During a recent Fox News interview, Vice President J.D. Vance cited “an old school and very Christian concept” to justify rejecting refugees and ending international aid. Bishops from his own church disagreed. The Holy Post crew explores the concept Vance was citing, how he misunderstands it, and why his interpretation undermines the entire New Testament. Kaitlyn interviews Skye about his new book, “What If Jesus Was Serious About Justice?” They talk about the link between justice and worship, what it means to have a heart “far from God,” and why the doctrine of penal substitutionary atonement is biblical but taught in a proudly unbiblical way in many churches. Also this week, Phil returns to Twitter and learns who Margaret is.
Holy Post Plus:
Bonus Interview with Skye Jethani:
https://www.patreon.com/posts/121522392/edit
0:00 - Sponsor - Bushnell University - Equip yourself to be transformative in your community! Go to https://www.bushnell.edu
0:49 - Show Starts
3:20 - Theme Song
3:42 - Sponsor - Faithful Counseling - This episode is sponsored by Faithful Counseling. Give online therapy a try at https://www.faithfulcounseling.com/HOLYPOST and get 10% off
4:45 - Sponsor - AG1 - Heavily researched, thoroughly purity-tested, and filled with stuff you need. Go to https://www.drinkag1.com/HOLYPOST
6:09 - Inauguration
7:27 - Tariff Fight!
12:03 - Twitter’s a Dirty Aquarium
17:29 - Who’s Margaret and Should She Care?
20:52 - The American Council of Bishops
24:22 - Augustine and Ordo Amoris
31:56 - Scripture and Ordo Amoris
37:36 - Case for Christian Nationalism
43:23 - The Resurrection Disrupts Politics
48:22 - Sponsor - Blueland - Get up to 25% off your first order by going to https://www.Blueland.com/HOLYPOST
49:28 - Sponsor - Pique - Pique’s tea is a superfood in a cup! Comes with a frother and glass beaker—get the starter kit at https://piquelife.com/HOLYPOST
51:08 - Interview
53:05 - Justice and Social Justice
1:01:10 - Oppression Beyond Identity
1:09:55 - God’s Justice and Mercy
1:14:42 - Penal Substitutionary Atonement
1:22:45 - End Credits
Links Mentioned in News Segment:
JD Vance is Wrong: Jesus doesn’t ask us to rank our love for others:
Other resources:
What if Jesus Was Serious About Justice by Skye Jethani: https://a.co/d/gFydI1K
Holy Post website: https://www.holypost.com/
Holy Post Plus: www.holypost.com/plus
Holy Post Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/holypost
Holy Post Merch Store: https://www.holypost.com/shop
The Holy Post is supported by our listeners. We may earn affiliate commissions through links listed here. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying
purchases.
David French brings us his thoughts on why the GOP is no longer the party of the Constitution. Have political party allegiances broken the system? What Constitutional guard rails can operate when people are worried about falling out of the President’s favor? Then, he talks about Carl Schmitt, a German political thinker who may have the key to understanding the difference between the politics we’re used to—and the emerging politics of the New Right.
David French’s article on Schmittian politics:
https://www.nytimes.com/2025/01/26/opinion/trump-maga-schmitt.html
0:00 - Theme Song
0:17 - Show Begins
2:11 - Tiktok—banned or not?
8:10 - Does Trump obey the Supreme Court?
15:30 - Resistant Bacteria Analogy
24:26 - Senators Following the People
27:29 - Political Parties as Checks
34:45 - The Gingrich-Clinton Wars
41:28 - Schmitt and MAGA Morality
53:15 - The Moment for Courage
1:04:52 - End Credits
The first week of the second Trump administration has seen refugees cut off and January 6th criminals cut loose. Franklin Graham declared in his inauguration prayer that God himself had chosen the President. The MAGA faithful applauded this mix of Christian faith and politics, but when Bishop Budde asked the President to “show mercy” to frightened people during her homily at the National Cathedral, she was accused of everything from political activism to witchcraft. Phil has a theory about what these two religious leaders at the inauguration reveal about the state of American Christianity. Then Matthew Soerens from World Relief is back to discuss Trump’s immediate shut down of all refugee resettlement, including cutting all financial aid previously promised to refugees already in the U.S. What’s behind the President’s aggressive policy, and how can we practically help our neighbors abandoned by the government that brought them here? Also this week—reanimated squirrels and Skye wears a red hat.
0:00 - Show Starts
4:14 - Theme Song
4:36 - Sponsor - Go to https://www.fromourplace.com and use code HOLYPOST to get 10% off site wide on beautiful cookware!
5:42 - Sponsor - Faithful Counseling - This episode is sponsored by Faithful Counseling. Give online therapy a try at https://www.faithfulcounseling.com/HOLYPOST and get 10% off
10:54 - Inauguration
20:57 - The Demonization of Empathy
27:08 - Loyalty Buys Protection
32:26 - Cruelty as Proof of Allegiance
39:30 - Created Order vs. the Marginalized
59:07 - Sponsor - Sundays Dog Food - Get 40% off your first order of Sundays. Go to https://www.SundaysForDogs.com/HOLYPOST or use code HOLYPOST at checkout.
1:00:08 - Sponsor - The NIV Lectio Bible - A simple, ancient way to read the library of scripture. Find it at https://www.nivlectio.com or wherever Bibles are sold!
1:01:17 - Sponsor - J29 Coalition - Guide your church into a Christ-centered approach to politics! Visit https://j29coalition.com to sign up today
1:02:24 - Interview
1:05:50 - The Refugee Resettlement Program
1:09:44 - We Invited Refugees
1:15:22 - What Options to Help Refugees
1:21:45 - Helping Local Immigrant Communities
1:28:10 - End Credits
Links Mentioned in News Segment:
Evangelicals Made a Bad Trade:
https://www.theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2025/01/evangelicals-trump/681450/
Collision of Two Christianities:
Other resources:
Learn how recent executive orders are having a devastating impact on thousands of refugees and humanitarian programs both in the U.S. and globally, and find out how you can help make a difference!
Partner with World Relief: https://give.worldrelief.org/site/Donation2?df_id=5541&5541.donation=form1&mfc_pref=T&utm_source=HolyPost&utm_medium=ShowNotes&utm_campaign=EO_UrgentAppeal
Sign the Christian Statement on Refugee Resettlement: https://worldrelief.org/christianstatement/
Easy tool to contact Congress with talking points: https://p2a.co/AEQhezU
Access This Toolkit to Get Involved: https://worldrelief.org/content/uploads/2025/01/World-Relief-Toolkit.pdf
Holy Post website: https://www.holypost.com/
Holy Post Plus: www.holypost.com/plus
Holy Post Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/holypost
Holy Post Merch Store: https://www.holypost.com/shop
The Holy Post is supported by our listeners. We may earn affiliate commissions through links listed here. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.
According to New York Times columnist, David Brooks, our society has given up on moral formation to focus instead on individual success and happiness. Can we recover a culture of shared virtue? Surprising new data shows that overall college enrollment is down, but Christian colleges and universities are growing. What’s the explanation? Then Robert P. Jones, from PRRI, is back to unpack the numbers from the presidential election. Why did more Latinos support Trump, and are Democrats learning the wrong lessons from their loss? Also this week—animals hold grudges.
List of Ways to Contribute:
https://www.holypost.com/post/ways-to-contribute-to-la-fire-relief
Holy Post Plus:
Getting Schooled - Communion 201
https://www.patreon.com/posts/120202366/
0:00 - Show Starts
3:17 - Theme Song
3:40 - Sponsor - Glorify - Sign up for the #1 Christian Daily Devotional App to help you stay focused on God. Go to https://glorify-app.com/en/HOLYPOST to download the app today!
4:43 - Sponsor - Rocket Money - Find and cancel your old subscriptions with Rocket Money at https://www.rocketmoney.com/holypost
5:50 - The Inauguration
8:30 - Connecting to Relief Work
12:05 - Ants’ Tiny Grudges
17:30 - Character Building Toolkit
24:28 - Morally Fragmented World
39:21 - Christian College Growth
44:52 - Sponsor - J29 Coalition - Guide your church into a Christ-centered approach to politics! Visit https://j29coalition.com to sign up today
45:58 - Sponsor - AG1 - Heavily researched, thoroughly purity-tested, and filled with stuff you need. Go to https://www.drinkag1.com/HOLYPOST
47:15 - Interview
48:50 - Lack of Change
57:01 - Don’t Overread
1:12:44 - Fatigue
1:17:38 - Pray for Wisdom
1:21:40 - End Credits
Links Mentioned in News Segment:
World Relief:
https://worldrelief.org/advocate/
Christian Colleges Continue to See Enrollment Growth:
Biologists Antagonised Ants:
Other resources:
The Hidden Roots of White Supremacy: and the Path to a Shared American Future by Robert P. Jones: https://a.co/d/5ZoIHOp
White Too Long: The Legacy of White Supremacy in American Christianity by Robert P. Jones: https://a.co/d/0K5cI5W
Robert P. Jones’ Substack: www.whitetoolong.net
Holy Post website: https://www.holypost.com/
Holy Post Plus: www.holypost.com/plus
Holy Post Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/holypost
Holy Post Merch Store: https://www.holypost.com/shop
The Holy Post is supported by our listeners. We may earn affiliate commissions through links listed here. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying
purchases.
How can we help those impacted by the L.A. wildfires? Because of A.I., climate change, and falling fertility rates, Ezra Klein says we are living “in the age of monsters,” but is he really just upset about Trump? And how is technology fundamentally rewiring our brains to avoid social interaction, and what should we do about it? Phil, Kaitlyn, and Skye offer their suggestions. Then Kaitlyn talks with Wheaton College theology professor Emily McGowin about her new book, “Households of Faith,” and what it means to think of our families formationally rather than formulaically. Also this week—the new Holy Post studio is killer!
0:00 - Show Starts
2:16 - Theme Song
2:38 - Sponsor - AG1 - Heavily researched, thoroughly purity-tested, and filled with stuff you need. Go to https://www.drinkag1.com/HOLYPOST
3:56 - Sponsor - Learn from some of the world’s most brilliant minds with this 10-day event at Calvin! Go to https://www.calvin.edu/JANUARY
7:57 - California Wildfires
15:22 - The Time of the Monsters
25:11 - The Time for Churches
31:25 - The Anti-Social Century
39:12 - Tiktok and Lonely Routines
45:25 - Bring Back Youth Group!
51:14 - Sponsor - Faithful Counseling - This episode is sponsored by Faithful Counseling. Give online therapy a try at https://www.faithfulcounseling.com/HOLYPOST and get 10% off
52:16 - Sponsor - Pique - Pique’s tea is a superfood in a cup! Comes with a frother and glass beaker—get the starter kit at https://piquelife.com/HOLYPOST
53:53 - Sponsor - J29 Coalition - Guide your church into a Christ-centered approach to politics! Visit https://j29coalition.com to sign up today
55:00 - Interview
56:42 - Why Write About Family?
1:00:40 - Discernment and Improvisation
1:08:04 - Family of God
1:16:05 - Sabbath for Fellowship
1:22:31 - Rhythms of Life
1:29:30 - End Credits
Households of Faith: Practicing Family in the Kingdom of God by Emily Hunter McGowin: https://a.co/d/7hd5XIW
Links Mentioned in News Segment:
Ezra Klein’s “Now is the Time of the Monsters:”
https://www.nytimes.com/2025/01/12/opinion/ai-climate-change-low-birth-rates.html
The Anti-Social Century:
Other resources:
Holy Post website: https://www.holypost.com/
Holy Post Plus: www.holypost.com/plus
Holy Post Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/holypost
Holy Post Merch Store: https://www.holypost.com/shop
The Holy Post is supported by our listeners. We may earn affiliate commissions through links listed here. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.
Former president and born again Christian, Jimmy Carter, died at the age of 100. As the media reflects on his legacy of public service and humanitarianism, some are contrasting Carter’s faith with that of conservative white evangelicals. Esau McCaulley says Carter is being used as a cudgel by progressives to shame their political opponents. Is he right? Skye and Phil unpack two explanations for the country’s rejection of President Carter for Ronald Reagan in 1980. Was Carter too liberal or too humble? Then, pastor and Holy Post Pundit, Gabriel Salguero, is back to talk about a second Trump administration’s plan to deport millions of undocumented immigrants, and how Christians and church leaders should hope for the best but prepare for the worst. Also this week—Phil wants to do a telethon for turtles.
Holy Post Plus
Getting Schooled - Heresy 101:
https://www.patreon.com/posts/119252265/
0:00 - Show Starts
3:51 - Theme Song
4:12 - Sponsor - Sundays Dog Food - Get 40% off your first order of Sundays. Go to https://www.SundaysForDogs.com/HOLYPOST or use code HOLYPOST at checkout
5:15 - Sponsor - Hiya Health - Go to www.hiyahealth.com/HOLYPOST to receive 50% off your first order
6:54 - News of the Bubble Butt Turtles
16:15 - Jimmy Carter’s Legacy
23:36 - Is Carter Popular for Being a Progressive Evangelical?
30:36 - Carter, Mr. Rogers, and Pope Francis
49:42 - Sponsor - Wheaton - Go to www.wheaton.edu/communicatingchrist to learn more about the Doctor of Ministry program at the Wheaton College grad school
50:46 - Sponsor - Faithful Counseling - This episode is sponsored by Faithful Counseling. Give online therapy a try at https://www.faithfulcounseling.com/HOLYPOST and get 10% off
51:53 - Interview
59:24 - The Ambiguity of the Trump Administration
1:11:46 - Developing a Pastoral Response
1:22:03 - Signs of Mass Deportation
1:28:18 - End Credits
Links Mentioned in News Segment:
Sea Turtle Bubble Butt 3D Printing:
https://www.npr.org/2024/12/28/nx-s1-5238294/sea-turtle-bubble-butt
Jimmy Carter Embodied the “Road Not Taken” by Many White Evangelical Christians:
https://www.cnn.com/2024/12/31/us/jimmy-carter-evangelical-christians-cec?cid=ios_app
Jimmy Carter’s Life Should Make Christian Right Feel Ashamed:
https://www.thedailybeast.com/jimmy-carter-represented-christianity-in-politics-at-its-best/
Other resources:
Holy Post website: https://www.holypost.com/
Holy Post Plus: www.holypost.com/plus
Holy Post Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/holypost
Holy Post Merch Store: https://www.holypost.com/shop
The Holy Post is supported by our listeners. We may earn affiliate commissions through links listed here. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.
Happy new year! We’re starting 2025 by answering questions from the Holy Post audience. You’ve asked us about movies and shows we are looking forward to this year, and what regrets we have about things we’ve said in the past. Phil explains his fashion choices, Skye explains why he’s still a conservative, and Kaitlyn has an idea for replacing “News of the Butt.” Plus, will there be enough room for everyone in the new heavens and earth?
0:00 - Show Starts
2:57 - Theme Song
3:18 - Sponsor - Rocket Money - Find and cancel your old subscriptions with Rocket Money at https://www.rocketmoney.com/holypost
4:26 - Blueland - Get up to 25% off your first order by going to https://www.Blueland.com/HOLYPOST
5:33 - Sponsor - AG1 - Heavily researched, thoroughly purity-tested, and filled with stuff you need. Go to https://www.drinkag1.com/HOLYPOST
8:20 - Skye's FBI Hat
11:42 - Public Statement Regrets
18:50 - News of the Butt Replacement?
22:01 - Movies and Shows Coming Out in 2025
26:15 - Loving Your Enemies When They're Hurting Others
35:37 - Holy Post: Liberal or Conservative?
47:35 - What Should Phil Wear?
52:44 - Not a Political Talk Podcast
1:03:57 - How to Fit All the People in Heaven
1:10:09 - End Credits
Other resources:
Holy Post website: https://www.holypost.com/
Holy Post Plus: www.holypost.com/plus
Holy Post Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/holypost
Holy Post Merch Store: https://www.holypost.com/shop
The Holy Post is supported by our listeners. We may earn affiliate commissions through links listed here. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.
The MeToo movement was a huge cultural movement—but now, many major government leaders with sexual abuse scandals under their belt seem to go under the radar—how did we get to this point? And what about the aftermath of the ChurchToo movement? David and Skye discuss this, as well as a case in the Supreme Court about Tennessee’s ban on transgender medical intervention for kids.
0:00 - Theme Song
0:17 - Show Begins
7:19 - MeToo as a Christian Ethic
12:34 - False Safety in Christian Subculture
22:48 - The Bad Patterns in the Aftermath
28:45 - Bon on Transgender Medical Intervention for Kids
35:14 - Rational Basis Example
44:45 - Tattoos and Parental Consent
52:09 - David’s Prediction on the Court Ruling
58:15 - Looking Forward to Superman
1:06:23 - End Credits
Other resources:
Holy Post website: https://www.holypost.com/
Holy Post Plus: www.holypost.com/plus
Holy Post Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/holypost
Holy Post Merch Store: https://www.holypost.com/shop
The Holy Post is supported by our listeners. We may earn affiliate commissions through links listed here. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.
Merry Christmas! In celebrity conversion news, Denzel Washington got baptized at his church in Harlem just days before his 70th birthday and became a licensed minister, and New York Times columnist, David Brooks, has written about his surprising journey from agnosticism to Christianity. What do these stories tell us about our culture’s ongoing hunger for God? On the other side, David French explains why some Christians now think cruelty is acceptable. New Testament scholar, Nijay Gupta, is back to talk about what the Gospels actually say about Jesus’ birth, and what our Christmas pageants get right and very wrong about the story. Also this week—an airport in New Zealand bans hugs longer than three minutes
Sponsor - Logos Bible Study App: If you want to simplify your study and go deeper into Scripture, visit www.logos.com/holypost. You can get started for free with an exclusive extended 2-month free trial.
Sponsor - Hiya Health - Go to www.hiyahealth.com/HOLYPOST to receive 50% off your first order
Sponsor - Faithful Counseling - This episode is sponsored by Faithful Counseling. Give online therapy a try at https://www.faithfulcounseling.com/HOLYPOST and get 10% off
Links Mentioned in the News Segment
Is this airport’s 3-minute limit on goodbye hugs ‘inhumane’? https://www.euronews.com/travel/2024/10/22/max-hug-time-three-minutes-new-zealand-airport-goes-viral-for-limiting-goodbyes#:~:text=Three%20minutes%20was%20%22plenty%20of,and%20serotonin%2C%20De%20Bono%20said
Denzel Washington Gets Baptized and Becomes a Minister During Live Streamed Ceremony: 'It Took a While but I'm Here' https://people.com/denzel-washington-gets-baptized-and-becomes-minister-during-live-streamed-ceremony-8765639
Opinion | The Shock of Faith: It’s Nothing Like I Thought It Would Be https://www.nytimes.com/2024/12/19/opinion/faith-god-christianity.html
A Catholic bishop, with a social media following second only to the Pope, is proving that dumbing down the faith is the wrong way to reach young adults. But is his celebrity status getting in the way? A new study finds the most generous people are also the most likely to consistently read the Bible. Kaitlyn talks to Pricelis Perreaux-Dominguez about telling the truth to the church out of love. Her new book, “Being a Sanctuary,” is honest about the harms many churches are causing, but also shows how the church is the key to healing. Also this week—rat race cars in Froot Loop land.
Holy Post Plus
Hills to Die On:
https://www.patreon.com/posts/118157091/
0:00 - Intro
1:19 - Show Starts
2:42 - Theme Song
3:03 - Sponsor - Aura Frames - Exclusive $45-off Carver Matte at https://www.AuraFrames.com. Use code HOLYPOST at checkout to save!
4:06- Sponsor - Blueland - Get up to 25% off your first order by going to https://www.Blueland.com/HOLYPOST
5:16 - Skye’s Dead Salmon Hat
8:15 - Rats Driving Little Cars!
12:50 - Rats Love Driving Little Cars!
21:26 - Bible-Readers Donate More?
25:38 - Are Bible-Readers More Communal?
37:50 - Father Robert Barron
48:33- Sponsor - Glorify - Sign up for the #1 Christian Daily Devotional App to help you stay focused on God. Go to https://glorify-app.com/en/HOLYPOST to download the app today!
49:36 - Sponsor - AG1 - Heavily researched, thoroughly purity-tested, and filled with stuff you need. Go to https://www.drinkag1.com/HOLYPOST
50:55 - Interview
53:32 - Why Did She Write Being a Sanctuary?
56:38 - The Starbucks Church Model
1:03:25 - Disagreeing Within the Church
1:13:05 - Approaching Looking for a New Church
1:24:20 - End Credits
Links Mentioned in the News Segment:
Bishop Robert Barron:
https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2024/12/bishop-robert-barron-catholic-church/680953/
Rats Driving Little Cars!
Christians Who Read Bible Are More Charitable:
Other resources:
Being a Sanctuary: The Radical Way for the Body of Christ to Be Sacred, Soft, and Safe by Pricelis Perreaux-Dominguez: https://a.co/d/eQy7IEh
Holy Post website: https://www.holypost.com/
Holy Post Plus: www.holypost.com/plus
Holy Post Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/holypost
Holy Post Merch Store: https://www.holypost.com/shop
The Holy Post is supported by our listeners. We may earn affiliate commissions through links listed here. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.
More Americans than ever are single but they’re not happy about it. A new article in The Atlantic examines how the sexes are drifting apart, why more men are looking for a partner than women, and the side-effects of using an app rather than community to find a date. Then, political scientist Hahrie Han’s new book “Undivided” explores why the racial solidarity program at an evangelical megachurch was more successful than corporate DEI programs, and how that success created unexpected challenges for the predominantly white church. Also this week: the Swiss make an A.I. Jesus, and a Chicago school kid makes a medical breakthrough.
Holy Post Plus
Bonus Interview:
https://www.patreon.com/posts/117695861/
0:00 - Intro
1:08 - Show Starts
2:47 - Theme Song
3:09 - Sponsor - Sundays Dog Food - Get 40% off your first order of Sundays. Go to https://www.SundaysForDogs.com/HOLYPOST or use code HOLYPOST at checkout.
4:13 - Sponsor - Hiya Health - Go to www.hiyahealth.com/HOLYPOST to receive 50% off your first order
5:21 - Listener Shirt Sent In
9:26 - News of the Butt
12:46 - AI Jesus Confessional
16:04 - Why Not an AI Priest?
21:46 - Are People Dating Anymore?
27:17 - Men’s Delayed Adulthood
34:45 - The Church as Family
51:42 - Sponsor - Glorify - Sign up for the #1 Christian Daily Devotional App to help you stay focused on God. Go to https://glorify-app.com/en/holypost to download the app today!
52:47 - Sponsor - Aura Frames - Exclusive $45-off Carver Matte at https://www.AuraFrames.com. Use code HOLYPOST at checkout to save!
53:53 - Sponsor - Go to https://www.fromourplace.com and use code HOLYPOST to get 10% off site wide on beautiful cookware!
54:58 - Interview
58:00 - Why Write About the Undivided Program?
1:09:06 - What Problems Did Undivided’s Success Cause?
1:18:23 - Jesus and “Being Apolitical”
1:29:13 - End Credits
Links Mentioned in the News Segment:
Swiss ‘AI Jesus’ https://cbn.com/news/world/swiss-church-sets-ai-jesus-confessional-booth-critics-cry-blasphemous
The Death of America Romance
Other resources:
Undivided: The Quest for Racial Solidarity in an American Church by Hahrie Han: https://a.co/d/4k8R6z5
Holy Post website: https://www.holypost.com/
Holy Post Plus: www.holypost.com/plus
Holy Post Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/holypost
Holy Post Merch Store: https://www.holypost.com/shop
The Holy Post is supported by our listeners. We may earn affiliate commissions through links listed here. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying
purchases.
Your feedback is valuable to us. Should you encounter any bugs, glitches, lack of functionality or other problems, please email us on [email protected] or join Moon.FM Telegram Group where you can talk directly to the dev team who are happy to answer any queries.