by Rob DiCristino
The votes are in! Well, mine are, at least.
Among my many blessings in 2024 — good health, happy family, gainful employment, correct Ben Affleck opinions — was my admission to the Critics Choice Association, a national body of critics, writers, and broadcasters whose awards have grown to become significant precursors to the Oscars in the years since the group’s inception in 1995. With the CCA announcing our official list of film nominees this past week, I thought it might be fun to compare my first ballot choices in a few of the major categories to the consensus contenders and walk through what I’m leaning toward for my final selections. Does that sound good? Is that okay? I mean, you’re here, aren’t you?
1. Best Actor
My Nominees: Adrien Brody (
The Brutalist) Aaron Pierre (
Rebel Ridge), and Josh Hartnett (
Trap).
CCA Nominees: Adrien Brody (
The Brutalist), Timothée Chalamet (
A Complete Unknown), Daniel Craig (
Queer), Colman Domingo (
Sing Sing), Ralph Fiennes (
Conclave), and Hugh Grant (
Heretic).
First of all, I like that the CCA asks its members to nominate only three candidates in most of these categories. On other ballots, I usually have to combine a few choices I actually feel excited about with a bunch I’m more half-hearted on (or feel pressure from other critics to nominate) just to get it up to five or ten. Anyway, I knew Aaron Pierre and Josh Hartnett were long shots (perhaps that’s why I nominated them in the first place), but hey, it’s great to see Hugh Grant’s Golden Globes momentum keeping up! He’s really fun in
Heretic, as is Daniel Craig in
Queer, but my vote’s likely going to Adrien Brody in
The Brutalist, a film that will probably need a full hype/backlash/Good Actually/re-backlash cycle after its release before we all recognize it — and Brody’s performance — as an American masterpiece.
2. Best Supporting Actor
My Nominees: Yura Borisov (
Anora), Guy Pearce (
The Brutalist), and Denzel Washington (
Gladiator II).
CCA Nominees: Yura Borisov (
Anora), Kieran Culkin (
A Real Pain), Clarence Maclin (
Sing Sing), Edward Norton (
A Complete Unknown), Guy Pearce (
The Brutalist), and Denzel Washington (
Gladiator II).
This is probably a good time for me to admit that I think
Sing Sing is just okay. It’s nicely made and boasts some engaging performances from professional and non-professional actors alike (including the charismatic Clarence Maclin as himself), but it’s cloying and manipulative and it takes easy dramatic shortcuts that undercut what should be compelling themes of isolation, renewal, and the transformative power of performance. It’s pretending at a lot more profundity than it executes, frankly, and I like it a lot less than I want to. With that said, my finalists are Yura Borisov and Guy Pearce, the latter of whom would be absolutely deserving of recognition this year for a lifetime of great work. Borisov is my boy, though, as his understated performance in
Anora might be my favorite of any kind in 2024.
3. Best Actress
My Nominees: Mikey Madison (
Anora), Marianne Jean-Baptiste (
Hard Truths), and Demi Moore (
The Substance).
CCA Nominees: Cynthia Erivo (
Wicked), Karla Sofía Gascón (
Emilia Pérez), Marianne Jean-Baptiste (
Hard Truths), Angelina Jolie (
Maria), Mikey Madison (
Anora), and Demi Moore (
The Substance).
Hell yeah, Demi Moore! I’m so excited to see
The Substance getting serious awards play, something I think a lot of us had convinced ourselves was impossible.
Emilia Pérez, on the other hand, is genuinely awful, and its presence in the conversation feels like a cultural overcorrection that we’ll look back on in a few years with more than a little discomfort. Let’s see: Cynthia Erivo does her best in
Wicked, for sure, but she’s too hamstrung by its incompetent execution to really merit consideration. Maybe that’s not fair to her? I can see that argument! But I digress. I’m going with Mikey Madison over Marianne Jean-Baptiste by a nose, I think, mostly because Madison gets a shade or two more to play with as
Anora. Marianne Jean-Baptiste is outstanding in
Hard Truths, though. Don’t miss that one.
4. Best Supporting Actress
My Nominees: Katy O’Brian (
Love Lies Bleeding), Michele Austin (
Hard Truths), and Natasha Lyonne (
His Three Daughters).
CCA Nominees: Danielle Deadwyler (
The Piano Lesson), Aunjanue Ellis-Taylor (
Nickel Boys), Ariana Grande (
Wicked), Margaret Qualley (
The Substance), Isabella Rossellini (
Conclave), and Zoe Saldaña (
Emilia Pérez).
This is the first category where I have to pivot, as none of my nominees made the cut. I was definitely surprised by how in on the joke Ariana Grande is in
Wicked, but despite
being bribed upwards of four figures to cast a vote in her favor, I can’t bring myself to sanction any of that movie’s buffoonery. Rossellini is a goddess, obviously, but let’s stop kidding ourselves about
Conclave. Qualley? Is there enough there? I like Aunjanue Ellis-Taylor well enough in
Nickel Boys (another movie I’m cooler on than others), but she’s a bit better in
Exhibiting Forgiveness. Do I hold that against her? Danielle Deadwyler may end up being my consolation vote, honestly, as she and Ray Fisher are bright spots in the otherwise underwhelming
Piano Lesson. I think it’s going to be a coin flip. Justice for Katy O’Brian!*
5. Best Young Actor/Actress (Under 21)
My Nominees: Nykiya Adams (
Bird), Lily Collias (
Good One), and Izaac Wang (
Didi).
CCA Nominees: Alyla Browne (
Furiosa: A Mad Max Saga), Elliott Heffernan (
Blitz), Maisy Stella (
My Old Ass), Izaac Wang (
Didi), Alisha Weir (
Abigail), and Zoe Ziegler (
Janet Planet).
I really like that this category is specifically “Under 21” instead of just “Breakthrough Performance,” which is a term that gets a bit too broad and subjective for my taste. This is another situation where I have to make a compromise, though, as
Good One was probably just not seen by enough critics to earn my top choice Lily Collias the recognition she deserves. I like seeing Alisha Weir get some heat for
Abigail (a good movie!), and Izaac Wang made my nomination ballot for a reason. But now I’m wondering if my affection for
Didi has more to do with my affection for early aughts internet culture than it does for its performances, whereas it’s Maisy Stella’s brilliant naturalism that really makes
My Old Ass sing as well as it does. I think I’m going to end up calling an audible and going with Stella.
6. Best Directing
My Nominees: Robert Eggers (
Nosferatu), Coralie Fargeat (
The Substance), and Rose Glass (
Love Lies Bleeding).
CCA Nominees: Jacques Audiard (
Emilia Pérez), Sean Baker (
Anora), Edward Berger (
Conclave), Brady Corbet (
The Brutalist), Jon M. Chu (
Wicked), Coralie Fargeat (
The Substance), RaMell Ross (
Nickel Boys), and Denis Villeneuve (
Dune: Part Two).
I’m about as heartbroken that Rose Glass didn’t make this cut as I am that Jon M. Chu did, but I’m starting to understand why awards bodies feel safe recognizing poorly-made but popular movies in nebulous categories like directing. Quality directing is much harder to quantify than quality acting, after all, and critics who claim otherwise are lying, deluding themselves, or both. Here’s my criteria: Is the tone consistent? Are scenes constructed creatively? Does the film linger on its strengths and whistle past its weaknesses? Is there a coherent vision? While the MOST directed film on this list is either
Nickel Boys — shot in a subjective style that works to its detriment — or
The Substance, I’m giving my vote to Denis Villenueve, whose
Dune films remain remarkable achievements born of a singular vision.
7. Best Comedy
My Nominees: Hundreds of Beavers, Kneecap, and
Kinds of Kindness.
CCA Nominees: A Real Pain, Deadpool & Wolverine, Hit Man, My Old Ass, Saturday Night, and
Thelma.
I don’t want to tip my hand when it comes to my favorite movies of the year, but I do want to recognize the inclusion of Best Comedy, which seems to nod to the Golden Globes’ genre-split Best Picture categories without compromising the integrity of a single, unified list of great films. Obviously, none of my choices made it —
Hundreds of Beavers being completely shut out is perhaps my biggest disappointment of this whole affair — but I’m happy to find a compromise between Richard Linklater’s
Hit Man and Josh Margolin’s
Thelma. While both are taught, inventive, and much smarter than anything else on this list,
Thelma holds together a bit better and features a glorious lead performance from all-star badass June Squibb. Her “electricity” bit still makes me laugh whenever I think about it.
See the full list of nominees here, and watch the 30th annual Critics Choice Awards on E! at 7 PM EST on Sunday, January 12th!
*You could argue that O’Brian is the co-lead of
Love Lies Bleeding, but since her principal role is to be a catalyst for K-Stew’s more story-propellant actions, I consider hers a supporting performance.