- 28 minutes 4 secondsRule 5 and an Introduction to Rule 6 – The Second Week Rules for the Discernment of Spirits w/ Fr. Timothy Gallagher – Discerning Hearts Podcast

Episode 10 – Rule 5 and introduction to Rule 6 – The Second Week Rules for the Discernment of Spirits
In this episode, Fr. Timothy Gallagher continues his exploration of St. Ignatius of Loyola’s Second Week Rules for the Discernment of Spirits, focusing on the subtle ways the enemy can lead a person away from God’s will under the appearance of good. Returning to the example of Kathy, a dedicated teacher discerning whether to remain at her suburban school or serve at an inner-city school, Fr. Gallagher examines how small changes in her patience, motivation, and spiritual disposition may reveal signs of diminishment. Through Kathy’s conversations with her spiritual director, Father Mark, listeners learn the importance of carefully observing the unfolding of thoughts and desires rather than making decisions based solely on an initial experience of spiritual consolation. Rule Five provides the criteria for recognizing whether a seemingly good inspiration is gradually leading toward a less fruitful spiritual outcome.
Fr. Gallagher then introduces Rule Six, which invites individuals to revisit the entire course of thoughts after recognizing the enemy’s deception. By prayerfully examining the beginning, middle, and end of a discernment experience, a person can identify the subtle steps that led away from the original movement of grace and become better prepared to recognize similar temptations in the future. Fr. Gallagher explains that being temporarily deceived carries no shame, particularly when someone sincerely desires to follow God’s will and seeks wise spiritual guidance. Through attentive prayer, reflection, and the assistance of a competent spiritual director, the faithful can grow in spiritual freedom, deepen their understanding of God’s movements in their lives, and become more confident in discerning His will.
Fifth Rule.
The fifth: We should give much attention to the course of the thoughts; and if the beginning, middle and end is all good, inclined to all good, it is a sign of the good angel; but if in the course of the thoughts that he brings, it ends in something bad, or distractive, or less good than the soul had proposed to do before, or if it weakens it, or disquiets, or troubles the soul, taking away the peace, tranquility and quiet, which it had before, it is a clear sign that it proceeds from the bad spirit, the enemy of our profit and eternal salvation.(333)
Sixth Rule
The sixth: When the enemy of human nature has been perceived and known by his serpent’s tail and the bad end to which he induces, it profits the person who was tempted by him, to look immediately at the course of the good thoughts that he brought, and the beginning of them, and how little by little he procured to make him descend from the sweetness and spiritual gladness in which he was, till he brought him to his depraved intention; so that with such an experience known and noted he may guard himself in the future from his customary deceits. (334)
Discerning Hearts Questions for Reflection and Study
Personal Reflection
- When have I experienced an initial sense of peace or enthusiasm about a decision that gradually changed as I continued to consider it?
- Am I attentive to subtle changes in my patience, charity, generosity, and willingness to serve others?
- Do I sometimes allow my personal preferences or desires to influence what I believe God is asking of me?
- How willing am I to remain faithful to my present responsibilities when another opportunity for service appears more appealing?
- Do I regularly bring important decisions before the Lord in prayer, asking for the grace to recognize His will rather than my own?
- How might the guidance of a wise spiritual director help me recognize movements of the heart that I cannot clearly see on my own?
- When I recognize that I have misunderstood a spiritual movement, do I respond with discouragement or with gratitude for the opportunity to learn?
- What past experiences of discernment could I prayerfully revisit to better understand how God has guided me?
- How can I develop a greater habit of examining the fruits of my thoughts and decisions over time?
- What would it mean for me to surrender my plans more completely to God, trusting that His will leads to the greatest spiritual fruitfulness?
Group Reflection or Study
- How does Kathy’s experience illustrate the subtle ways spiritual deception can develop even when a person sincerely desires to serve God?
- Why does St. Ignatius encourage careful attention to small changes in our thoughts, motivations, and spiritual dispositions?
- What is the difference between objective and subjective diminishment, and how might these signs appear in everyday decisions?
- How does Rule Five help us evaluate the direction and eventual outcome of thoughts that initially appear good and holy?
- What role does Father Mark play in helping Kathy recognize movements she might otherwise overlook?
- Why is it important to examine the beginning, middle, and end of a spiritual experience rather than focusing only on its initial consolation?
- How does Rule Six transform an experience of spiritual deception into an opportunity for greater wisdom and spiritual growth?
- Why does Fr. Gallagher explain that there is no shame in being temporarily deceived by the enemy under the appearance of good?
- How can journaling and reviewing past spiritual experiences strengthen our ability to discern God’s will?
- In what ways do the Second Week Rules help protect both our personal spiritual lives and the wider mission of the Church?
This series is based on Spiritual Consolation by Fr. Timothy Gallagher
You can find the book here
Also, here are the 2 handouts mentioned by Fr. Gallagher in Talk 2:
Guidance for a Greater Discernment of Spirits with Fr. Timothy Gallagher O.M.V.
For the PDF document:
Handout Number 1 – The Text of the 8 Rules of the Second Week
https://www.discerninghearts.com/Gallagher/The_Text_of_the_Rules.pdfHandout Number 2 – Examples – Discernment of Spirits – 2nd Week rules
https://www.discerninghearts.com/Gallagher/EXAMPLES-DISCERNMENT_OF_SPIRITS-SECOND_WEEK_RULES.pdfThrough a series of compelling conference talks, Fr. Gallagher carefully breaks open St. Ignatius of Loyola’s Second Week Rules for Greater Discernment. This set of 8 “rules” (or guidelines) helps us to discern whether a seemingly good, noble, holy idea or feeling, often understood as a “spiritual consolation,” could be a working of the enemy intending to lead us astray. He shows how all of us can learn to listen to and follow God’s gentle leading in our daily lives.
For more from Fr. Gallagher on Discerning Hearts:
The Discernment of Spirits: The First Week Rules /w Fr. Timothy Gallagher, OMV
The Daily Prayer of Discernment: The Examen Prayer with Fr. Timothy Gallagher
The Discernment of God’s Will in Everyday Decisions with Fr. Timothy Gallager
The post Rule 5 and an Introduction to Rule 6 – The Second Week Rules for the Discernment of Spirits w/ Fr. Timothy Gallagher – Discerning Hearts Podcast appeared first on Discerning Hearts Catholic Podcasts.
16 November 2026, 6:50 pm - 10 minutes 36 secondsMonday of the Thirty-Third Week in Ordinary Time – A Time of Lectio Divina for the Discerning Heart Podcast
Monday of the Thirty-Third Week in Ordinary Time – A Time of Lectio Divina for the Discerning Heart PodcastAs you begin, take a deep breath and exhale slowly. For at least the next few moments, surrender all the cares and concerns of this day to the Lord.
Say slowly from your heart “Jesus, I Trust In You…You Take Over”
Become aware that He is with you, looking upon you with love, wanting to be heard deep within in your heart…
From the Holy Gospel According to St. Luke 18:35-43
As Jesus drew near to Jericho there was a blind man sitting at the side of the road begging. When he heard the crowd going past he asked what it was all about, and they told him that Jesus the Nazarene was passing by. So he called out, ‘Jesus, Son of David, have pity on me.’ The people in front scolded him and told him to keep quiet, but he shouted all the louder, ‘Son of David, have pity on me.’ Jesus stopped and ordered them to bring the man to him, and when he came up, asked him, ‘What do you want me to do for you?’ ‘Sir,’ he replied ‘let me see again.’ Jesus said to him, ‘Receive your sight. Your faith has saved you.’ And instantly his sight returned and he followed him praising God, and all the people who saw it gave praise to God for what had happened.
What word made this passage come alive for you?
What did you sense the Lord saying to you?
Once more give the Lord an opportunity to speak to you:
As Jesus drew near to Jericho there was a blind man sitting at the side of the road begging. When he heard the crowd going past he asked what it was all about, and they told him that Jesus the Nazarene was passing by. So he called out, ‘Jesus, Son of David, have pity on me.’ The people in front scolded him and told him to keep quiet, but he shouted all the louder, ‘Son of David, have pity on me.’ Jesus stopped and ordered them to bring the man to him, and when he came up, asked him, ‘What do you want me to do for you?’ ‘Sir,’ he replied ‘let me see again.’ Jesus said to him, ‘Receive your sight. Your faith has saved you.’ And instantly his sight returned and he followed him praising God, and all the people who saw it gave praise to God for what had happened.
What did your heart feel as you listened?
What did you sense the Lord saying to you?
Once more, through Him, with Him and in Him listen to the Word:
As Jesus drew near to Jericho there was a blind man sitting at the side of the road begging. When he heard the crowd going past he asked what it was all about, and they told him that Jesus the Nazarene was passing by. So he called out, ‘Jesus, Son of David, have pity on me.’ The people in front scolded him and told him to keep quiet, but he shouted all the louder, ‘Son of David, have pity on me.’ Jesus stopped and ordered them to bring the man to him, and when he came up, asked him, ‘What do you want me to do for you?’ ‘Sir,’ he replied ‘let me see again.’ Jesus said to him, ‘Receive your sight. Your faith has saved you.’ And instantly his sight returned and he followed him praising God, and all the people who saw it gave praise to God for what had happened.
What touched your heart in this time of prayer?
What did your heart feel as you prayed?
What do you hope to carry with you from this time with the Lord?
Our Father, who art in heaven,
hallowed be thy name.
Thy kingdom come.
Thy will be done on earth, as it is in heaven.
Give us this day our daily bread,
and forgive us our trespasses,
as we forgive those who trespass against us,
and lead us not into temptation,
but deliver us from evil.
Amen
Excerpt from THE JERUSALEM BIBLE, copyright (c) 1966 by Darton, Longman & Todd, Ltd. and Doubleday, a division of Penguin Random House, Inc. Reprinted by Permission.
The post Monday of the Thirty-Third Week in Ordinary Time – A Time of Lectio Divina for the Discerning Heart Podcast appeared first on Discerning Hearts Catholic Podcasts.
16 November 2026, 4:00 am - 28 minutes 50 secondsThe Talents God Has Given You: Love Is Meant to Be Shared – Msgr. John Esseff | Discerning Hearts Podcast

The Talents God Has Given You: Love Is Meant to Be Shared – Building a Kingdom of Love with Msgr. John Esseff podcast
In this episode of Building a Kingdom of Love, Msgr. John Esseff reflects on Jesus’ parable of the ten virgins in Matthew 25 and what it teaches about preparing to meet the Lord. Five virgins are wise and bring oil for their lamps, while five are foolish and find themselves unprepared when the bridegroom arrives. Msgr. Esseff explains that the oil represents something essential to the Christian life: a living relationship with Jesus Christ. The wise virgins know the bridegroom, and he knows them. This becomes the central question for every Christian, especially those entrusted with leadership in the Church. We may accomplish many good things in God’s name, but are we listening to Him and doing what He actually asks of us?
Drawing from Jesus’ warning in Matthew 7, Msgr. Esseff explains that even extraordinary religious accomplishments cannot substitute for obedience to the Father’s will. He recalls St. Teresa of Calcutta, who would ask him to pray that she might stay out of God’s way. Her holiness came from listening to God and allowing Him to accomplish His work through her. Msgr. Esseff compares this relationship to the attentive love between husband and wife, where genuine love involves listening and understanding rather than simply doing things for the other person. Through Baptism and the gift of the Holy Spirit, Christians are drawn into Christ’s own relationship with the Father. As St. Paul teaches in his First Letter to the Thessalonians, the promise of Christ’s return offers hope that we will one day be with the Lord forever.
Kris McGregor raises an important question about those who believe God is calling them to undertake particular works or exercise spiritual gifts. How can they discern whether these desires truly come from the Lord? Msgr. Esseff points to obedience, humility, and the peace that accompanies genuine discernment. He recalls St. Padre Pio, whose extraordinary spiritual gifts remained subject to the authority of the Church. Kris also observes that pride, anger, division, and confusion can reveal the dangers of acting according to one’s own desires rather than submitting those desires to discernment. The episode invites listeners to examine their relationship with Christ and recognize that preparation for eternity begins with listening to Him and faithfully responding to His will.
Discerning Hearts Reflection Questions:
1. When I hear the parable of the talents, how do I recognize the capacity for love that God has entrusted to me?
2. Are there ways in which fear has prevented me from sharing the love I have received?
3. Where has self-centeredness or spiritual laziness made me less attentive to the needs of others?
4. How does beginning my day in prayer help me receive the grace to love more generously?
5. What can I learn from the ordinary saints whose love has made a difference in my life?
6. When suffering or disappointment makes it difficult to trust God’s love, how does looking at the Cross help me?
7. If I were asked to give an account of how I have used God’s gifts, what would my daily relationships reveal about my love for Him and others?
The post The Talents God Has Given You: Love Is Meant to Be Shared – Msgr. John Esseff | Discerning Hearts Podcast appeared first on Discerning Hearts Catholic Podcasts.
15 November 2026, 8:01 pm - 1 minute 38 secondsDay 9 – St. Gertrude the Great Novena – Discerning Hearts Catholic Podcasts

St. Gertrude the Great Novena – Day 9 – For the Grace of Humility
On this final day of this novena, we turn our hearts to St. Gertrude’s profound example of holy poverty. Her life, rich in virtue and devotion, continues to be a beacon that leads us to the true riches found in Christ. In the glory of heaven, she now stands before God, offering her prayers on our behalf. Let us humbly ask for the grace of humility so that we, too, may embrace the spiritual poverty that opens us to God’s infinite grace. And with trusting hearts, we ask St. Gertrude to intercede for the personal intention we carry through this novena.
We join St. Gertrude in a prayer she composed for the Holy Souls in Purgatory:
Eternal Father,
I offer Thee the Most Precious Blood of Thy Divine Son,
Jesus, in union with the Masses said throughout the world today,
for all the holy Souls in Purgatory,
for sinners everywhere,
for sinners in the Universal Church,
those in my own home and within my family.
Amen.St. Gertrude the Great, pray for us
For the entire novena visit: A Novena to St. Gertrude the Great – Discerning Hearts Podcast
Image is from SanctifiedSouls on Etsy; used with permission. Visit their shop for this image and more!
The post Day 9 – St. Gertrude the Great Novena – Discerning Hearts Catholic Podcasts appeared first on Discerning Hearts Catholic Podcasts.
15 November 2026, 4:30 am - 14 minutes 46 secondsSunday of the Thirty-Third Week in Ordinary Time – A Time of Lectio Divina for the Discerning Heart Podcast
Sunday of the Thirty-Third Week in Ordinary Time – A Time of Lectio Divina for the Discerning Heart PodcastAs you begin, take a deep breath and exhale slowly. For at least the next few moments, surrender all the cares and concerns of this day to the Lord.
Say slowly from your heart “Jesus, I Trust In You…You Take Over”
Become aware that He is with you, looking upon you with love, wanting to be heard deep within in your heart…
From the Holy Gospel According to St. Matthew 25:14-30
Jesus spoke this parable to his disciples: ‘The kingdom of Heaven is like a man on his way abroad who summoned his servants and entrusted his property to them. To one he gave five talents, to another two, to a third one; each in proportion to his ability. Then he set out.
‘The man who had received the five talents promptly went and traded with them and made five more. The man who had received two made two more in the same way. But the man who had received one went off and dug a hole in the ground and hid his master’s money.
‘Now a long time after, the master of those servants came back and went through his accounts with them. The man who had received the five talents came forward bringing five more. “Sir,” he said “you entrusted me with five talents; here are five more that I have made.”
‘His master said to him, “Well done, good and faithful servant; you have shown you can be faithful in small things, I will trust you with greater; come and join in your master’s happiness.”
‘Next the man with the two talents came forward. “Sir,” he said “you entrusted me with two talents; here are two more that I have made.” His master said to him, “Well done, good and faithful servant; you have shown you can be faithful in small things, I will trust you with greater; come and join in your master’s happiness.”
‘Last came forward the man who had the one talent. “Sir,” said he “I had heard you were a hard man, reaping where you have not sown and gathering where you have not scattered; so I was afraid, and I went off and hid your talent in the ground. Here it is; it was yours, you have it back.” But his master answered him, “You wicked and lazy servant! So you knew that I reap where I have not sown and gather where I have not scattered? Well then, you should have deposited my money with the bankers, and on my return I would have recovered my capital with interest. So now, take the talent from him and give it to the man who has the five talents. For to everyone who has will be given more, and he will have more than enough; but from the man who has not, even what he has will be taken away. As for this good-for-nothing servant, throw him out into the dark, where there will be weeping and grinding of teeth.”’What word made this passage come alive for you?
What did you sense the Lord saying to you?
Once more give the Lord an opportunity to speak to you:
Jesus spoke this parable to his disciples: ‘The kingdom of Heaven is like a man on his way abroad who summoned his servants and entrusted his property to them. To one he gave five talents, to another two, to a third one; each in proportion to his ability. Then he set out.
‘The man who had received the five talents promptly went and traded with them and made five more. The man who had received two made two more in the same way. But the man who had received one went off and dug a hole in the ground and hid his master’s money.
‘Now a long time after, the master of those servants came back and went through his accounts with them. The man who had received the five talents came forward bringing five more. “Sir,” he said “you entrusted me with five talents; here are five more that I have made.”
‘His master said to him, “Well done, good and faithful servant; you have shown you can be faithful in small things, I will trust you with greater; come and join in your master’s happiness.”
‘Next the man with the two talents came forward. “Sir,” he said “you entrusted me with two talents; here are two more that I have made.” His master said to him, “Well done, good and faithful servant; you have shown you can be faithful in small things, I will trust you with greater; come and join in your master’s happiness.”
‘Last came forward the man who had the one talent. “Sir,” said he “I had heard you were a hard man, reaping where you have not sown and gathering where you have not scattered; so I was afraid, and I went off and hid your talent in the ground. Here it is; it was yours, you have it back.” But his master answered him, “You wicked and lazy servant! So you knew that I reap where I have not sown and gather where I have not scattered? Well then, you should have deposited my money with the bankers, and on my return I would have recovered my capital with interest. So now, take the talent from him and give it to the man who has the five talents. For to everyone who has will be given more, and he will have more than enough; but from the man who has not, even what he has will be taken away. As for this good-for-nothing servant, throw him out into the dark, where there will be weeping and grinding of teeth.”’What did your heart feel as you listened?
What did you sense the Lord saying to you?
Once more, through Him, with Him and in Him listen to the Word:
Jesus spoke this parable to his disciples: ‘The kingdom of Heaven is like a man on his way abroad who summoned his servants and entrusted his property to them. To one he gave five talents, to another two, to a third one; each in proportion to his ability. Then he set out.
‘The man who had received the five talents promptly went and traded with them and made five more. The man who had received two made two more in the same way. But the man who had received one went off and dug a hole in the ground and hid his master’s money.
‘Now a long time after, the master of those servants came back and went through his accounts with them. The man who had received the five talents came forward bringing five more. “Sir,” he said “you entrusted me with five talents; here are five more that I have made.”
‘His master said to him, “Well done, good and faithful servant; you have shown you can be faithful in small things, I will trust you with greater; come and join in your master’s happiness.”
‘Next the man with the two talents came forward. “Sir,” he said “you entrusted me with two talents; here are two more that I have made.” His master said to him, “Well done, good and faithful servant; you have shown you can be faithful in small things, I will trust you with greater; come and join in your master’s happiness.”
‘Last came forward the man who had the one talent. “Sir,” said he “I had heard you were a hard man, reaping where you have not sown and gathering where you have not scattered; so I was afraid, and I went off and hid your talent in the ground. Here it is; it was yours, you have it back.” But his master answered him, “You wicked and lazy servant! So you knew that I reap where I have not sown and gather where I have not scattered? Well then, you should have deposited my money with the bankers, and on my return I would have recovered my capital with interest. So now, take the talent from him and give it to the man who has the five talents. For to everyone who has will be given more, and he will have more than enough; but from the man who has not, even what he has will be taken away. As for this good-for-nothing servant, throw him out into the dark, where there will be weeping and grinding of teeth.”’What touched your heart in this time of prayer?
What did your heart feel as you prayed?
What do you hope to carry with you from this time with the Lord?
Our Father, who art in heaven,
hallowed be thy name.
Thy kingdom come.
Thy will be done on earth, as it is in heaven.
Give us this day our daily bread,
and forgive us our trespasses,
as we forgive those who trespass against us,
and lead us not into temptation,
but deliver us from evil.
Amen
Excerpt from THE JERUSALEM BIBLE, copyright (c) 1966 by Darton, Longman & Todd, Ltd. and Doubleday, a division of Penguin Random House, Inc. Reprinted by Permission.
The post Sunday of the Thirty-Third Week in Ordinary Time – A Time of Lectio Divina for the Discerning Heart Podcast appeared first on Discerning Hearts Catholic Podcasts.
15 November 2026, 4:00 am - 1 minute 46 secondsDay 8 – St. Gertrude the Great Novena – Discerning Hearts Catholic Podcasts

St. Gertrude the Great Novena – Day 8 – For the Grace of a Greater Devotion to the Sacred Heart
St. Gertrude had a great devotion to her beloved patron, St. John the Evangelist. With aid of his Gospel and the action of the Holy Spirit, she deeply perceived the unceasing love of Jesus Christ for us, particularly through His Sacred Heart, which is an enduring symbol of His divine love and mercy. St. Gertrude’s insights laid the groundwork for the devotion that St. Margaret Mary Alacoque would later be known for. In the spirit of St. Gertrude, may we present our heartfelt intentions to the Sacred Heart of Jesus, embracing His unfailing love. May she also intercede in the intention we bring to this novena.
We join St. Gertrude in a prayer she composed for the Holy Souls in Purgatory:
Eternal Father,
I offer Thee the Most Precious Blood of Thy Divine Son,
Jesus, in union with the Masses said throughout the world today,
for all the holy Souls in Purgatory,
for sinners everywhere,
for sinners in the Universal Church,
those in my own home and within my family.
Amen.St. Gertrude the Great, pray for us
For the entire novena visit: A Novena to St. Gertrude the Great – Discerning Hearts Podcast
The post Day 8 – St. Gertrude the Great Novena – Discerning Hearts Catholic Podcasts appeared first on Discerning Hearts Catholic Podcasts.
14 November 2026, 4:13 am - 10 minutes 29 secondsSaturday of the Thirty-Second Week in Ordinary Time – A Time of Lectio Divina for the Discerning Heart Podcast
Saturday of the Thirty-Second Week in Ordinary Time – A Time of Lectio Divina for the Discerning Heart PodcastAs you begin, take a deep breath and exhale slowly. For at least the next few moments, surrender all the cares and concerns of this day to the Lord.
Say slowly from your heart “Jesus, I Trust In You…You Take Over”
Become aware that He is with you, looking upon you with love, wanting to be heard deep within in your heart…
From the Holy Gospel According to St. Luke 18:1-8
Jesus told his disciples a parable about the need to pray continually and never lose heart. ‘There was a judge in a certain town’ he said ‘who had neither fear of God nor respect for man. In the same town there was a widow who kept on coming to him and saying, “I want justice from you against my enemy!” For a long time he refused, but at last he said to himself, “Maybe I have neither fear of God nor respect for man, but since she keeps pestering me I must give this widow her just rights, or she will persist in coming and worry me to death.”’
And the Lord said ‘You notice what the unjust judge has to say? Now will not God see justice done to his chosen who cry to him day and night even when he delays to help them? I promise you, he will see justice done to them, and done speedily. But when the Son of Man comes, will he find any faith on earth?’
What word made this passage come alive for you?
What did you sense the Lord saying to you?
Once more give the Lord an opportunity to speak to you:
Jesus told his disciples a parable about the need to pray continually and never lose heart. ‘There was a judge in a certain town’ he said ‘who had neither fear of God nor respect for man. In the same town there was a widow who kept on coming to him and saying, “I want justice from you against my enemy!” For a long time he refused, but at last he said to himself, “Maybe I have neither fear of God nor respect for man, but since she keeps pestering me I must give this widow her just rights, or she will persist in coming and worry me to death.”’
And the Lord said ‘You notice what the unjust judge has to say? Now will not God see justice done to his chosen who cry to him day and night even when he delays to help them? I promise you, he will see justice done to them, and done speedily. But when the Son of Man comes, will he find any faith on earth?’
What did your heart feel as you listened?
What did you sense the Lord saying to you?
Once more, through Him, with Him and in Him listen to the Word:
Jesus told his disciples a parable about the need to pray continually and never lose heart. ‘There was a judge in a certain town’ he said ‘who had neither fear of God nor respect for man. In the same town there was a widow who kept on coming to him and saying, “I want justice from you against my enemy!” For a long time he refused, but at last he said to himself, “Maybe I have neither fear of God nor respect for man, but since she keeps pestering me I must give this widow her just rights, or she will persist in coming and worry me to death.”’
And the Lord said ‘You notice what the unjust judge has to say? Now will not God see justice done to his chosen who cry to him day and night even when he delays to help them? I promise you, he will see justice done to them, and done speedily. But when the Son of Man comes, will he find any faith on earth?’
What touched your heart in this time of prayer?
What did your heart feel as you prayed?
What do you hope to carry with you from this time with the Lord?
Our Father, who art in heaven,
hallowed be thy name.
Thy kingdom come.
Thy will be done on earth, as it is in heaven.
Give us this day our daily bread,
and forgive us our trespasses,
as we forgive those who trespass against us,
and lead us not into temptation,
but deliver us from evil.
Amen
Excerpt from THE JERUSALEM BIBLE, copyright (c) 1966 by Darton, Longman & Todd, Ltd. and Doubleday, a division of Penguin Random House, Inc. Reprinted by Permission.
The post Saturday of the Thirty-Second Week in Ordinary Time – A Time of Lectio Divina for the Discerning Heart Podcast appeared first on Discerning Hearts Catholic Podcasts.
14 November 2026, 4:00 am - 30 minutes 28 secondsCWC4 – God’s Longing For Us – Communion with Christ: Practical Prayer with Deacon James Keating – Discerning Hearts Podcast

Episode 4: God’s Longing For Us – Communion with Christ: Practical Prayer with Deacon James Keating
Deacon James Keating and Kris McGregor reflect on the final words of Jesus from the cross, continuing their exploration of Christian prayer through paragraph 2605 of the Catechism of the Catholic Church. As Jesus entrusts His mother to the beloved disciple, Deacon Keating considers the Blessed Virgin Mary as a model of prayer for the entire Church. Having held the mysteries of Christ’s life in her heart, Mary teaches us how to receive the Lord and remain attentive to His presence. Jesus’ words, “I thirst,” reveal another profound dimension of prayer: God’s longing for communion with humanity. Deacon Keating explains that our desire for God begins with God’s desire for us. Through grace, the Lord awakens within us a corresponding thirst for Him, transforming prayer from an obligation into an expression of love and a way of living in communion with God.
The conversation continues with Jesus’ cry, “My God, my God, why have you forsaken me?” Deacon Keating reflects on Christ’s solidarity with humanity in its experience of sin, loneliness, and separation from God, revealing a Savior who enters our darkness to bring us back to the Father. When Jesus declares, “It is finished,” His saving work reaches its fulfillment, yet the mystery of His sacrifice remains present to the Church through the Eucharist. The words “Father, into your hands I commend my spirit” express Christ’s complete trust in the Father, a trust vindicated in the Resurrection. Deacon Keating also considers the final cry of Jesus as an expression of creation’s longing to return to its source. Through Christ’s death and Resurrection, the way to communion with the Father is opened. Prayer becomes a participation in this saving mystery, sustained by the Holy Spirit and filled with the hope that even death cannot separate us from the life of God.
Check out Deacon Keating’s “Discerning Hearts” page
Discerning Hearts Questions for Reflection and Study
Personal Reflection
-
How does Mary’s example help you become more attentive to God’s presence in prayer?
-
What does Jesus’ cry, “I thirst,” reveal about His desire for communion with you?
-
How does recognizing God’s longing for you change the way you approach prayer?
-
What keeps prayer from becoming a natural expression of your love for God?
-
How can you become more receptive to the Holy Spirit praying within you?
-
When God seems distant, what helps you trust that He hasn’t abandoned you?
-
Where might Christ be inviting you to turn away from sin and return to Him?
-
How does the sacrifice of Christ on the cross deepen your appreciation of the Eucharist?
-
What can you learn from Jesus’ complete surrender to the Father’s will?
-
How does the promise of resurrection shape your understanding of suffering and death?
Group Reflection or Study
-
Why does Deacon Keating present Mary as a model of prayer for the entire Church?
-
What does Mary’s presence at the foot of the cross teach us about faithfulness to God?
-
How does understanding God’s thirst for humanity deepen our understanding of Christian prayer?
-
What distinguishes prayer motivated by obligation from prayer inspired by love?
-
Why is the Holy Spirit essential to our growing communion with Christ?
-
What does Jesus’ cry of abandonment reveal about His solidarity with sinful humanity?
-
How does Deacon Keating’s reflection challenge our understanding of God’s faithfulness?
-
What is the relationship between Christ’s sacrifice on Calvary and the celebration of the Eucharist?
-
How does Jesus’ surrender to the Father reveal the meaning of Christian trust?
-
What does Christ’s Resurrection reveal about the ultimate purpose of prayer and communion with God?
From the book description:The book addresses their mutual dedication to remain with Christ in prayer even in the service of parishioners. Once prayer finds a place in the heart, compassion grows for those who look for God “like sheep without a shepherd.” Through interior prayerfulness, clerical unity in ministry can be better ensured Remain in Me is for priests and deacons to use as prayer, on retreat, or during the holy seasons of Lent and Advent.
Deacon James Keating, Ph.D., is a professor of Spiritual Theology and serves as a spiritual director at Kenrick Glennon Seminary in St. Louis, MO.
The post CWC4 – God’s Longing For Us – Communion with Christ: Practical Prayer with Deacon James Keating – Discerning Hearts Podcast appeared first on Discerning Hearts Catholic Podcasts.
13 November 2026, 7:46 pm -
- 1 minute 53 secondsDay 7 – St. Gertrude the Great Novena – Discerning Hearts Catholic Podcasts

St. Gertrude the Great Novena – Day 7 – For the Grace of a Greater Love of the Holy Eucharist
St. Gertrude embraced the Mass as a profound encounter with Christ’s redemptive suffering. Let us reflect on this prayer that she composed,
‘Through this Mass, I offer You in reparation, loving Father, all the sufferings of Your Son from His first cry in the manger to His last breath on the Cross. In my humble state, I praise and adore Your mercy,’ Amen.
Let us ask St. Gertrude to intercede for us as we seek to unite our own joys and sorrows with the Eucharistic sacrifice. May this act of communion inspire us to live out each day in accordance with God’s loving plan for our lives. May she also intercede in the intention we bring to this novena.
We join St. Gertrude in a prayer she composed for the Holy Souls in Purgatory:
Eternal Father,
I offer Thee the Most Precious Blood of Thy Divine Son,
Jesus, in union with the Masses said throughout the world today,
for all the holy Souls in Purgatory,
for sinners everywhere,
for sinners in the Universal Church,
those in my own home and within my family.
Amen.St. Gertrude the Great, pray for us
For the entire novena visit: A Novena to St. Gertrude the Great – Discerning Hearts Podcast
The post Day 7 – St. Gertrude the Great Novena – Discerning Hearts Catholic Podcasts appeared first on Discerning Hearts Catholic Podcasts.
13 November 2026, 5:00 am - 10 minutes 28 secondsFriday of the Thirty-Second Week in Ordinary Time – A Time of Lectio Divina for the Discerning Heart Podcast
Friday of the Thirty-Second Week in Ordinary Time – A Time of Lectio Divina for the Discerning Heart PodcastAs you begin, take a deep breath and exhale slowly. For at least the next few moments, surrender all the cares and concerns of this day to the Lord.
Say slowly from your heart “Jesus, I Trust In You…You Take Over”
Become aware that He is with you, looking upon you with love, wanting to be heard deep within in your heart…
From the Holy Gospel According to St. Luke 17:26-37
Jesus said to the disciples:
‘As it was in Noah’s day, so will it also be in the days of the Son of Man. People were eating and drinking, marrying wives and husbands, right up to the day Noah went into the ark, and the flood came and destroyed them all. It will be the same as it was in Lot’s day: people were eating and drinking, buying and selling, planting and building, but the day Lot left Sodom, God rained fire and brimstone from heaven and it destroyed them all. It will be the same when the day comes for the Son of Man to be revealed.
‘When that day comes, anyone on the housetop, with his possessions in the house, must not come down to collect them, nor must anyone in the fields turn back either. Remember Lot’s wife. Anyone who tries to preserve his life will lose it; and anyone who loses it will keep it safe. I tell you, on that night two will be in one bed: one will be taken, the other left; two women will be grinding corn together: one will be taken, the other left.’ The disciples interrupted. ‘Where, Lord?’ they asked. He said, ‘Where the body is, there too will the vultures gather.’What word made this passage come alive for you?
What did you sense the Lord saying to you?
Once more give the Lord an opportunity to speak to you:
Jesus said to the disciples:
‘As it was in Noah’s day, so will it also be in the days of the Son of Man. People were eating and drinking, marrying wives and husbands, right up to the day Noah went into the ark, and the flood came and destroyed them all. It will be the same as it was in Lot’s day: people were eating and drinking, buying and selling, planting and building, but the day Lot left Sodom, God rained fire and brimstone from heaven and it destroyed them all. It will be the same when the day comes for the Son of Man to be revealed.
‘When that day comes, anyone on the housetop, with his possessions in the house, must not come down to collect them, nor must anyone in the fields turn back either. Remember Lot’s wife. Anyone who tries to preserve his life will lose it; and anyone who loses it will keep it safe. I tell you, on that night two will be in one bed: one will be taken, the other left; two women will be grinding corn together: one will be taken, the other left.’ The disciples interrupted. ‘Where, Lord?’ they asked. He said, ‘Where the body is, there too will the vultures gather.’What did your heart feel as you listened?
What did you sense the Lord saying to you?
Once more, through Him, with Him and in Him listen to the Word:
Jesus said to the disciples:
‘As it was in Noah’s day, so will it also be in the days of the Son of Man. People were eating and drinking, marrying wives and husbands, right up to the day Noah went into the ark, and the flood came and destroyed them all. It will be the same as it was in Lot’s day: people were eating and drinking, buying and selling, planting and building, but the day Lot left Sodom, God rained fire and brimstone from heaven and it destroyed them all. It will be the same when the day comes for the Son of Man to be revealed.
‘When that day comes, anyone on the housetop, with his possessions in the house, must not come down to collect them, nor must anyone in the fields turn back either. Remember Lot’s wife. Anyone who tries to preserve his life will lose it; and anyone who loses it will keep it safe. I tell you, on that night two will be in one bed: one will be taken, the other left; two women will be grinding corn together: one will be taken, the other left.’ The disciples interrupted. ‘Where, Lord?’ they asked. He said, ‘Where the body is, there too will the vultures gather.’What touched your heart in this time of prayer?
What did your heart feel as you prayed?
What do you hope to carry with you from this time with the Lord?
Our Father, who art in heaven,
hallowed be thy name.
Thy kingdom come.
Thy will be done on earth, as it is in heaven.
Give us this day our daily bread,
and forgive us our trespasses,
as we forgive those who trespass against us,
and lead us not into temptation,
but deliver us from evil.
Amen
Excerpt from THE JERUSALEM BIBLE, copyright (c) 1966 by Darton, Longman & Todd, Ltd. and Doubleday, a division of Penguin Random House, Inc. Reprinted by Permission.
The post Friday of the Thirty-Second Week in Ordinary Time – A Time of Lectio Divina for the Discerning Heart Podcast appeared first on Discerning Hearts Catholic Podcasts.
13 November 2026, 4:00 am - 24 minutes 8 secondsWhy Pray If God Already Knows? – St. Augustine on the Lord’s Prayer | The Spiritual Journey for the Discerning Heart Podcast

St. Augustine’s Letter to Proba on prayer, desire, asking God for what we need, and learning to trust his will
About This Episode
If God already knows what we need, why do we pray? And when something matters deeply to us, is it wrong to ask God for the outcome we’re hoping for?
In this episode of The Spiritual Journey for the Discerning Heart, Kris McGregor reflects on St. Augustine’s letter to Proba, a Christian widow who asked him a question that remains deeply relevant: how should we pray when St. Paul himself says, “we do not know how to pray as we ought”?
St. Augustine brings Proba back to the Lord’s Prayer. The words Jesus gave us aren’t meant to inform God about needs he doesn’t already know. They help us recognize what we’re asking for, clarify what’s happening within us, and gradually form our desires.
That doesn’t mean we shouldn’t ask God for concrete things. We can pray for a sick child to recover, for work when a job has been lost, or for help when financial pressures have become difficult. We can tell God honestly what we hope will happen. Jesus himself does this in Gethsemane when he asks that the cup pass from him and then entrusts himself to the Father’s will.
St. Augustine helps us hold those two movements together. We can ask with real hope while allowing prayer to deepen our trust in the Father, who sees more than we can see.
As St. Augustine moves through each petition of the Lord’s Prayer, he shows how prayer forms the heart. “Your kingdom come” awakens a deeper desire for God. “Your will be done” asks for the grace to receive and follow his will. “Give us this day our daily bread” places our real needs before the Father. Forgiveness asks us to receive mercy and gradually become merciful ourselves.
The final petitions also remind us that the spiritual life involves a real struggle. Temptation can come through attraction to sin, but also through discouragement and despair. When we pray, “Deliver us from evil,” we ask for protection from sin, suffering, the deception of the enemy, and anything that would draw us away from God. The devil is real, but he is never God’s equal, and the Christian response isn’t fear or preoccupation with the enemy. It’s trust in God and dependence upon his grace.
The Lord’s Prayer gives us words for every part of the spiritual journey, including those moments when we don’t know what to say. St. Augustine teaches us that prayer doesn’t require us to hide what we want from God. We bring him our real hopes and needs, and in that relationship he continues to form the heart of the person who asks.
Discerning Hearts Reflection Question
- When you bring a particular hope or need to God, are you able to tell him honestly what you want while also allowing him to lead you?
- St. Augustine says the words of prayer help us understand what we’re asking. Has prayer ever revealed that something deeper was happening within you than you first realized?
- Which petition of the Lord’s Prayer speaks most directly to where you are on the spiritual journey right now?
- When you pray, “Your will be done,” what helps you move from simply wanting to know God’s will toward trusting him enough to follow it?
A letter to Proba by St Augustine
We need to use words so that we may remind ourselves to consider carefully what we are asking, not so that we may think we can instruct the Lord or prevail on him.
Thus, when we say: Hallowed be your name, we are reminding ourselves to desire that his name, which in fact is always holy, should also be considered holy among men. I mean that it should not be held in contempt. But this is a help for men, not for God.
And as for our saying: Your kingdom come, it will surely come whether we will it or not. But we are stirring up our desires for the kingdom so that it can come to us and we can deserve to reign there.
When we say: Your will be done on earth as it is in heaven, we are asking him to make us obedient so that his will may be done in us as it is done in heaven by his angels.
When we say: Give us this day our daily bread, in saying this day we mean “in this world.” Here we ask for a sufficiency by specifying the most important part of it; that is, we use the word “bread” to stand for everything. Or else we are asking for the sacrament of the faithful, which is necessary in this world, not to gain temporal happiness but to gain the happiness that is everlasting.
When we say: Forgive us our trespasses as we forgive those who trespass against us, we are reminding ourselves of what we must ask and what we must do in order to be worthy in turn to receive.
When we say: Lead us not into temptation, we are reminding ourselves to ask that his help may not depart from us; otherwise we could be seduced and consent to some temptation, or despair and yield to it.
When we say: Deliver us from evil, we are reminding ourselves to reflect on the fact that we do not yet enjoy the state of blessedness in which we shall suffer no evil. This is the final petition contained in the Lord’s Prayer, and it has a wide application. In this petition the Christian can utter his cries of sorrow, in it he can shed his tears, and through it he can begin, continue and conclude his prayer, whatever the distress in which he finds himself. Yes, it was very appropriate that all these truths should be entrusted to us to remember in these very words.
Whatever be the other words we may prefer to say (words which the one praying chooses so that his disposition may become clearer to himself or which he simply adopts so that his disposition may be intensified), we say nothing that is not contained in the Lord’s Prayer, provided of course we are praying in a correct and proper way. But if anyone says something which is incompatible with this prayer of the Gospel, he is praying in the flesh, even if he is not praying sinfully. And yet I do not know how this could be termed anything but sinful, since those who are born again through the Spirit ought to pray only in the Spirit.
Excerpts from the English translation of The Liturgy of the Hours (Four Volumes), © 1974, International Commission on English in the Liturgy Corporation. All rights reserved.
Scripture for Reflection
Matthew 6:8, RSV-CE
“Do not be like them, for your Father knows what you need before you ask him.”
Romans 8:26, RSV-CE
“Likewise the Spirit helps us in our weakness; for we do not know how to pray as we ought, but the Spirit himself intercedes for us with sighs too deep for words.”
Matthew 26:39, RSV-CE
“My Father, if it be possible, let this cup pass from me; nevertheless, not as I will, but as thou wilt.”
St. Augustine
“We need to use words so that we may remind ourselves to consider carefully what we are asking, not so that we may think we can instruct the Lord or prevail on him.”
“We are stirring up our desires for the kingdom.”
“When we say: Your will be done on earth as it is in heaven, we are asking him to make us obedient.”
“In this petition the Christian can utter his cries of sorrow, in it he can shed his tears.”
Continue the Journey with Discerning Hearts
➜ Explore Discerning Hearts
➜ Discerning Hearts Series Programming
➜ The Spiritual Journey with Kris McGregor
Continue Exploring
➜ “The desire of your heart constitutes your prayer” – St. Augustine
A particularly good companion to this episode because St. Augustine reflects directly on desire as prayer.➜ Praying with St. Augustine – Sarah Park McLaughlin with Kris McGregor
A conversation about St. Augustine’s prayers and the deeply personal character of his relationship with God.➜ St. Augustine, Father and Doctor of the Church
More Discerning Hearts resources on the life, conversion, teaching, grace, and spirituality of St. Augustine.➜ St. Augustine of Hippo – “Late Have I Loved You”
St. Augustine’s famous prayer from the Confessions, centered on the soul’s longing for God.The post Why Pray If God Already Knows? – St. Augustine on the Lord’s Prayer | The Spiritual Journey for the Discerning Heart Podcast appeared first on Discerning Hearts Catholic Podcasts.
12 November 2026, 10:37 pm - More Episodes? Get the App