent in Hope Springs, Idaho, the real meat of the episode takes place in a bar where Chuck/God summons Metatron to edit his autobiography. Through their intense discussions, we get unprecedented insight into God's relationship with creation, humanity, and his sister Amara.

Rob Benedict delivers one of his finest performances as Chuck/God, particularly during a confrontation where Metatron calls him a coward for abandoning his creation. The episode culminates in a powerful moment where Chuck performs "Fare Thee Well" (Dink's Song), leading to Dean's amulet glowing and confirming his divine identity.

Key Topics Covered:

• The drinking game rules: Pop culture references, black veins, Amara mentions, fog appearances, and Chuck solos
• Metatron's transformation from antagonist to humanity's advocate
• Chuck's revelation about his relationship with Amara and why he created the universe
• The parallel between Chuck's autobiography and the show's writers commenting on their own work
• The return of Dean's amulet and its significance
• Discussion of the episode's deeper themes about facing one's demons and the importance of fighting for creation

Krissy and Nate's entertaining commentary and drinking game format make this complex episode more accessible while highlighting its significance to the series' overall mythology. As they note, this episode marks a turning point in Supernatural's narrative, setting up Chuck's eventual transformation from savior to villain in later seasons.

Whether you're a longtime fan or new to the series, this episode of Gank That Drank offers invaluable insights into one of Supernatural's most crucial moments. Join them for their next episode as they travel back in time to Season 1's "Provenance."

---
Learn more about supporting this podcast by becoming a member. It's just $5/month or $55/year. Visit our website to learn more.

Join Krissy and Nate as they tackle Supernatural's Season 9 Episode 15 "#THINMAN," where the infamous Ghost Facers make their final appearance in the series. This monster-of-the-week episode takes a dark turn when what seems like a supernatural entity turns out to be something far more sinister – human killers exploiting internet folklore.

The episode follows Sam and Dean investigating a mysterious death where a teenage girl is killed after capturing a creepy figure known as "The Thin Man" in her selfie. Their investigation leads them to cross paths with Ed and Harry of the Ghost Facers, who are desperately trying to prove the Thin Man's existence. As tensions rise between the Winchester brothers over past betrayals, a parallel story unfolds as Ed's own betrayal of Harry comes to light.

The true horror of the episode emerges when the Thin Man is revealed to be two local men – a deputy and a waiter – who are killing people for revenge and internet fame. In a poignant conclusion, Harry leaves the Ghost Facers behind after learning of Ed's manipulation, marking the end of an era for these beloved recurring characters.

Other topics covered:

• The hosts' drinking game rules, including taking drinks for Ghost Facers mentions, pop culture references, and every time someone says "Thin Man"
• A record-breaking 43 mentions of "Thin Man" throughout the episode
• The real-world location of Springdale, Washington, and its connection to the episode's setting
• Sam and Dean's touching childhood memory about jumping off a shed dressed as Batman and Superman
• Discussion of the episode's commentary on internet fame and viral content
• The parallel relationship struggles between Sam/Dean and Ed/Harry
• A breakdown of the various supernatural creatures initially suspected before revealing human killer

Whether you're a long-time Supernatural fan or just love a good drinking game podcast, this episode delivers plenty of laughs, scares, and surprisingly emotional moments as we bid farewell to the Ghost Facers team. Don't forget to follow Krissy and Nate at the Neighborhood Comedy Theater in Mesa, Arizona, and catch their other podcast content on True Story FM.

---
Learn more about supporting this podcast by becoming a member. It's just $5/month or $55/year. Visit our website to learn more.

Join hosts Krissy Lenz and Nate McWhorter as they dive deep into one of Supernatural's most emotional episodes – the Season 5 finale "Swan Song." Originally written as a potential series finale, this episode brings the apocalyptic showdown between Michael and Lucifer to its dramatic conclusion.

The hosts break down how Chuck's narration frames the entire episode through nostalgic reflections about the Impala, setting up what was intended to be the show's final chapter. They discuss Sam's sacrificial plan to say "yes" to Lucifer and trap him in the cage, despite Dean's initial reluctance. The emotional weight of Dean finally accepting his brother's choice leads to some of the series' most powerful moments.

The climactic scene in Stull Cemetery delivers on five seasons of buildup, with Jensen Ackles giving a devastating performance as Dean refuses to give up on reaching Sam, even as Lucifer (in Sam's body) beats him nearly to death. The hosts analyze how the sight of the toy soldier stuck in the Impala's ashtray becomes the key to Sam regaining control, proving the profound importance of the brothers' shared history.

Key Topics Covered:

• Chuck's role as narrator and mounting evidence that he may be God
• The significance of Detroit as the prophesied location for Sam to say "yes"
• Castiel's memorable "Hey assbutt!" moment before Molotov-ing Michael
• The powerful montage of Sam's memories that allows him to overcome Lucifer
• Analysis of the bittersweet ending with Dean attempting a normal life
• Discussion of how the episode works both as a series and season finale
• The drinking game rules and tallies for the episode

The hosts close by reflecting on how "Swan Song" serves as a love letter to fans while leaving just enough of an opening for the story to continue—which it did for another 10 seasons. Whether viewed as a season or series finale, this episode stands as one of Supernatural's finest hours, perfectly balancing action, emotion, and the core theme of family that defined the series.

Remember to catch Krissy and Nate performing live at the Neighborhood Comedy Theater in Mesa, Arizona, and don't miss their upcoming Savvy Fest Improv Festival this coming Valentine's Day weekend!

---
Learn more about supporting this podcast by becoming a member. It's just $5/month or $55/year. Visit our website to learn more.

Join Krissy and Nate as they dive deep into the wild world of Supernatural's "Tall Tales" - an episode that's part X-Files homage, part supernatural shenanigans, and 100% drinking game excitement! This fan-favorite season 2 episode features a trickster, multiple unreliable narrators, and enough crazy scenarios to keep you on the edge of your seat (and potentially your barstool).

The episode centers around a series of bizarre incidents that seem too weird even for the Winchester brothers. From a professor's ghostly romantic encounter to an alien abduction and an alligator attack, Sam and Dean investigate a campus haunted by increasingly strange events. The unique storytelling approach mimics the classic X-Files episode "Bad Blood," with each character presenting their own dramatically different version of events.

The highlight of the episode is the introduction of the Trickster (later revealed to be the archangel Gabriel), played by Richard Speight Jr. His electric chemistry with Dean and knack for supernatural pranks makes for some of the most memorable moments in the series. The hosts discuss how this character became so popular that the writers likely planned to expand his role from the very beginning.

Drinking Game Highlights:

• 7 "bitch" and "jerk" mentions
• 3 character deaths
• Multiple research scenes
• Alien slow dance sequence
• 7 "angry BM" (bromance) scenes

Key Moments:

• Dean and Sam's competing narratives
• The Trickster's elaborate supernatural pranks
• References to Busty Asian Beauties website
• Foreshadowing of Gabriel's true identity

Whether you're a die-hard Supernatural fan or just love a good supernatural comedy, this episode recap will have you laughing, drinking, and appreciating the show's unique blend of humor and horror. Gank that drink and enjoy the ride!

---
Learn more about supporting this podcast by becoming a member. It's just $5/month or $55/year. Visit our website to learn more.

Welcome back to Gank That Drank, the ultimate Supernatural drinking game podcast! Hosts Krissy Lenz and Nate McWhortor are diving into Season 5, Episode 4, “The End,” one of the most iconic episodes of Supernatural. Packed with apocalyptic visions, angelic scheming, and Sexy Satan Sam in a striking white suit, this episode delivers unforgettable drama and plenty of drinking opportunities. Grab your drink and join us for a hilarious and insightful ride through this post-apocalyptic masterpiece.

Key Points:

Apocalyptic Shenanigans:
Dean is zapped five years into a bleak 2014 future by Zachariah, where the Croatoan virus has ravaged the world, and Lucifer (in Sam's body) reigns supreme. The bleak vision of Dean 2014—hardened, ruthless, and desperate—sets the stage for a powerful exploration of loyalty, choices, and resilience. Dean 2009's struggle with this grim reality is a haunting reminder of what’s at stake.

Drinking Game Highlights:
With hilarious and spot-on rules, this episode’s drinking game keeps fans engaged. Whether it's taking a sip when someone says “gank” or downing a shot for Sexy Satan Sam's white suit, the drinking rules turn this intense episode into a fun, participatory experience.

Castiel, The Love Guru:
Hippie Castiel steals the spotlight with his chilled-out, orgy-planning, life-coaching persona. This version of Cas is a far cry from his usual stoic angel self, offering comic relief and poignant commentary on hope and despair in a world falling apart.

Dean-on-Dean Dynamics:
The tense and revealing exchanges between Dean 2009 and his future self, Dean 2014, highlight the emotional core of the episode. Jensen Ackles delivers an incredible dual performance, showcasing Dean’s fears, flaws, and determination to carve a better path forward.

Other Topics Covered:

• The unforgettable Sexy Satan Sam in his iconic white suit.
• Hilarious Easter eggs like “Route 666” on the apocalyptic marquee.
• Zachariah’s persuasive yet diabolical mind games.
• Chuck’s omniscient warning to hoard toilet paper—eerily prescient!
• The poignant lesson about brotherly reconciliation and the importance of staying united in the face of chaos.

Krissy and Nate wrap up with a preview of the next featured episode, Season 2, Episode 15 - “Tall Tales,” promising more drinking rules, fun, and laughs. Don’t miss the antics as the hosts break down alien slow dances, urban legends, and plenty of sibling squabbles.

For exclusive early access and ad-free episodes, become a member at TruStory.FM. And as always, keep the Gank That Drank mantra in mind: Be excellent to each other and party on, dudes!

Cheers to saving people, hunting things, and enjoying the family business—one drink at a time!

---
Learn more about supporting this podcast by becoming a member. It's just $5/month or $55/year. Visit our website to learn more.

Join hosts Krissy Lenz and Nate McWhortor as they dive into Supernatural Season 9, Episode 13 "The Purge" - where fat-sucking monsters, competitive eating, and the beloved introduction of Sheriff Donna Hanscom combine for a delightfully gross adventure. Grab your favorite beverage and play along with their drinking game rules while the Winchester brothers investigate mysterious weight loss deaths at a health spa.

In this episode, Sam and Dean go undercover at Canyon Valley spa after a series of bizarre deaths where victims' fat is mysteriously sucked from their bodies. Dean finds himself relegated to cafeteria duty (complete with hairnet) while Sam leads questionably long yoga classes. The investigation introduces fans to the unforgettable Sheriff Donna Hanscom, whose first appearance showcases her signature "you betcha" charm and reveals the painful story of her ex-husband Doug.

The case leads to the discovery of Maritza, a Pishtaco (Peruvian fat sucker) running the spa with her murderous brother Alonzo. While Maritza uses her abilities to help willing clients lose weight, Alonzo's uncontrollable hunger leads to multiple deaths. The episode culminates in a tense moral debate between the brothers about whether non-violent monsters deserve to live, adding another layer to their ongoing family drama.

Key Topics Covered:

• First appearance of fan-favorite Sheriff Donna Hanscom
• Competitive eating culture and sabotage
• Pishtacos: Peruvian fat-sucking monsters
• Undercover work at Canyon Valley spa
• Dean's pudding addiction
• The ethics of letting non-violent monsters live
• Continuing tension between Sam and Dean
• Sam's shocking admission about not saving Dean

The episode concludes with one of the series' most gut-punching brother moments, as Sam tells Dean he wouldn't have saved him if their roles were reversed - a harsh statement that perfectly encapsulates the growing rift between the Winchesters. 

Don't forget to check out True Story FM to become a member and get early, ad-free access to future episodes plus exclusive bonus content.

---
Learn more about supporting this podcast by becoming a member. It's just $5/month or $55/year. Visit our website to learn more.

Dive into the apocalyptic premiere of Supernatural Season 5 with Gank That Drink hosts Krissy Lenz and Nate McWhortor as they break down "Sympathy for the Devil," an episode packed with game-changing revelations, angelic interventions, and demonic double-crosses.

The episode picks up right where Season 4 left off, with Sam and Dean mysteriously transported to an airplane just as Lucifer is released. As the world descends into chaos, we're introduced to Mark Pellegrino's Nick - Lucifer's temporary vessel - through a series of haunting visions. Meanwhile, fan-favorite character Becky makes her debut as Chuck's messenger, leading the Winchester brothers on a crucial quest for the Michael Sword.

The hosts dissect the complex relationship between Sam and Dean, particularly examining Dean's struggle to trust his brother after the events that triggered the apocalypse. They also explore the fascinating dynamic between Zachariah (Kurt Fuller) and Castiel, whose dramatic return suggests divine intervention - potentially from God himself.

Key Topics Covered:

• Introduction of Lucifer's vessel Nick and his tragic backstory
• First appearance of super-fan Becky Rosen
• Castiel's mysterious resurrection and new powers
• Bobby's possession and near-fatal encounter with demons
• The return of Meg, now played by Rachel Minor
• Zachariah's revelation about Dean being Michael's true vessel
• The deteriorating trust between the Winchester brothers

The episode's drinking game featured rules including "ouchy noises," pop culture references, Castiel mentions, Dean's outbursts, world reports, Becky's swooning, and creepy devil visions - making for an entertaining accompaniment to this pivotal episode.

Join Krissy and Nate next time as they tackle Season 9, Episode 13, "The Purge," featuring the first appearance of fan-favorite character Donna and promises plenty of drinking opportunities with rules centered around family mentions, fat-sucking, and Donna-isms.

Remember to catch their live performances at the Neighborhood Comedy Theater in downtown Mesa, Arizona, and support the podcast through their membership program for early, ad-free episodes and exclusive content.

---
Learn more about supporting this podcast by becoming a member. It's just $5/month or $55/year. Visit our website to learn more.

Get ready to take flight with Gank That Drank as we dive into Supernatural's Season 1, Episode 4: "Phantom Traveler"! Join hosts Krissy Lenz and Nate McWhortor as they unpack this early gem that laid the groundwork for the entire series. Buckle up for a thrilling ride through demon possessions, plane crashes, and the Winchester brothers' first encounter with the supernatural at 30,000 feet!

This episode serves as a roadmap for the entire show, introducing key elements that would become Supernatural staples. From the boys' first fake Homeland Security badges to Dean's iconic fear of flying, "Phantom Traveler" sets the stage for many recurring themes. The hosts discuss how this episode, nearly 19 years old, feels both nostalgic and pivotal in establishing the show's mythology.

Krissy and Nate break down the episode's significance in introducing demons to the Supernatural universe. They highlight how Sam and Dean's lack of knowledge about demons at this point makes for an intriguing and sometimes humorous viewing experience. The hosts also dive into the episode's use of EVP (Electronic Voice Phenomenon) and EMF (Electromagnetic Frequency) detection, elements that would become staples in the Winchesters' hunting toolkit.

The show notes wrap up with a detailed breakdown of the drinking game rules for this episode, including demon smoke appearances, black eyes sightings, and mentions of the brothers' father. Krissy and Nate compare their drink tallies, offering listeners a fun way to engage with the rewatch.

Other topics covered in this episode include:

• The introduction of sulfur as a sign of demonic presence
• Dean's makeshift EMF detector crafted from a Walkman
• The boys' first time buying suits for a case
• The episode's biblical references, including the significance of the number 40
• Early character development for Sam and Dean, including their distinctively higher-pitched voices
• The one-time use of "Christo" to identify demons
• Jerry's character and his connection to John Winchester
• The episode's cliffhanger ending with John's voicemail

Tune in to Gank That Drank for a nostalgic trip down Supernatural memory lane, complete with drinking game rules that'll have you raising a glass to the Winchesters' early adventures. Whether you're a long-time fan or new to the series, this podcast offers a fresh, entertaining perspective on the episode that helped shape Supernatural into the beloved show it became. Don't miss out on this deep dive into "Phantom Traveler" – it's a flight you won't want to miss!

---
Learn more about supporting this podcast by becoming a member. It's just $5/month or $55/year. Visit our website to learn more.

"Lucifer Rising": The Epic Supernatural Season 4 Finale That Changed Everything

Get ready for a thrilling ride as Krissy Lenz and Nate McWhortor dive deep into Supernatural's game-changing Season 4 finale, "Lucifer Rising." This episode of Gank That Drank takes you on a wild journey through one of the most pivotal moments in the series, complete with demon blood, angelic deception, and the rise of the Devil himself.

Sam and Dean Winchester face their greatest challenge yet as the apocalypse looms. With Sam spiraling down a dark path fueled by demon blood and manipulated by Ruby, Dean finds himself trapped in a heavenly waiting room, desperately trying to stop his brother from making a catastrophic mistake. The episode expertly weaves together multiple storylines, building tension to an explosive climax that sets the stage for an epic fifth season.

Our hosts break down the intricate plot, dissecting key moments like Zachariah's villainous reveal, Castiel's crisis of faith, and Ruby's masterful long con. They explore the moral dilemmas faced by the characters and the consequences of their choices, all while enjoying a drink (or several) with their ingenious set of rules for this unforgettable episode.
Key points covered:

• Sam's descent into darkness and his fateful confrontation with Lilith
• Dean's struggle against angelic manipulation and his attempt to save his brother
• The true nature of the final seal and Lilith's role in Lucifer's rise
• Ruby's ultimate betrayal and her chilling "bond villain" speech
• Chuck's mysterious role and the questions surrounding his true identity

Other topics discussed:

• Yellow Eyes' 1972 flashback and Lucifer's instructions
• Bobby's colorful insults and confrontation with Dean
• The ethical dilemma of Sam drinking demon blood from an innocent host
• Castiel's journey towards rebellion and team free will
• The effectiveness of the drinking game rules for this action-packed episode

As the dust settles and Lucifer begins to emerge, Krissy and Nate reflect on the impact of this game-changing finale and its place in Supernatural lore. Whether you're a die-hard fan or new to the series, this episode of Gank That Drank offers a fresh, entertaining perspective on a classic Supernatural moment. So grab a drink, settle in, and join the hosts as they navigate the twists, turns, and copious amounts of alcohol in "Lucifer Rising."

---
Learn more about supporting this podcast by becoming a member. It's just $5/month or $55/year. Visit our website to learn more.

Join Krissy Lenz and Nate McWhortor as they tackle Season 5, Episode 7 of Supernatural in their hilarious drinking game podcast. "The Curious Case of Dean Winchester" serves up a thrilling blend of suspense, humor, and unexpected twists that will keep you on the edge of your seat – and maybe reaching for your drink!

In this episode, our hosts dive deep into a high-stakes poker game where the currency isn't money, but years of life. When Bobby loses 25 years to a mysterious player, Dean steps in to win them back, only to find himself rapidly aging into his golden years. The episode brilliantly showcases Jensen Ackles' versatility as he portrays an elderly Dean, bringing both comedy and poignancy to the character's predicament.

Krissy and Nate break down the episode's clever premise, discussing how it plays with the themes of mortality and sacrifice that run throughout Supernatural. They highlight the stellar performance of Chad Everett as Old Dean, praising his ability to capture Dean's essence while adding the perfect touch of grumpy old man charm.

The hosts also explore the episode's emotional core, touching on Bobby's struggle with feeling useless and Dean's heartfelt reassurance of Bobby's importance to their makeshift family. This moment adds depth to the characters' relationships and reinforces the show's central theme of family bonds.

Other topics covered in this laughter-filled recap include:

• The introduction of Patrick, the charming Irish witch with a penchant for high-stakes gambling
• Sam's unexpected poker skills and his climactic face-off with Patrick
• The witty banter and old man jokes that pepper the episode
• The touching backstory of Patrick and his witch companion
• Dean's hilarious attempts to adjust to life as a senior citizen

Tune in to hear Krissy and Nate's drinking game rules for this episode, including takes for rapid aging, witch-related terminology, and of course, the classic "Sammy" rule. Whether you're a die-hard Supernatural fan or new to the series, this episode of Gank That Drank offers a fresh, entertaining perspective on a beloved show.

So grab your salt, your silver, and your favorite beverage, and join Krissy and Nate for a supernaturally good time with "The Curious Case of Dean Winchester"!

---
Learn more about supporting this podcast by becoming a member. It's just $5/month or $55/year. Visit our website to learn more.

Grab your salt and holy water, because Krissy Lenz and Nate McWhortor are diving deep into Supernatural's meta madness! In this episode of Gank That Drank, our hosts tackle Season 4, Episode 18, "The Monster at the End of This Book" – a game-changing installment that introduces the enigmatic Chuck Shurley and turns the Winchester brothers' world upside down.

Krissy and Nate unpack the mind-bending revelation that Sam and Dean's lives have been chronicled in a series of pulp novels. They explore the hilarious meta-commentary on fandom, including Sam and Dean's reactions to slash fiction and their own rabid fanbase. The hosts dissect Chuck's role as a "prophet" and debate whether the writers always intended for him to be more than he seems.

The episode's exploration of free will versus destiny takes center stage as Sam and Dean struggle against Chuck's prophetic visions. Our hosts discuss the tension between the brothers as they grapple with Sam's demon blood addiction and Dean's mistrust. The showdown with Lilith and the tantalizing hints about the impending apocalypse set the stage for the season finale.

Other topics covered:

• The brilliant fourth-wall-breaking moments and Easter eggs
• Chuck's "Vonnegut" writing style and literary references
• Castiel's revelation about prophets and archangel protection
• The mysterious final scene with Zachariah
• Drinking game rules and their effectiveness for this episode

From comic book store shenanigans to cosmic stakes, "The Monster at the End of This Book" delivers laughs and thrills in equal measure. Krissy and Nate's witty banter and insightful analysis make this episode of Gank That Drank a must-listen for any Supernatural fan. So pour yourself a drink, settle in, and join the hunt as we unravel the mysteries of Chuck, prophecy, and the Winchesters' destiny. Don't forget to tune in next time as our hosts tackle another classic Supernatural episode – same demon-hunting time, same demon-hunting channel!

---
Learn more about supporting this podcast by becoming a member. It's just $5/month or $55/year. Visit our website to learn more.