- 48 minutes 18 secondsDo we need to change the MVP conversation around Shohei Ohtani? | Brewers sweep Cubs, Tarik Skubal trade outlook, Tony Gwynn Jr. joins the show
On today's episode, Buster Olney and David Schoenfield break down the Brewers surge and the Cubs fall, discuss if Tarik Skubal could be traded midseason, why the Astros decade of dominance is over, and if Shohei Ohtani is the favorite in the NL Cy Young award race.
Tony Gwynn Jr. then joins us to discuss the Padres-Dodgers recent series; is it the best rivalry in baseball? Plus Mason Miller's dominance and why the MVP conversation around Ohtani is feeling like it did around Michael Jordan.
Sarah Langs tells us why Ohtani, Sal Stewart, and Jacob Misiorowski are doing things that we haven't seen in 50+ years, and Todd Radom gives us his 3 most underrated ballparks.
0:00 Intro + Welcome
2:13 Dave Schoenfield joins the show
2:56 Brewers sweep Cubs
5:53 Could Tarik Skubal be traded?
8:40 Cal Ripken Jr. to return as Orioles President?
11:19 Royals could be sellers at the trade deadline
13:19 Astros decade of dominance appears over
16:15 Ohtani's Cy Young case
17:30 J.P. Crawford willing to move to Third Base
19:35 Sarah Langs plays the numbers game
20:58 Tony Gwynn Jr joins the show
22:54 What did we learn from Padres-Dodgers series?
25:48 Why Manny Machado is in a slump
27:08 Mason Miller should be a Cy Young and MVP candidate
29:02 Sandy Alcantara should be a Padres trade target
30:28 Ohtani's MVP conversation feels like it did with MJ
34:13 Tony Gwynn Sr's feelings towards the Dodgers
35:01 Todd Radom's most underrated parks in baseball
41:57 Bleacher Tweets
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
22 May 2026, 4:33 pm - 49 minutes 26 secondsWhy the NL is so much better than the AL, Yankees bullpen issues | Mariners exec Jerry Dipoto
Welcome back to the Baseball Tonight podcast! Hembo joins us to talk about the National League's dominance over the American League, the Mets youth movement, Brice Turang stating claim to the best 2nd baseman in baseball, the Yankees bullpen issues, and the Giants historically low walk percentage.
Then Mariners President of Baseball Operations Jerry DiPoto joins to discuss top prospect Colt Emerson's booming big league arrival, Julio Rodriguez's early-season success, why Cal Raleigh is struggling, and his approach to the trade deadline.
0:00 - Intro + last night
1:37 - Hembo joins the show
2:30 - National League's dominance over the American League
6:18 - Mets youth movement
10:37 - Brice Turang, best 2nd baseman in baseball?
13:10 - What's wrong with the Yankees bullpen?
18:30 - The Giants are taking walks at a historically low percentage
22:07 - Is Cam Schlittler running away with the AL Cy Young?
24:41 - Mariners exec Jerry Dipoto joins the show
25:00 - Rookie Colt Emerson's big week
29:46 - State of the Mariners season so far
31:48 - Julio Rodriguez's best start to a season of his career
35:00 - Cal Raleigh's struggles
37:26 - Trade deadline outlook
43:41 - Bleacher Tweets (Phillies, Yankees)
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
20 May 2026, 5:02 pm - 33 minutes 52 secondsBrewers Cy Young hopeful Jacob Misiorowski joins the show + Tim Kurkjian on the White Sox, Phillies, and more
Jacob Misiorowski joins the show to talk about his lights-out performance against the Yankees, the first time he hit 100 mph, his unique relationship with manager Pat Murphy, and more. Then Tim Kurkjian stops by to discuss why hope prevails for the ailing Tigers (and the rest of the AL), the white hot White Sox, the loaded NL Cy Young Race, the Phillies surge, and the best baseball story of the week in St. Louis.
0:00 Intro and welcome
0:41 Weekend Headlines: Phillies, Dodgers, Padres, and White Sox
2:27 Jacob Misiorowski joins the show
2:40 Misiorowski's dominance vs the Yankees
4:10 The Origin Story
5:09 First time hitting 100 mph
6:14 Opposing hitters reactions
7:00 Konnor Griffin question for Misiorowski
9:19 How much do you study other pitchers?
11:40 What makes the Brewers so good?
12:21 Unique relationship with Pat Murphy
13:28 Tim Kurkjian joins, Tigers in trouble
15:38 American League is wide open
19:03 White Sox are white hot
22:20 National League Cy Young Race is loaded
26:45 Phillies are surging
27:47 Cardinals "Tarps Off" fans were best thing this weekend
30:38 Thanks for watching
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
18 May 2026, 6:15 pm - 47 minutes 58 secondsThe loaded NL Cy Young Race + White Sox GM Chris Getz
Welcome back to the Baseball Tonight podcast! Jorge Castillo joins the show to discuss the loaded NL Cy Young Race between Shohei Ohtani, Paul Skenes, Jacob Misiorowski, and a 4th pitcher who might be the best of all. Buster and Jorge then break down which players on the Mets, Red Sox, and Astros could be dealt at the trade deadline, and finish by discussing what Anthony Volpe should do to keep himself on the Yankees Roster.
White Sox GM Chris Getz then joins as we go inside Chicago's rebuild into an early-season playoff contender. He shares what makes the clubhouse so special and what Munetaka Murakami and Colson Montgomery are doing to power their success. Plus, will we see the Pope throw out a first pitch?
We finish the show with Sarah Langs and Bleacher Tweets!
0:00 Intro
0:36 Welcome Jorge Castillo
1:23 NL Cy Young Race: Skenes, Misiorowski, Ohtani
8:04 Mason Miller for MVP?
9:31 Trade Deadline candidates
14:20 Anthony Volpe's recent comments
18:07 White Sox GM Chris Getz joins
20:00 What makes the clubhouse so special?
23:21 Munetaka Murakami has silenced doubters
26:37 Colson Montgomery is finding his groove
31:30 White Sox strategy for 1st pick in MLB draft
32:49 The Pope throwing out the first pitch?
34:55 2024 season reflection
39:25 Sarah Langs plays the numbers game
41:03 Bleacher Tweets: Brewers + Home Runs
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
15 May 2026, 10:00 am - 46 minutes 51 secondsWhy so many superstars are struggling + Konnor Griffin joins the show
Welcome back to the Baseball Tonight Podcast! Pirates rookie shortstop Konnor Griffin joins the show to discuss his adjustment to life in the Big Leagues, the toughest pitchers he's faced, and his favorite ballparks he's played in so far. Hembo then swings by to share why several stars, including Shohei Ohtani, Cal Raleigh, and Vladimir Guerrero Jr. are struggling. Then injury expert Stephania Bell goes in-depth on Tarik Skubal's surgery. We end with Bleacher Tweets about the Orioles and Padres!
0:00 Intro + Top of the First
2:21 Konnor Griffin Joins
2:48 Griffin's favorite MLB ballparks
4:46 Adjusting to MLB travel
5:58 Best pitchers Griffin has faced
7:22 First time being asked for an autograph
8:16 Paul Skenes' dominance
9:46 State of the Pirates
11:57 Players Griffin is looking forward to meeting
12:55 Griffin's first purchase after signing contract
13:53 Hembo joins the show
14:27 Konnor Griffin's improvement
18:26 Struggling Superstars: Ohtani, Guerrero Jr., Raleigh, Tatis Jr., Henderson
31:00 Stephania Bell breaks down Tarik Skubal's surgery
41:06 Bleacher Tweets: Orioles and Padres
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
13 May 2026, 3:08 pm - 47 minutes 18 secondsNEW DETAILS about Tarik Skubal's surgery that could be "life-changing" for the game of baseball
Welcome back to the Baseball Tonight podcast, publishing a day early because of breaking news surrounding Tigers pitcher Tarik Skubal. His agent, Scott Boras, joined us to give us the details surrounding this first-time surgical procedure on an MLB player that could cut Skubal's recovery time in half. He also shares his memories about the late Bobby Cox.
ESPN's Jesse Rogers then hops on to discuss the surprising reason for the Cubs early-season success, and who they could target at the trade deadline. We then switch to the AL where he tells us which playoff-favorite teams he's most concerned about. We finish the segment discussing some concerns about Boston's Chief Baseball Officer Craig Breslow.
Finally, Royals broadcaster Eric Hosmer joins us to react to the Skubal news from Boras and why it could be a life-changing for the game of baseball. He then also shares his AL teams he's most concerned about. We finish with the state of sign-stealing in today's game.
We end the show with Bleacher Tweets and Buster's memories about Bobby Cox.
0:00 Welcome
0:57 Scott Boars joins
1:31 Details on Skubal's surgery
4:27 Skubal's new timeline for returning to baseball
5:52 Update on Skubal post-surgery
6:22 Why Skubal can return much quicker than expected
7:25 Nerves for a new surgery?
8:32 How this surgery might impact Skubal's free agency
9:15 Bobby Cox memories
11:21 Jesse Rogers on the Cubs success
13:25 How Pete Crow-Armstrong is taking control
15:37 Cubs potential trade-deadline targets
18:27 Concern: Orioles, Red Sox, Mariners, Tigers, Blue Jays, Royals
22:07 Questions about Craig Breslow
26:51 Eric Hosmer joins the show
28:01 Reaction to Skubal surgery news
31:21 Concern: Orioles, Red Sox, Mariners, Tigers, Blue Jays, Royals
33:25 Trouble in Detroit
34:47 Royals are on the rise
35:52 Sign-Stealing discussion
40:28 Bleacher Tweets: Andy Pages + Cubs
42:57 Remembering Bobby Cox
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
10 May 2026, 9:16 pm - 44 minutes 50 secondsWhy the Braves aren't getting too excited + Yankees rotation getting stronger, Favorite John Sterling memories
Welcome back to the Baseball Tonight Podcast! Braves GM Alex Anthopoulos joins us to detail why he's not getting too excited yet about the Braves best start since 1998, how Matt Olson is getting even better, and his reaction to 62-year-old manager Walt Weiss' tackle during last month's brawl. Yankees fan Rich Eisen then stops by to talk about his favorite John Sterling memories, the time he creeped out Don Mattingly, and how scary the Yankees rotation can be with Carlos Rodon and Gerrit Cole on the way back. Plus Sarah Langs and Todd Radom!
0:00 Welcome
0:37 Cubs are on fire
2:06 Braves GM Alex Anthopoulos joins the show
2:36 Atlanta's best start since 1998
3:51 Matt Olson can do it all
6:33 Reaction to Walt Weiss' tackle in brawl
9:41 Braves depth in face of injuries
11:13 Reflecting on the iconic David Price 2015 trade
16:09 Sarah Langs plays the Numbers Game
17:04 Rich Eisen joins the show
17:19 Favorite John Sterling memories
21:23 Rich's Yankee fandom origin story
23:27 Favorite Yankee players growing up
24:20 Awkward Don Mattingly story
28:33 Rodon and Cole coming back
29:50 Why the Yankees are so good this year
35:40 Todd Radom joins the show
36:20 Best bobblehead giveaways this year
38:44 Quiz time!
39:56 Bleacher Tweets: Mike Trout to the east coast?
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
8 May 2026, 12:49 pm - 38 minutes 12 secondsDid Framber Valdez plunk Trevor Story because he was upset at Boston stealing signs?
Benches cleared after Tigers pitcher Framber Valdez hit Red Sox batter Trevor Story on Tuesday. Valdez said it was not intentional, while Tigers manager A.J. Hinch said it was a "low moment" for the team. Speculation abounds that Valdez was upset about the Boston stealing signs, rather than the two home runs they hit before Story was beaned. Eduardo Perez joins to break it all down. Later on, Hembo hops on to discuss Matt Olson's hot streak, Rafael Devers slow start, and the rookie who is raking for the Cubs.
0:00 Welcome
0:41 Eduardo Perez joins
0:55 Framber Valdez fallout
3:01 How long should Valdez be suspended?
5:11 Tigers starting pitching injury crisis
6:39 Tarik Skubal out 2-3 months
9:02 Junior Caminero is must-watch
9:57 What is happening with the Giants?
12:09 Carlos Correa out for the season
13:00 Hembo joins the show
13:57 Rafael Devers struggles in San Francisco
18:35 Matt Olson, Hall of Fame bound?
22:30 Red Sox struggling at the plate
25:34 Moises Ballesteros on fire for the Cubs
30:15 Marlins middle infield swap
32:22 Congrats to the Schwinks
33:06 Bleacher Tweets
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
6 May 2026, 10:02 pm - 27 minutes 10 secondsHow superstar Elly De La Cruz has gotten even better | BBTN Pod
Reds Manager Terry Francona joins the show to discuss Elly De La Cruz's improvements this year, what has made rookie Sal Stewart so special early on, and why Boston is such a brutal place to leave as a manager. Then Hunter Pence swings by to talk about two Japanese "rookies" who are lighting up the big leagues: Munetaka Murakami with the White Sox and Kazuma Okamoto with the Blue Jays. He also discusses the biggest threat to the Dodgers' crown and why the Giants have struggled to start the year. We end by giving our tribute to the legendary broadcast, John Sterling.
0:00 Welcome
0:52 Yankees are surging
1:03 Braves have best record but lose Acuna
1:22 Twins SP Joe Ryan leaves with injury
1:38 Yankees option Anthony Volpe to AAA
2:03 Giants calling up Bryce Eldridge
2:24 Welcome Terry Francona
2:45 Elly De La Cruz is getting even better
6:00 What makes Sal Stewart so good
7:24 Hunter Greene injury update
8:07 NL Central is best division in baseball
9:02 Reacting to Alex Cora's firing, why is Boston so brutal?
12:27 Hunter Pence joins the show
12:52 Munetaka Murakami can't stop hitting HRs
15:02 Kazuma Okamoto has established a unique tradition
18:56 Who can challenge the Dodgers?
20:48 Giants early-season struggles
22:19 Taylor baby update!
23:13 Remembering John Sterling
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
4 May 2026, 7:56 pm - 46 minutes 40 secondsHow the Red Sox season just went from bad to worse
The Boston Red Sox received bad news with star pitcher Garrett Crochet headed to the IL, just a few days after firing manager Alex Cora. Buster Olney and Alden Gonzalez discuss the Red Sox fate this year. They also dive into the Dodgers tactic of benching Shohei Ohtani as a DH when he pitches; how the Atlanta Braves have the best record in baseball; and the resurgence of the Seattle Mariners. Blue Jays pitcher Kevin Gausman joins the show to discuss Toronto's season, and Sarah Langs plays the numbers game.
0:00 Welcome
1:23 Matt Olson Walks It Off
1:38 JJ Wetherholt HRs off Paul Skenes
1:54 Marlins take series from Dodgers
2:18 Mariners back to .500
2:28 Garrett Crochet to IL
2:39 Alden Gonzalez joins the show
3:10 Red Sox issues
10:44 Dodgers Organizational Success
15:16 Ohtani not batting when pitching
20:08 Braves best record in MLB
23:12 Mariners surging
26:28 Kevin Gausman joins the show
26:45 Gausman close to 2,000 career Ks
27:32 How Gausman unlocked his splitter
29:14 The Braves secret to boosting Gausman
31:30 Advice to younger players
33:05 Blue Jays clubhouse is tight-knit
35:32 How piano playing saved Max Scherzer's career
38:17 Calling pitches
41:22 Sarah Langs plays the numbers game
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
1 May 2026, 9:01 am - 26 minutes 35 secondsNeed Friction: Phillies Fire Manager Rob Thomson; Can Philadelphia save its season?
The Philadelphia Phillies have official fired manager Rob Thomson and named Don Mattingly the interim manager. Buster Olney and Paul "Hembo" Hembekides discussing Thomson's dismissal, why it should've happened after the 2025 postseason, the outlook on Mattingly at interim, where recently fired Alex Cora fits into this puzzle, and Buster's advice for Cora while he examines the landscape. Plus, panic or patience on the Dodgers' Kyle Tucker, Yordan Álvarez looking downright terrifying, Craig Stammen has the Padres humming, and the Brewers have unlocked Kyle Harrison. 0:00 Welcome 0:15 Hembo 0:30 Phillies fire Rob Thomson 8:06 Could Alex Cora take over in Philadelphia? 13:31 Dodgers Kyle Tucker 15:57 Astros Yordan Álvarez 18:29 Craig Stammen has Padres rolling 21:10 Brewers unlocked Kyle Harrison CALL THE SHOW: 406-404-8460 EMAIL THE SHOW: [email protected] REACH OUT ON X: #BLEACHERTWEETS Follow The Baseball Tonight Podcast on… YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLHeL6O-A-ASmSMwbSCFvPKEq1Cslo_lrw Spotify: https://open.spotify.com/show/5FG6xCcd338SgZjZ9urHRI Apple Podcasts: https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/baseball-tonight-with-buster-olney/id137699414
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
29 April 2026, 3:45 pm - More Episodes? Get the App