The Tastemakers | Did Timothee Blow His Oscar Chances?

Taran Armstrong (@armstrongtaran) and Grace Leeder (@hifromgrace) are The Tastemakers! Every week, Grace and Taran tell you about what’s on TV, which shows are worth watching, and which shows are worth skipping.

Today, Taran Armstrong and Grace Leeder discuss what they’ve been watching.

Send in feedback every week by emailing [email protected]

Never miss a minute of RHAP’s scripted coverage!
LISTEN: Subscribe to the RHAP: We Know Scripted TV podcast feed
WATCH:  Watch and subscribe to the podcast on YouTube
SUPPORT:  Become a RHAP Patron for bonus content, access to Facebook and Discord groups plus more great perks!

Rob Reacts to Paradise Season 2 Ep 4

Paradise Season 2, Episode 4 sends Xavier on a dramatic journey that leaves both the characters and listeners with plenty to unpack. Host Rob Cesternino teams up with Chappell to break down the latest events, including family turmoil, life-and-death decisions, and haunting glimpses of what lies ahead. The emotional stakes are raised as Xavier navigates a world where trust is scarce, and every choice could mean survival or heartbreak.

Rob and Chappell dive in as Xavier searches for his missing wife, Terry, only to find himself caring for a newborn and wrestling with tough questions about family loyalty and responsibility. The episode sprawls out across both the bunker and the battered landscape outside, with the hosts tracing Xavier and Annie’s journey and the larger consequences of the world’s devastation. The flashbacks and time jumps serve up twists, as both discuss how events tie together, from a mixed family forming in Paradise, to President Bradford trying to rally hope inside the bunker, and Annie’s tragic fate after childbirth.

Explore these highlights:

• Xavier and Annie’s uneasy partnership, sparked by a medical emergency and the need to survive, and their tense negotiations over travel plans.
• The emotional impact of Annie’s death, with Rob relating the childbirth scenes to real-life anxiety and Chappell connecting medical details to TV drama.
• President Bradford’s optimistic push to name the bunker baby “Hope” while exploring the value of symbols for morale.
• Speculation about Sinatra’s evolving role and mysterious motives, including hints at scientific innovation and possible space travel or time manipulation.
• Moments of humor and skepticism, as Chappell questions “work husband” dynamics and the trustworthiness of several key characters.

Paradise takes a sharp turn as Xavier inherits a new “holy charge”—caring for Annie’s child and hunting for answers about Terry’s disappearance. Is trust really possible in a fractured world, or are the survivors destined to repeat old mistakes as they move forward?

Chapters:
00:00 Xavier’s Surprising New Family
06:36 Annie’s Unexpected Tragic Demise
14:04 Xavier’s Visions and Sci-Fi Hints
21:20 Baby Names and Graceland Connections
27:06 Emotional Farewell to Annie
33:05 Terry’s Disappearance Shocks Xavier
38:01 Space or Time Travel Theories
41:00 Dan Fogelman’s Survivor Ambitions
43:02 Shailene Woodley’s Early Exit

Never miss a minute of RHAP’s coverage!
LISTEN: Subscribe to the podcast feed!
WATCH:  Watch and subscribe to the podcast on YouTube
SUPPORT:  Become a RHAP Patron for bonus content, access to Facebook and Discord groups plus more great perks!

The Tastemakers | The Winters Olympics Was a Mess

Taran Armstrong (@armstrongtaran) and Grace Leeder (@hifromgrace) are The Tastemakers! Every week, Grace and Taran tell you about what’s on TV, which shows are worth watching, and which shows are worth skipping.

Today, Grace Leeder welcomes Kirsten MacInnis on to talk about the winter Olympics.

Send in feedback every week by emailing [email protected]

Never miss a minute of RHAP’s scripted coverage!
LISTEN: Subscribe to the RHAP: We Know Scripted TV podcast feed
WATCH:  Watch and subscribe to the podcast on YouTube
SUPPORT:  Become a RHAP Patron for bonus content, access to Facebook and Discord groups plus more great perks!

The Tastemakers | Scream 7 is Not Bad

Taran Armstrong (@armstrongtaran) and Grace Leeder (@hifromgrace) are The Tastemakers! Every week, Grace and Taran tell you about what’s on TV, which shows are worth watching, and which shows are worth skipping.

Today, Grace Leeder welcomes Ariel and Chappell on to discuss Scream 7.

Send in feedback every week by emailing [email protected]

Never miss a minute of RHAP’s scripted coverage!
LISTEN: Subscribe to the RHAP: We Know Scripted TV podcast feed
WATCH:  Watch and subscribe to the podcast on YouTube
SUPPORT:  Become a RHAP Patron for bonus content, access to Facebook and Discord groups plus more great perks!

Rob Reacts to Paradise Season 2 Premiere Week

Paradise returns for season 2, and Rob Cesternino and Chappell take on the massive triple episode drop, covering the first week of episodes. The show launches viewers into Graceland, Mayday, and Another Day in Paradise, weaving together new character backstories, tense flashbacks, and the unfolding bunker drama. From Annie’s survival challenge in Graceland to Xavier’s journey with the Lost Boys and the power plays inside the bunker, this week’s discussion uncovers the tangled motivations and evolving alliances driving the series forward.

Rob and Chappell dive deep:

• Annie’s two-year survival inside Graceland, the emergence of Link, and a surprising decision not to join the Colorado mission.
• Xavier’s tough encounter with a group of resilient kids and the tense battle for supplies during his journey from Colorado to Atlanta.
• The introduction and significance of the Alex project, Elliot Stemple’s memorable final monologue, and Link’s pivotal role as the protégé.
• Flashbacks revealing Terry and Xavier’s emotional bond and how their story shapes the stakes of the present timeline.
• The rise and fall of President Baines, Sinatra’s secret scheme, and Jane’s calculated moves to frame Agent Robinson after the latest presidential assassination.

This discussion unpacks Paradise’s blend of character-driven storytelling and dystopian stakes, as the hosts weigh whether the bunker power struggles and outside survival tactics can shift the future. With the show signaling even bigger twists ahead, will Link’s plan reach the bunker in time, and whose interests will Sinatra truly protect?

Chapters:
0:00 Paradise’s Triple Episode Premiere
06:36 Annie’s Graceland Flashback Unfolds
14:24 Apocalypse Group Bonds Over Graceland
19:00 Mets, Survivor, and Apocalypse Regrets
25:00 Annie and Link’s Pregnant Gamble
32:12 Xavier Fights for Survival with Kids
36:14 Xavier and Terry’s Hospital Backstory
41:34 Sinatra Unveils Second Catastrophe Warning
46:45 Sinatra and Jane’s Revenge Flashback
53:15 Billy’s Deal, Link’s Purpose Revealed
59:54 Bunker Power Grab, Jane’s Plot
01:06:20 Robinson Framed, Kids Plan Rebellion

Never miss a minute of RHAP’s coverage!
LISTEN: Subscribe to the podcast feed!
WATCH:  Watch and subscribe to the podcast on YouTube
SUPPORT:  Become a RHAP Patron for bonus content, access to Facebook and Discord groups plus more great perks!

The Tastemakers | The Game of Thrones Sequels We Want to See

Taran Armstrong (@armstrongtaran) and Grace Leeder (@hifromgrace) are The Tastemakers! Every week, Grace and Taran tell you about what’s on TV, which shows are worth watching, and which shows are worth skipping.

This week, Taran and Grace are joined by Rich (DM Philly), Mari, and Chappell to break down the finale, and the future, of A Night of the Seven Kingdoms and the wider Game of Thrones universe.

The panel digs into how A Night of the Seven Kingdoms has unexpectedly punched back into the cultural mainstream. With critical acclaim, strong word of mouth, and even an IMDb ratings skirmish with Breaking Bad fans, the show has reminded audiences what made Westeros compelling in the first place: intimate stakes, rich characterization, and storytelling rooted firmly in George R.R. Martin’s voice, something many felt was missing in House of the Dragon.

From there, the group opens the writers’ room and pitches smart, restraint-first spinoff ideas designed to avoid franchise burnout. Concepts include a tightly focused Robert’s Rebellion political drama, a sequel-style Great Council series meant to reckon with the original show’s divisive ending, and an ambitious anthology in the vein of Black Mirror or Star Wars: Visions. Genre swings follow with spy thrillers inspired by Andor, offbeat buddy comedies, romances, and even grounded crime stories set in the shadows of Westeros.

To close things out, the hosts share what they’re watching now, from The Pit and Hacks to new films like The Phoenician Scheme and Marty Supreme starring Timothée Chalamet. If you’re craving thoughtful franchise talk with big ideas and sharp takes, this episode delivers. 

Send in feedback every week by emailing [email protected]

Never miss a minute of RHAP’s scripted coverage!
LISTEN: Subscribe to the RHAP: We Know Scripted TV podcast feed
WATCH:  Watch and subscribe to the podcast on YouTube
SUPPORT:  Become a RHAP Patron for bonus content, access to Facebook and Discord groups plus more great perks!

The Tastemakers | Wuthering Heights and Nirvana: The Band The Show The Movie Reviews with Haley Strong and Brian Scally

Taran Armstrong (@armstrongtaran) and Grace Leeder (@hifromgrace) are The Tastemakers! Every week, Grace and Taran tell you about what’s on TV, which shows are worth watching, and which shows are worth skipping.

This week, Grace Leeder welcomes Haley Strong on to talk about Wuthering Heights and Brian Scally on to talk about Nirvana: The Band The Show The Movie. 

Send in feedback every week by emailing [email protected]

Never miss a minute of RHAP’s scripted coverage!
LISTEN: Subscribe to the RHAP: We Know Scripted TV podcast feed
WATCH:  Watch and subscribe to the podcast on YouTube
SUPPORT:  Become a RHAP Patron for bonus content, access to Facebook and Discord groups plus more great perks!

The Tastemakers | Baldur’s Gate 3 and Brandon Sanderson

Taran Armstrong (@armstrongtaran) and Grace Leeder (@hifromgrace) are The Tastemakers! Every week, Grace and Taran tell you about what’s on TV, which shows are worth watching, and which shows are worth skipping.

This week, Taran and Grace discuss the news on a possible Baldur’s Gate 3 television series before diving into what they’ve been watching.

Chapters:
00:00 Intros
03:00 Brandon Sanderson series
21:15 Baldur’s Gate 3 series
30:00 What we’ve been watching

Send in feedback every week by emailing [email protected]

Never miss a minute of RHAP’s scripted coverage!
LISTEN: Subscribe to the RHAP: We Know Scripted TV podcast feed
WATCH:  Watch and subscribe to the podcast on YouTube
SUPPORT:  Become a RHAP Patron for bonus content, access to Facebook and Discord groups plus more great perks!

The Tastemakers | ‘Heated Rivalry’ Is So Hot Right Now with Mary Kwiatkowski

Taran Armstrong (@armstrongtaran) and Grace Leeder (@hifromgrace) are The Tastemakers! Every week, Grace and Taran tell you about what’s on TV, which shows are worth watching, and which shows are worth skipping.

This week, Grace Leeder welcomes Mary Kwiatkowski onto the podcast to discuss Heated Rivalry.

Send in feedback every week by emailing [email protected]

Never miss a minute of RHAP’s scripted coverage!
LISTEN: Subscribe to the RHAP: We Know Scripted TV podcast feed
WATCH:  Watch and subscribe to the podcast on YouTube
SUPPORT:  Become a RHAP Patron for bonus content, access to Facebook and Discord groups plus more great perks!

The Tastemakers | Catching Up on The Pitt, A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms and Skyscraper Live

Taran Armstrong (@armstrongtaran) and Grace Leeder (@hifromgrace) are The Tastemakers! Every week, Grace and Taran tell you about what’s on TV, which shows are worth watching, and which shows are worth skipping.

This week, Taran Armstrong and Grace Leeder discuss the latest that HBO has to offer in The Pitt, A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms, and Industry.

Chapters:
00:00 Intros
02:30 The Oscars
14:00 The Pitt (HBO)
19:20 A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms (HBO)
25:00 Industry (HBO)
31:30 Ponies (Peacock)
33:50 Skyscraper Live
40:45 Task (HBO)
45:30 28 Years Later: The Bone Temple
52:00 Sentimental Value
55:00 Train Dreams
01:05:00 What’s coming up

Send in feedback every week by emailing [email protected]

Never miss a minute of RHAP’s scripted coverage!
LISTEN: Subscribe to the RHAP: We Know Scripted TV podcast feed
WATCH:  Watch and subscribe to the podcast on YouTube
SUPPORT:  Become a RHAP Patron for bonus content, access to Facebook and Discord groups plus more great perks!

The Tastemakers | Golden Globes Reactions & Pluribus Review

Taran Armstrong (@armstrongtaran) and Grace Leeder (@hifromgrace) are The Tastemakers! Every week, Grace and Taran tell you about what’s on TV, which shows are worth watching, and which shows are worth skipping.

This week, Grace Leeder welcomes Dr. Amanda Rabinowitz onto the podcast to discuss the Golden Globe winners and all of Pluribus Season 1.

Chapters:
00:00 Intros
01:00 Golden Globe reactions
19:10 Pluribus Season 1

Send in feedback every week by emailing [email protected]

Never miss a minute of RHAP’s scripted coverage!
LISTEN: Subscribe to the RHAP: We Know Scripted TV podcast feed
WATCH:  Watch and subscribe to the podcast on YouTube
SUPPORT:  Become a RHAP Patron for bonus content, access to Facebook and Discord groups plus more great perks!