Why has the doctrine of adoption received so little attention in Reformed theology?

In this live episode of Christ the Center, Camden Bucey is joined by Jonathan Master and Matt Holst at Shiloh Orthodox Presbyterian Church in Raleigh, North Carolina, to discuss John L. Girardeau’s rich and pastoral treatment of adoption. The conversation explores why adoption should not be collapsed into justification or regeneration, how it addresses our alienation from God, and why it matters so deeply for prayer, suffering, assurance, and the Christian life.

Along the way, the panel reflects on Girardeau’s life and ministry, Adam’s original sonship, Christ’s filial obedience, the believer’s inheritance in Christ, and the comfort of knowing God not only as Judge, but as Father.

This is a warm and theologically substantial discussion on one of the most beautiful and neglected doctrines in Scripture.

Watch on YouTube

Chapters

• 00:00 Introduction and live recording at Shiloh OPC
• 01:45 Why discuss John L. Girardeau on adoption?
• 03:12 Who was John L. Girardeau?
• 09:52 Why adoption is such an important doctrine
• 14:05 Why adoption has been neglected in Reformed theology
• 17:50 Courtroom and family room: justification and adoption
• 23:19 Adam’s original sonship and what was lost in the fall
• 27:07 Christ’s sonship and key Christological distinctions
• 33:14 The pastoral comfort of adoption
• 37:33 Adoption, suffering, and inheritance
• 41:17 God’s name on his people and the hope of glory
• 43:24 How adoption transforms prayer
• 50:11 The Father’s generosity toward his children
• 53:04 Final reflections and conclusion

Participants: Camden Bucey, Jonathan Master, Matt Holst

What is a Presbyterian? Is Presbyterianism merely a style of church government, or is it a coherent biblical and theological system? In this episode, we welcome Matthew Adams and Ben Ratliff for a lively conversation on Presbyterian identity, church government, and why polity still matters.

The discussion begins with Matt Adams’s article “Grassroots Presbyterianism ≠ Congregationalism” and expands into a broader exploration of Presbyterian ecclesiology. Along the way, the panel considers plurality and parity of elders, the role of presbyteries and general assemblies, the importance of connectionalism, and the ways accountability serves the peace, purity, and unity of the church.

They also reflect on differences in ecclesial culture among the PCA, OPC, and URCNA, discuss overtures and church courts, and offer practical encouragement for ordinary church members who want to be active, faithful Presbyterians in their local congregations.

Matthew Adams serves as Senior Pastor of First Presbyterian Church in Dillon, South Carolina. In addition to his pastoral ministry, Adams serves as a council member for the Gospel Reformation Network and co-hosts the podcast Larger for Life.

Ben Ratliff serves as Associate Pastor of Covenant Presbyterian Church in Cleveland, Mississippi. Ratliff is also a co-host of the podcast Polity Matters, where he helps lead conversations on Presbyterian polity and church government.

Watch on YouTube

Chapters

• 00:00 Introduction
• 01:49 Why Presbyterian government matters
• 03:12 Grassroots Presbyterianism is not congregationalism
• 08:56 Why the confusion persists
• 11:02 Different Presbyterian cultures: PCA, OPC, and URCNA
• 14:25 Overtures, church courts, and how change happens
• 22:27 What Presbyterianism is
• 25:50 Plurality, parity, and connectionalism
• 32:48 Accountability, freedom, and the well-being of the church
• 39:27 How church members can participate
• 48:36 Polity Matters, Larger for Life, and final thoughts

Participants: Ben Ratliff, Camden Bucey, Matt Adams

In this special crossover episode with Dead Presbyterians Society recorded at Greenville Presbyterian Theological Seminary, Camden Bucey joins Jonathan Master, President of Greenville Seminary, for a conversation on the life, method, and enduring relevance of Geerhardus Vos (1862–1949). Vos stands as a remarkable bridge figure: Dutch by birth, deeply shaped by continental Reformed theology and close friendship with Herman Bavinck, yet firmly planted in the American confessional Presbyterian tradition as the first chair of biblical theology at Old Princeton Seminary alongside B. B. Warfield.

Drs. Bucey and Master explore Vos’s foundational distinction between biblical theology and systematic theology—and why both are indispensable for faithful exegesis and preaching. Biblical theology, which Vos himself preferred to call “the history of special revelation,” reads Scripture as the organic, progressive unfolding of God’s redemptive acts in history—from the protoevangelium in Genesis 3:15 to the consummation of all things in Christ. That redemptive-historical framework opens up notoriously difficult passages (Hebrews 6, the unforgivable sin) in ways systematics alone cannot. The conversation also covers Vos’s two-age eschatology, his key works (Biblical Theology, The Pauline Eschatology, Grace and Glory, The Teaching of Jesus Concerning the Kingdom of God and the Church), and the question of why Vos remained at Princeton when Machen and others departed.

Be sure to subscribe to the Dead Presbyterians Society podcast from Greenville Presbyterian Theological Seminary.

Watch on YouTube

Chapters

• 0:00 Introduction: Camden at Greenville Seminary
• 1:08 Greenville Seminary Launches Confessional.org
• 3:47 Geerhardus Vos: Bridge Figure Between Princeton and the Continent
• 9:03 What Is Biblical Theology? The History of Special Revelation
• 13:49 Why We Need Both Biblical Theology and Systematics
• 16:33 “You Cannot Do Either Without the Other”
• 22:19 Why Did Vos Remain at Princeton?
• 27:48 Vos’s Key Works
• 31:39 The “Vibe of Vos”: Redemptive History in Practice
• 37:44 The Two-Age Eschatology: Already and Not Yet
• 40:33 Closing Remarks

Participants: Camden Bucey, Jonathan Master

In a culture saturated with self-help strategies, identity politics, and the language of “manifesting,” where do Christians turn for a stable, coherent sense of self? On this episode of Christ the Center, Camden Bucey sits down with pastor and author Justin N. Poythress to explore the deep theological roots of the identity crisis plaguing our age. Drawing from his new book, Who Am I? And What Am I Doing With My Life? Finding Stability and Purpose in Jesus (The Good Book Company), Poythress argues that only Christ can rightly function as our “master identity”—the organizing center beneath every role, relationship, and calling. Work, sexuality, politics, and even parenting all fail catastrophically when elevated to that ultimate position, because none of them can bear the weight of the human soul.

At the heart of the conversation lies a powerful biblical framework: we are in Christ while also being conformed to his image. Romans 8:29 declares that God predestined His people to be conformed to the image of His Son—a settled identity and a lifelong trajectory of growth. Poythress unpacks how 2 Corinthians 3:18 reframes the secular obsession with “manifesting” into the biblical practice of beholding Christ, the true mechanism of transformation. The episode also explores the church as a “thick community” designed for the kind of multi-dimensional, embodied relationships that curated online personas can never provide. For pastors, elders, and anyone seeking maturity in Christ, the takeaway is both liberating and compelling: the Christian life is a matter of becoming what you already are in Christ.

Watch on YouTube

Chapters

• 00:07 Introduction
• 08:50 Master and Sub-Identities
• 13:53 Identity as a Theological Issue
• 16:58 Romans 8:29
• 21:22 Manifesting vs. Beholding
• 28:09 The Means of Grace
• 32:19 Thick Communities
• 41:12 Authenticity
• 46:14 Work, Sexuality, and Politics as Functional Religions
• 51:12 Becoming What You Are in Christ
• 56:29 Conclusion

Participants: Camden Bucey, Justin N. Poythress

Dr. Robert Letham joins Lane Tipton and Camden Bucey to discuss Dr. Letham’s recent book The Eternal Son (P&R Publishing). Their conversation presses into a simple but urgent claim: Christology is not a side department of theology—it is the living center. When the church loses clarity about who the Son is, the gospel itself becomes unclear because salvation depends on the identity of the Savior. They also explore why the church must listen carefully to the whole ecumenical tradition, especially the often-neglected debates after Chalcedon.

Dr. Letham explains why it matters that the acting subject in the Gospels is the eternal Son, who assumes a true human nature without change in his divine person. From there, they engage contemporary confusions—especially biblicism that isolates Scripture from the church’s confession—and they address the claim that Christ was “adopted” at the resurrection, showing how such proposals unravel both orthodox Christology and the gracious character of adoption for believers.

Watch on YouTube

Chapters

• 00:07 Introduction
• 02:04 This Book within the Trilogy
• 04:36 Christ and the Center of Christianity
• 11:05 Reading the Bible in Isolation
• 16:44 The Ecumenical Councils After Chalcedon
• 26:44 The Pre-Existent Son
• 30:24 Christology from Below
• 35:54 The Doctrine of Adoption
• 44:48 Twin Errors of Christology and Soteriology
• 53:15 An Exhortation to Re-Examine the Historical Confession of the Church
• 56:19 Conclusion

Participants: Camden Bucey, Lane G. Tipton, Robert Letham

In this episode, Dan Ragusa speaks about Letters from America (Reformed Forum). Between 1935 and 1940, Cornelius Van Til (1895–1987) wrote twenty-four letters from America for the Dutch magazine De Reformatie at the invitation of its editor Klaas Schilder (1890–1952). Daniel Ragusa’s translation presents these letters in English for the first time.

Letters from America opens a window into a critical moment in Reformed history—when orthodox and confessional Presbyterianism in America was under siege from both modernism and the rising influence of Barthianism, which Van Til labeled “the new modernism.” Ragusa introduces these letters by situating them within the broader relationship between the Dutch Reformed in the Netherlands and the orthodox Presbyterians in America—a relationship that reaches back to the seventeenth century.

Van Til’s wartime-like correspondences—written in the heat of theological conflict—offer a firsthand account of the spiritual and ecclesiastical upheavals of the era. Through Van Til’s eyes, fixed steadfastly on his risen and reigning Lord, readers witness pivotal moments in American Presbyterian history, among them J. Gresham Machen’s trial, deposition, and sudden death; the founding of Westminster Theological Seminary and the evangelistic work of its graduates; and the formation of the Presbyterian Church of America and its subsequent renaming as the Orthodox Presbyterian Church.

These letters bring to life a pivotal chapter in the defense and development of the Reformed faith that helps us to make sense of our present ecclesiastical and theological landscape.

Watch on YouTube

Chapters

• 00:00:07 Introduction
• 00:06:13 Upcoming Seminar in Raleigh, NC
• 00:09:29 Dr. Ragusa’s Introduction to Van Til’s Dutch Letters
• 00:20:54 Van Til’s Concern for the Church
• 00:29:16 Highlights of the Letters
• 00:36:19 Van Til’s Hope for the Church
• 00:42:38 The Afscheiding (Secession) of 1834
• 00:57:46 A Vision for the Future of the Church
• 01:06:05 Remaining Faithful Today
• 01:12:15 Conclusion

Participants: Camden Bucey, Dan Ragusa

In this episode, we continue engaging Geerhardus Vos’s treatment of repentance and the righteousness of the kingdom. The discussion begins by clarifying the close relationship between faith and repentance: Both are saving graces, sovereignly gifted by God, inseparably joined in conversion, yet not identical. Faith uniquely receives and rests upon Christ for justification, while repentance—though necessary—never functions as the instrument of union with Christ or the ground of God’s verdict. This careful distinction protects the gospel from subtle moralism and keeps repentance in its proper place as fruit flowing from mercy apprehended in Christ.

Vos then situates repentance within Jesus’ proclamation of the kingdom: Repentance corresponds to the kingdom’s righteousness-aspect, just as faith corresponds to its power-aspect. Repentance is not a meritorious condition for entry, but the moral-spiritual “fitness” that belongs to life under God’s righteous reign. The episode explores Vos’s “vernacular of repentance” in the Gospels—regret, inner reversal, and outward turning—showing that biblical repentance is comprehensive, God-centered, and transformative. Far from mere remorse or isolated moral adjustment, repentance is a whole-life reorientation toward God, forming a people whose inner and outer life increasingly reflects the righteousness of the kingdom.

Watch on YouTube

Chapters

• 00:00 2026 Raleigh, NC Seminar
• 02:19 Introduction
• 04:40 Faith and Repentance
• 11:42 The Connection to the Kingdom of God
• 16:05 The Logical and Instrumental Priority of Faith
• 22:19 Aspects of the Kingdom
• 32:47 The Vernacular of Repentance
• 37:05 The Universal Demand of Repentance
• 46:36 Conclusion

Participants: Camden Bucey, Lane G. Tipton

In this episode we welcome church historian Stephen O. Presley to explore the life, theology, and enduring relevance of Irenaeus of Lyons. Writing in the latter half of the second century, Irenaeus emerges not merely as a polemicist against Gnosticism but as a deeply pastoral theologian—one whose doctrine, biblical interpretation, and ecclesial commitments were inseparably bound to the life of the church.

Presley highlights Irenaeus’s vision of Scripture as a unified, Christ-centered story, summed up in his doctrine of recapitulation: All things find their meaning, coherence, and redemption in Christ, the true head of humanity. Against both ancient Gnosticism and modern disembodied spiritualities, Irenaeus affirms the goodness of creation, the integrity of the human person, and the necessity of catechesis rooted in the rule of faith. For today’s church—navigating doctrinal confusion, cultural fragmentation, and questions of discipleship—Irenaeus offers a compelling model of theological method that is biblical, confessional, pastoral, and profoundly Christ-centered.

Dr. Stephen O. Presley is Director of Education and Engagement and Senior Fellow for Religion and Public Life at the Center for Religion, Culture and Democracy and Associate Professor of Church History at Southern Seminary. He is the author of Irenaeus of Lyons: His Impact and Life (Christian Focus) and Cultural Sanctification: Engaging the World like the Early Church (Eerdmans).

Watch on YouTube

Chapters

• 00:07 Introduction
• 01:47 The Center for Religion, Culture, and Democracy
• 04:48 How to Pronounce Irenaeus
• 08:48 The Early Church
• 13:31 Irenaeus as a Church Theologian
• 16:00 The Rule of Faith
• 20:36 Reading Scripture
• 26:11 Recapitulation
• 30:18 Against Gnosticism
• 33:38 Christ as the New Adam
• 44:07 Surprises While Writing the Book
• 46:39 Conclusion

Participants: Camden Bucey, Stephen Presley

In this episode of Christ the Center, Camden Bucey and Lane Tipton discuss a deceptively brief but theologically weighty section of Geerhardus Vos’s Biblical Theology, exploring Jesus’s critique of first-century Jewish ethics. Far from addressing merely surface-level moral failures, Vos shows that Jesus exposes a deeper religious collapse—one marked by practical deism and pervasive self-centeredness. When God’s glory is displaced as the center of ethical life, obedience becomes external, fragmented, and ultimately irreligious.

This conversation presses the listener to consider how these same distortions reappear across church history and into the present—whether in moralistic fundamentalism, liberal Protestant ethics, or debates surrounding the New Perspective on Paul. The antidote Vos commends is not tighter rules or refined casuistry, but a recovery of true religion: life coram Deo, grounded in union with Christ, animated by delight in God himself as our supreme reward. In Christ, obedience is restored to its proper place as worship, flowing from grace rather than self-reliance.

Watch on YouTube

Chapters

• 00:07 Introduction
• 07:32 Jesus’s Critique of Jewish Ethics
• 18:07 Common Distortions of Ethics
• 32:55 Modern Expressions of the Same Error
• 40:46 Von Harnack and the Essence of Christianity
• 44:08 The New Perspective on Paul
• 49:35 The Antidote
• 52:28 Conclusion

Participants: Camden Bucey, Lane G. Tipton

In this episode of Christ the Center, we welcome Josiah Leinbach to discuss William Whitaker’s A Disputation on Holy Scripture—a monumental sixteenth-century defense of sola Scriptura, newly edited and republished by Prolego Press. Written in 1588 against leading Roman Catholic theologians such as Robert Bellarmine, Whitaker’s work offers a comprehensive treatment of Scripture’s authority, canon, clarity, and sufficiency. Leinbach explains how Whitaker combined Renaissance humanism with scholastic rigor, engaging Scripture, church history, and patristic sources to show that Protestant convictions about Scripture were neither novel nor reactionary, but deeply rooted in the catholic tradition of the church.

The conversation also explores the modern relevance of Whitaker’s work—especially amid contemporary debates over authority, tradition, and ecumenism. Leinbach reflects on how advances in historical and textual scholarship have confirmed many of the Reformers’ arguments, while Rome’s own positions have shifted over time. Whitaker’s insistence on the perspicuity of Scripture, the singular infallibility of God’s Word, and the Spirit’s inward testimony offers not only apologetic clarity but deep pastoral comfort. This episode invites listeners to recover confidence in Scripture as God’s clear and sufficient means of revealing Christ to his people.

Watch on YouTube

Chapters

• 00:07 Introduction
• 01:08 William Whitaker’s A Disputation on Holy Scripture
• 07:25 Leinbach’s Transition from History to Machine Learning
• 18:10 Whitaker’s Polemical Approach
• 22:03 The Canon of Scripture
• 25:50 The Perspicuity of Scripture
• 28:29 Biblical Authority
• 32:02 The Testimony of the Holy Spirit
• 35:27 Ecumenical Dialogue Yesterday and Today
• 48:10 Future Works
• 52:25 Conclusion

Participants: Camden Bucey, Josiah Leinbach

In this episode, Camden Bucey and Marcus Mininger reflect together on Resurrection and Redemption by Richard B. Gaffin Jr.—a work that has profoundly shaped Reformed biblical theology over the past half century. Rather than offering a technical review, the conversation unfolds as a guided meditation on the book’s central claim: Christ’s resurrection is not a theological afterthought but the controlling center of Paul’s soteriology and eschatology. Gaffin’s careful exegesis helps readers see how redemption is inseparable from resurrection life in union with the risen Christ.

This discussion is part of Reformed Forum’s broader effort to offer conversational commentaries on formative Reformed texts—books that have formed us as pastors and theologians. Bucey and Mininger highlight why Resurrection and Redemption remains so enduringly fruitful: It teaches the church to think biblically about salvation, not as a static transaction, but as participation in the resurrected life of Christ. The result is theology that serves the pulpit, strengthens assurance, and orients the Christian life toward the hope of glory already secured in the risen Lord.

Watch on YouTube

Chapters

• 00:00:07 Introduction
• 00:01:56 International Cohorts and Reading Guides
• 00:10:31 Encountering Resurrection and Redemption
• 00:16:15 The Title and Purpose of the Book
• 00:26:18 The Discipline of Biblical Theology
• 00:32:56 Paul as Theologian
• 00:51:23 Redemptive-Historical Epochs
• 00:59:44 The Occasional Nature of Paul’s Writings
• 01:08:27 Conclusion

Participants: Camden Bucey, Marcus Mininger