Movie love for movie lovers.
by Adam Riske and Sonia Mansfield
Sonia and Adam chat about Django Unchained, Galaxy Quest, The Illusionist (2010), I.Q., and more!
I’ll be honest, Django Unchained isn’t one of my go-to Tarantino movies. I liked it when I saw it in the theater, but it’s (understatement alert) uncomfy. It’s not fun to rewatch like Pulp Fiction or Once Upon a Time in Hollywood. Still, a lot of racists get murdered. That’s pretty fun.
My first pick is Fred Schepsi’s 1994 Christmas Day release I.Q., starring Meg Ryan, Tim Robbins, and Walter Matthau as Albert Einstein. This is not in any way one of my favorites. I just felt like revisiting it because it’s a movie that sort of has autobiographical infamy for me. On January 13, 1995, I went with my friends to the movie to see Tales from the Crypt: Demon Knight on its opening day but was denied entry because we were only 12 years old. The only movies playing at the theater we could be admitted to were Street Fighter or I.Q. We had all already seen Street Fighter, so we picked I.Q. and I was enraged so I didn’t give that movie a fair shake at all. Having now done so, I can say unequivocally that I.Q. is not as good as Demon Knight. In fact, I’ll go as far as saying it’s my least favorite Meg Ryan romantic comedy of the '90s that I’ve seen (I haven’t seen French Kiss). There’s something so dopey about the movie with Einstein and his friends playing Cupid for Robbins’ inquisitive mechanic. My big issue with the movie is that it feels like Ryan doesn’t have any choice in her matters of the heart. It’s like Tim Robbins sees her, says “HER!” to himself in his head, and then just wears her down while Matthau and his boys further manipulate her. There’s no great chemistry between Ryan and Robbins, so I didn’t really want them to get together and then in the scene where she tells him she loves him, it feels so thrown away and false that it pretty much sinks a movie that was otherwise in danger of falling off the rails. For something as seemingly innocuous as a movie like I.Q. presents itself to be, it’s a tad bit annoying.
I was curious, so I went to check out Galaxy Quest on Rotten Tomatoes. I couldn’t imagine there was someone who doesn’t like it, yet it has 90%, which means 10% of the reviews are wrong.
Sonia: I liked The Illusionist the first time I saw it in 2010. But this time I actually get it and appreciate it, because I’ve actually seen some Tati movies since then. The movie also hits differently for me now because I’m a parent. The fact that the magician works extra jobs without her knowing to make her feel like life is still magical speaks a lot to what it can be like to be a parent (especially around the holidays). And as a parent, you get to a point when you kinda have to burst that bubble, and your child sees you not as a magical all-knowing figure, but an actual human being. I imagine that’s a very bittersweet feeling. I say “imagine” because obviously I AM A MAGICAL ALL-KNOWING FIGURE, so my son never needs to find out.by JB
The screenings, scenes, shots, performances, and dialogue that now live rent-free in my head, thanks to this... interesting... moviegoing year.
Thanks to Rob and Adam, I watched Eephus, a wonderful, unconventional film that has stayed with me for months. Most moves these days don’t last until you get out to the parking lot.
The wonder and satisfaction of a big dance number, Sinners.
“So shines a good deed in a weary world.” Mike Flanagan’s The Life of Chuck. This film alone got me through a very long June.
Completely terrifying non-horror: A House of Dynamite.
The audience learns that Jesse Plemons is right about one thing, Bugonia.
How delightful to know that there are filmmakers who still know what they are doing. It kind of gives you hope: Wake Up, Dead Man.by Patrick Bromley
So much more than just a nepo baby.
Sofia Coppola starts her career with one of her best movies, an adaptation of the 1993 novel by Jeffrey Eugenides about five sisters in 1970s Michigan who cast a spell (not literally) over the boys in their high school. Haunting and gorgeous and achingly melancholy, The Virgin Suicides examines adolescence through a gauzy haze of misplaced nostalgia -- a memory of how things were rather than what they really were, which makes the tragedy at the end all the more shocking and awful despite being right there in the title. I'm not sure there's a sadder image in Coppola's filmography than that of Kirsten Dunst (in her first collaboration with the director; it would not be her last) waking up along on the football field after spending the night with BMOC Trip Fontaine. The moody score by French electronic group Air and the cinematography by Edward Lachman help to announce Coppola not just as a supremely talented filmmaker and someone who appreciates aesthetic beauty but also as someone with remarkable empathy and sensitivity.
I know there are some who accuse Sofia Coppola's films of prioritizing style of substance, a criticism with which I have never agreed -- except maybe in the case of The Bling Ring, Coppola's weakest and most hollow film. I know, I know: the hollowness is part of the point because this is a movie about vapid and entitled socialites who begin robbing houses simply because they're bored and have never had to face consequences for anything in their lives. I think there's a movie here and I think Coppola could have been the right person to make it given her understanding of aesthetics and privilege. Unfortunately, everything about the Bling Ring is surface and not completely in a way that was intended. For a filmmaker who's usually so willing to investigate the movie's themes of privilege and alienation, this movie seems strangely uncurious about its own subject matter.
If Sofia Coppola has a movie that can be considered her most underrated, it's Marie Antoinette. And maybe Priscilla. But also this one, which I suspect a lot of people would put in the "lows" column of her filmography even though it doesn't belong there. One of a few movies she's made about fathers and daughters (or father figures and daughter figures), Somewhere gives Stephen Dorff his best role in 20 years as a successful actor attempting to connect with his daughter (Elle Fanning) during an indefinite stay at the Chateau Marmont in Hollywood. While the movie could be accused of being Coppola's most insular and navel-gazing -- it's all about Hollywood boredom and being stuck at a specific point in your life both geographically and existentially (it's like Lost in Translation that way) -- it's also deeply personal and affecting.
Coppola's On the Rocks, which barely feels like it exists as it was made for Apple TV and released during COVID, isn't a bad movie, just one that feels formulaic in a way that none of her other films do. An autobiographic story (it has to be, right?) about a daughter (Rashida Jones) and her sometimes absentee father (Bill Murray) coming together to sus out if Jones' marriage is over, On the Rocks reads and often feels like a generic studio comedy drama. A real StuComDram. The performances are good because of course they are (it's nice to see Marlon Wayans getting a good role in 2020 as the husband Jones suspects of being unfaithful), but they're in service of a formulaic screenplay. I can appreciate Coppola's desire to make something more commercial, but she sacrifices what makes her so singular in the process. She's so much about vibes. On the Rocks has no vibes.
Ok I know I said that Somewhere is Sofia Coppola's most underrated movie but I'm changing my mind because it's this one: her 2017 remake of the Don Siegel/Clint Eastwood movie The Beguiled. Reimagining the 1971 film about a macho, toxic man that everyone wants to fuck as a movie told from the point of view of the women in the story, Coppola's update does just what a remake should do: it takes the basic premise of the original film but places it under a different lens, imbuing the same story with different meaning and new authorship. Shot on 35mm film using only natural light by French cinematographer Phillippe Le Sourd (who would go on to shoot Coppola's next two films as well), The Beguiled is one of those "every frame a painting" movies that's almost achingly beautiful in its compositions. Coppola was awarded Best Director at the Cannes Film Festival (becoming only the second woman in the fest's history, because progress) and then the movie was hardly talked about upon release. It more than doubled its budget at the worldwide box office but feels like a forgotten film, which is unfortunate because it's among her best.
I want to make sure that this one is included over more obvious titles like Lost in Translation (hit) or Marie Antoinette (hit) for somewhat selfish reasons: it's really only represented on our site by Rob's review and he really didn't like it, whereas it's one of my favorite movies of 2023. The world is a rainbow! From its opening moments in which a young Priscilla Presley's feet touch the floor to its ending in which she finds the courage and maturity to walk away from Elvis (set to Dolly Parton's "I Will Always Love You"), this is a movie about what it means to be a woman, not just on a personal level but in terms of societal expectations and projections. I love it not only because it presents a Hollywood biopic as filtered through Coppola's sensibilities, but also because it's a great movie.by Rob DiCristino
Dream big!
That business, unlikely as it may seem, is table tennis. It’s Asia’s fastest-growing sport — according to Marty, at least — and an ideal opportunity for any American investor who shares the eager young hustler’s dream of, well, seeing himself on the front of a Wheaties box. But is it a safe bet? Can the kid really win? Don’t ask Marty. He’s never stopped selling himself long enough even to consider the possibility of defeat, the possibility that reigning champs like Bela Kletzki (Géza Röhrig) or up-and-comers like Japan’s Koto Endo (Koto Kawaguchi) could ever compete with his raw, God-given skill. His victory is merely a matter of vision, you see, of convincing friends like Wally (Tyler Okonma) and industry magnates like Milton Rockwell (Shark Tank’s Kevin O’Leary; Yes, seriously) to open their eyes and see the future. That future is now. It’s 1952, for Christ’s sake. The war is over. The Great American Century is just beginning. A generational figure like Marty was not born to toil in a shop, making rent and feeding a pack of children. He was meant, you see, for greatness.
Fueled by a Timothée Chalamet performance that makes Uncut Gems’ Howard Ratner feel like the kind of well-adjusted everyman that its title character would happily crush underfoot, Josh Safdie’s Marty Supreme is nothing short of a new American masterpiece, an exhilarating — and, as with the Safdies’ Gems and Good Time before it, often excruciating — interrogation of our national psyche, a lens aimed squarely at the intoxicating mix of bull-headed arrogance and religious fervor that had the U.S. convinced it was the envy of the world. Written by Safdie and longtime collaborator Ronald Bronstein, it’s also a story about what happens to boys when manhood comes calling, about that fateful day when we’re forced to accept that we’re never going to play Major League Baseball. Never going to invent that million-dollar gadget. Never going to marry that pinup goddess. How, then, do we make our own meaning? How, then, do we find our own bliss? “It’s every man for himself where I come from,” Marty tells someone. How, then, do we know when we get there?
And while Marty Mouser may share DNA with plenty of other Safdie scamps, it’s Timothée Chalamet’s career-defining performance that truly brings him to gangly, chattering, insufferable life. Chalamet feels looser and more agile than he ever has before, giving Marty an unrepentant guile that Paul Atreides would consider unbecoming. And while Safdie and Bronstein have considerably more sympathy for Marty than for, say, Howard Ratner — it’s easier to blame Ratner’s behavior on addiction, whereas Marty is simply a mirror held up to the striver inside us all — each of Marty’s little failures seems laced with a lively undercurrent of Schadenfreude. Even the film’s competition scenes feel like they’re filmed in air quotes, as if we’re indulging Marty’s sports hero aspirations only insofar as they’ll contribute to his self-destruction. Still, Safdie knows that cynicism is the easy way out, and Marty’s eventual acceptance of his real destiny — hint: it’s not the cover of a Wheaties box — overflows with all the joy and purpose he could never quite find at the ping pong table.
None of this focus on Timothée Chalamet should draw from Marty Supreme’s other virtues, chief of which is a galaxy of supporting faces that includes everyone from Penn Gillette to Sandra Bernhard, each of whom shows up for half a scene — seriously, it’s like Oppenheimer in ‘50s New York — without ever slowing down the film’s breakneck momentum. Darius Khondji’s cinematography is impeccable. Jack Fisk’s production design is lush. Safdie and Bronstein’s editing is note-perfect. In other words, while Marty may see fit to cast himself as the underdog, everything in his world has been precisely engineered to support his journey. Everything has been arranged for his benefit. In the end, the real question isn’t whether or not Marty will become an international sporting celebrity, but whether or not Marty will find a level of humility that allows him to appreciate what he already has, whether or not he’ll get out of his own way long enough to count his blessings and learn his place. That greatness he’s been looking for? It’s been right in front of him this entire time. by Adam Thas
Going it alone for a new streaming Christmas movie.
After reading the synopsis and seeing the trailer, it would stand to reason that Oh. What. Fun. is going to be a mix between multiple holiday movies but told from a woman’s point of view. For the much of the first act, that is what it sets up. After the opening narration, the movie begins proper with Claire’s house in the Texas suburbs, where she is obsessed with Christmas decoration and a neighbor she can’t stand (National Lampoons: Christmas Vacation). Slowly we are introduced to her husband, Nick (Denis Leary); her daughter, Taylor (Chloe Grace Moretz); her son, Sammy (Dominic Sessa); her eldest daughter, Channing (Felicity Jones), and Channing’s husband Doug (Jason Schwartzman). Claire only wants two things for Christmas: to make a magical holiday for her family and to be nominated by her family as a “Holiday Mom” on the fictional Zazzy Tims Show. After a series of mix-ups, Claire’s family leaves for a holiday concert and leaves Claire at home (Home Alone). This causes Claire to snap and, since none of her family nominated her, she decides to drive cross country to Burbank and attend the Zazzy Tims Show (Planes, Trains, and Automobiles).
Oh. What. Fun. suffers from what so many ensemble movies suffer from: they’re trying to tell so many different stories that rather than getting one good story you end up getting a handful of half-assed ones. Oh. What. Fun. is clearly trying to channel several Christmas movies, including Christmas Vacation, another holiday classic with a large ensemble cast. The reason Christmas Vacation works is because everyone besides Clark Griswald is a one-note character. No one has an arc besides Clark. The weird part is that Showalter knows this; after all, he wrote one of the funniest and greatest ensemble movies of all time in Wet Hot American Summer. The frustration with Oh. What. Fun. is that there's a movie hiding in there somewhere. There is a good moment with Claire and her husband Nick where they talk about becoming complacent in marriage. There is a side story with Channing and Claire about not feeling supported that just sputters out and feels unearned. Had the movie included more comedy beats and concentrated on what it wanted to be -- a movie told from the women’s point of view -- that might have worked.
There are women in the world that feel unappreciated by their families for any number of reasons. This movie, and particularly Claire, are meant to speak to them. But outside of this demographic, Claire becomes very unlikable. To put it another way, Claire feels unappreciated by her family that has come from all over the country to be with her for the holidays. She leaves her million-dollar house and family in her Audi to get the present no one got her for Christmas. In the end, Claire is vindicated after she finds out how terrible her family’s life was without her.
It's another epic holiday celebration with Patrick and Adam Riske.by Adam Thas & Alison Thas
That one named after a Taylor Swift song. No not that one the other one. The one in Paris.
Putting the predictable plot aside for the moment, I found Champagne Problems to be particularly charming. I believe a lot of that charm is owed to the movie being filmed in both Paris and the Champagne region of France. The film allows us a brief escape from our everyday lives to one that is filled with chateaus, champagne, and fromage. I would argue that if this movie were to be filmed anywhere but France, it would have fallen flat.
Unfortunately, Champagne Problems isn’t doing anything unique, and that’s the main issue. For the first 45 minutes, I really enjoyed this one and then it just kind of sputters out. At one point, the owner of the winery brings everyone to his Chateau, claiming he wants to get to know them before selling him his winery. Ok, a believable request, but then he then proceeds to have them do menial tasks and decorate a tree. Again, believable, but it is very clear that these tasks had no bearing on the outcome of the movie.
Champagne Problems started off great and built up enough good will throughout the first half that I was able to ignore some of the problems that appeared later. The scenery was great, there were a few laughs, but this one was solidly in the middle of the pack as even the “One Year Later” scene we seem to always get couldn’t clean up the relationships that went unearned. You could do worse than this one, but you could also do better. by JB
Reading about this godforsaken thing on the Wikipedia machine, one would think that it is a beloved holiday classic. I recently watched it and proclaimed it “the worst holiday special and the worst re-telling of Dickens ever made.”
The album was withdrawn two weeks after its release because American President John F. Kennedy was assassinated, and Little had Kennedy playing the Ghost of Christmas Present on the album. At one point Little has Kennedy say, “"Scrooge, my life upon the globe is brief; it ends tonight. In fact, it ends as fast as you can say your name.” Continuing to sell the album was seen as being in bad taste.
Imagine my surprise the other night when, binging all the holiday delights on the YouTube machine, I came across a holiday special made for the Canadian Broadcasting Company in 1978. It was shown on HBO in 1979. It won awards. It’s Rich Little’s Christmas Carol, a warmed-over remake of the Scrooge and the Stars album Little had made 16 years earlier. It is one of the most joyless and soul-crushing holiday specials I have ever seen.
CAVEAT: I do think it’s cool that classic Hollywood had a kind of resurgence in the Seventies. Impressionists were popular, and classic films got a new life on television and in reparatory theaters. Hell, even the doomed kids in the original Friday the 13th attempt impressions of Humphrey Bogart, Mae West, and Katherine Hepburn.
The holiday special fails on almost all levels: 1) It is not funny. It was written by Rich Little, but contains no jokes; 2) It has a sluggish pace that kills the comedy; 3) Except for a few scattered vocal reactions from extras, Rich Little is the only actor in the show who speaks. He also narrates; 3) Someone had the bright idea to make this a musical, but the musical numbers and generic and simplistic. They sound like songs written to herald a new grocery store opening. Also, Rich Little cannot sing. This problem is compounded by having Rich Little imitate famous actors who also could not sing, then he has them sing. Say what you will about W.C. Fields, Groucho Marx, and Jimmy Stewart; they were not known for their singing. The musical numbers are a slog; 4) The Dickens’ characters seem to have been assigned to classic Hollywood stars with no rhyme or reason. Little plays Scrooge as W.C. Fields. Scrooge’s old partner Jacob Marley is Richard Nixon. Scrooge’s nephew Fred is Johnny Carson. Scrooge’s old boss Fezziwig is Groucho Marx. Scrooge’s clerk Bob Cratchit is Paul Lynde. Bob Cratchit’s wife is Jean Stapleton as Edith Bunker. Tiny Tim is Truman Capote. The Ghost of Christmas Past is Humphrey Bogart. The Ghost of Christmas Present is Peter Falk as Columbo. The Ghost of Christmas Yet to Come is Peter Sellers as Inspector Clouseau. The two businessmen who implore Scrooge to make a charitable contribution are Laurel & Hardy. John Wayne, George Burns, and James Mason show up as the men on the street commenting on Scrooge’s death. None of this makes any sense. None of the “casting” exists to make any sort of comedic point; it’s just characters that Rich Little is known to imitate.
CAVEAT: I did think Richard Nixon’s Marley, covered with audio tapes instead of chains, was kind of funny. Nixon once stole a piece of America’s soul that we have yet to get back.
What award did your favorite movies get this year?A Dog Can’t Do All Your Homework: Good Boy
Also Recognizes The Peacemaker (1997) Rules: Jay Kelly
Always Listen to Patrick and Mike Recommendations: Nouvelle Vague
Attaboy Elric: The Dead Thing
Best 2025 Burns: The Family McMullen
Best Centerpiece Sequence: Highest 2 Lowest
Better Than I Expected: 28 Years Later
Biggest Disappointment: Mission: Impossible – The Final Reckoning

Could’ve Been an Email: Megadoc
Did I Hallucinate This? Stealing Pulp Fiction
Did You Mean to Make Him Look Like an Asshole? It’s Never Over, Jeff Buckley
Dumbest Shit Ever: I Know What You Did Last Summer
Enough Already: Superman
Feels Like a Movie from 1993: The Day the Earth Blew Up: A Looney Tunes Movie
Feels Like a Movie from 1996: One of Them Days
Feels Like a Movie from 2007: Fight or Flight
Good 2025 Burns: Millers in Marriage
Good Drama, Bad Comedy: Materialists

Good One Scene/Bad Another: Together
“Heartbreak Feels Good in a Place Like This”: The Life of Chuck
Hidden Gem: Eephus
Homeboy Looks Just Like Cruise Lestat: Frankenstein
I Didn’t Mind It: Caught Stealing
I Dunno…He Probably Had Good Times Too? John Candy: I Like Me
I Dunno…Recommended? Karate Kid: Legends
I Give It Tree and a Half Branches: Train Dreams
I’m the Only Person Who Saw: Not Just a Goof
It’s Fine/She’s FINE: Oh, Hi!

It’s Kinda Just There: Freakier Friday
Like a Saturday Morning Cartoon Show: Predator: Badlands
Like Eating at Applebee’s When You Wanted to Eat at Chili’s: Paddington in Peru
Most Canadian (complimentary): The Shrouds
Most Clamoring for an MTV Movie Awards Nomination for Best Villain: Sinners
Most Cognizant of People Getting Meals In: Springsteen: Deliver Me from Nowhere
Most Dollar Tree: The Fetus
Most Geico Slasher Movie Commercial: Clown in a Cornfield
Most Intermittently Funny: Friendship
Most Obnoxious: The Monkey

Most Old Country Buffet: The Alto Knights
Most Patting on its Own Back: Heart Eyes
Most Pennywise: Weapons
Most Pleasant: Sacramento
Most Product Placement: Oh. What. Fun.
Most Surprisingly Violent: Novocaine
Most Sweet: Nonnas
Most Tedious: Mickey 17
Most Tense: One Battle After Another
Most Undercooked: Shelby Oaks

Most Underrated: The Surfer
Most Unnecessary: Lilo & Stitch
Most Walmart $5 Bin: Final Destination Bloodlines
Most Wealth Flaunting: Being Eddie
Movie I Can’t Believe I Saw in Theaters: Witchboard
Movie I Like Less Than Everyone Else: Black Bag
Movie I Like More Than Everyone Else: Honey Don’t!
Pleasant Surprise: Dangerous Animals
Pretty Good: Ballerina
Saves Me a Trip to the Academy Museum: Jaws at 50: The Definitive Inside Story

Seems Irresponsibly Expensive: F1
So Bad It Should Be Against the Law: High Rollers
So Poorly Made It’s Uncomfortable: Happy Gilmore 2
The Ideal January Movie: Companion
“The Wood-man’s Done It Again”: Bugonia
Ugh: Thunderbolts*
We Misunderstood Why People Like This: Den of Thieves 2: Pantera
What Are Movies? A Merry Little Ex-Mas
Will Play Like Gangbusters at Fraternities: The Long Walk
Worst Movie: Love Hurts
Worst Product Placement for Orange Juice: Presence
Worst Third Act: The Running Man
Worst Twist: Relay

WTF: The Threesome
Yikes: Bad Shabbos
“YOU BLEW IT” (Robert De Niro voice): The Naked Gun
You Can Stop Any Time Now: Jurassic World Rebirth