OSCARS: What Were They Thinking?!

Atomic Entertainment

  • 1 hour 9 minutes
    ENCORE 1986 - Back to the Oscars (Again)

    Due to a scheduling snafu - we don't have a new episode ready for you today! So, we're replaying one of our favorites (and an early one many of you may have missed!) While Out of Africa and The Color Purple were battling it out (22 nominations between them) for Oscar glory -- another film was all but ignored in all the major categories -- despite dominating the box office that year. But if we could jump into a Delorean and go back in time -- would we perhaps bestow this beloved action/comedy with some Oscar love? We'll be back with the 1997 Oscars later this week! Thanks!

    Movies Mentioned

    Recommended

    *Out of Africa

    *The Color Purple

    *Kiss of the Spider Woman

    *Prizzi’s Honor

    *Witness

    **Back to the Future

    Rambo: First Blood Pt. 2

    Ladyhawke

    The English Patient

    Evita

    Butterfly

    Trip to Bountiful 

    *Agnes of God

    Sweet Dreams

    **Tootsie

    *Cocoon

    Twice in a Lifetime

    Ice Pirates

    Murphy’s Romance

    *Runaway Train

    Jagged Edge

    Things Change

    *Trading Places

    The Story of Alexander Graham Bell

    Cocoon 2

    The Way We Were

    *Absence of Malice

    *Three Days of the Condor

    **They Shoot Horses Don’t They?

    *Ran

    C.H.U.D.

    C.H.U.D. 2: Bud the C.H.U.D.

    The Official Story

    *Parasite

    *Mask

    The Phantom of the Opera

    *The Mask

    *Remo Williams: the Adventure Begins

    A Chorus Line

    *White Nights

    *Silverado

    *Young Sherlock Holmes

    Return to Oz

    The Black Hole

    **The Sting

    **Quiz Show

    *Ordinary People

    *Save the Tiger

    Last Tango in Paris

    *The Last Detail

    **Serpico

    **The Natural

    *Barefoot in the Park

    *Butch Cassidy & Sundance Kid

    *The Candidate

    *Purple Rose of Cairo

    *Brazil

    Rifkin’s Festival

    *Midnight in Paris

    *Radio Days

    *Crimes and Misdemeanors

    *Bananas

    *Take the Money and Run

    *Manhattan

    *Stardust Memories

    12 Years a Slave

    *Do the Right Thing

    **Boyz in the Hood

    *Malcolm X

    *Glory

    *Training Day

    *A Beautiful Mind

    Scent of a Woman

    Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

    9 February 2026, 8:01 am
  • 1 hour 7 minutes
    BONUS - 2026 Oscars: Conversations about the Nominations

    Hey Oscar fans — with the recent Oscar nominations we felt it was only fitting for our Oscars podcast to talk about them... Even though it goes against the theme of our show which uses the ‘test of time’ to see what really deserved to win or be nominated. Despite that, we still have thoughts and hot takes!  Join “Tex” and Mark as we discuss the nominees, make predictions, point out snubs and use everything we’ve learned making this show to try and understand what the Academy was thinking!  As always thanks for listening!


    Contact us: [email protected]

    Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

    2 February 2026, 6:10 am
  • 1 hour 5 minutes
    BONUS - The Fabulous Films Noir of 1946!

    1946 was an extraordinary year for film noir—so much so, even the Academy had to take notice. As Hollywood plunged into the shadows, moral ambiguity, and hard-boiled despair, the Oscars recognized standouts like Notorious, The Killers, and The Stranger. But with so much darkness flooding the screen, plenty of essential classics were left behind. Films like Gilda, The Postman Always Rings Twice, and The Big Sleep—now pillars of the noir canon—went largely unnoticed at the time. In this bonus episode, we celebrate a truly great year for film noir, revisiting fourteen unforgettable films and exploring what the Academy saw, what it missed, and why 1946 remains a defining moment for one of cinema’s most enduring styles.


    Films Mentioned

    *Recommended

    **It’s a Matter of Life and Death (not noir)

    **The Killers

    **Notorious

    **The Stranger

    *The Spiral Staircase

    *The Blue Dahlia

    *The 7th Veil (not considered noir)

    **Gilda

    **The Postman Always Rings Twice

    *The Big Sleep

    *The Dark Mirror

    *The Strange Love of Martha Ivers

    **The Locket

    *Shock!

    *The Strange Woman

    *The Glass Key

    **This Gun For Hire

    Saigon

    **Double Indemnity

    **Too Late for Tears

    **To Have and Have Not

    Confidential Agent

    *The Lady From Shanghai

    **The Magnificent Ambersons (not noir)

    **Citizen Kane  (not noir)


    Contact us: [email protected]

    Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

    26 January 2026, 6:20 am
  • 1 hour 16 minutes
    1947 - It’s a “Wonderful” VS. “Best” Oscar

    Hey there Oscar fans — Bruce is back and we are excited to bring you a super fun episode that looks back at the 1947 Oscars for the films of 1946 — yet another simply outstanding year of movies. And while this year is highlighted by a heavyweight battle between ‘The Best Years of Our Lives’ and ‘It’s a Wonderful Life’…  You can pretty much name any genre and find an incredible movie to suit your taste — many of which are still talked about today.  But with so many great movies this year, it’s remarkable how many A+ films didn’t make the cut.  So, did the right films win?  Were the right actors & actresses nominated?  And what classic films from Hollywood’s golden era should you be adding to your watch-list?  Get ready to find all that out and more.  And remember, every time you leave us a 5-star review — Bruce eats some wings!  Thanks for listening!


    Films Mentioned - (*Recommended)

    **Duel in the Sun

    **The Best Years of our Lives

    The Jolson Story

    Blue Skies

    Saratoga Trunk

    *The Razor’s Edge

    Night and Day

    *Notorious

    *The Yearling

    Till the Clouds Roll By

    **It’s a Wonderful Life

    Anna and the King of Siam

    *The King and I

    *Henry V

    **The Killers

    **Brief Encounter

    *The Big Sleep

    **My Darling Clementine

    **The Stranger

    *The Spiral Staircase

    *The Dark Mirror

    *The Human Comedy

    *National Velvet

    **The Postman Always Rings Twice

    *To Each His Own

    *Sister Kenny

    **Gilda

    *The Seventh Veil

    *The Blue Dahlia

    **Children of Paradise

    *Road to Utopia

    **Rome, Open City

    Vacation From Marriage

    *The Strange Love of Martha Ivers

    **Shoe Shine


    Email us at: [email protected]

    Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

    19 January 2026, 5:00 am
  • 22 minutes 51 seconds
    Bonus - Golden Globes 2026 Reaction

    Hey Oscars fans -- before recording earlier this week, Bruce, "Tex" and Mark had a brief conversation about the recent Golden Globe Awards. Here is our theorizing on how this bodes for the upcoming Oscar nominations as well as some thoughts on the movies we've seen (so far) from 2025. Enjoy.

    Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

    16 January 2026, 7:24 pm
  • 1 hour 27 minutes
    Bonus - Mr. Kubrick, or: How I Learned to Stop Worrying and Love Losing Oscars

    Hey Oscar fans, we’ve got a special treat for you — another episode on yet another luminary director, responsible for some of the greatest movies of all time — only to have the Academy shrug and vote for something/someone else.  Granted a lot of Stanley Kubrick’s movies may have felt ahead of their time, or were in stiff competition with other great movies.  But the fact that you can go to Stanley Kubrick’s estate (or museum) and not see an Oscar for Best Director (or Best Picture) among his possessions feels like an Oscar hate crime.  Sit back and enjoy as “Tex” and Mark examine Kubrick’s legendary filmography with an eye on finding a path to giving Kubrick his much deserved Oscar glory.  A must-listen for film nerds and casual film fans alike!


    Films Mentioned

    (*Recommended )

    *Day of the Fight (doc short)

    *Day of the Fight (feature)

    Flying Padre (doc short)

    The Seafarers (doc short)

    Fear and Desire

    Killer’s Kiss

    *The Killing

    Around the World in 80 Days

    *Giant

    The King and I

    The Ten Commandments

    Friendly Persuasion

    *Paths of Glory

    *Bridge on the River Kwai

    *12 Angry Men

    Peyton Place

    Sayonara

    *Witness for the Prosecution

    *Spartacus

    *Ben-Hur

    *The Apartment

    *Elmer Gantry

    The Alamo

    Sons and Lovers

    The Sundowners

    *Psycho

    Lolita

    *Lawrence of Arabia

    *To Kill a Mockingbird

    *Dr. Strangelove, or:  How I Learned to Stop Worrying and Love the Bomb

    My Fair Lady

    *Becket

    *Mary Poppins

    *Zorba the Greek

    *2001:  A Space Odyssey

    Oliver!

    Funny Girl

    *The Lion in Winter

    Rachel, Rachel

    Romeo and Juliet

    *The Producers

    *A Clockwork Orange

    *The French Connection

    Fiddler on the Roof

    *The Last Picture Show

    Nicholas and Alexandria

    Sunday Bloody Sunday

    *Barry Lyndon

    *One Flew Over the Cuckoos Nest

    *Dog Day Afternoon

    *Jaws

    *Nashville

    *Amarcord

    *Amadeus

    *The Fireman’s Ball

    *The Shining

    The Shining (Stephen King version)

    *Full Metal Jacket

    The Last Emperor

    *Broadcast News

    *Fatal Attraction

    Hope and Glory

    *Moonstruck

    *My Life as a Dog

    *Wall Street

    *Eyes Wide Shut


    Contact The Oscars: WWTT?:   [email protected]

    Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

    12 January 2026, 5:00 am
  • 1 hour 5 minutes
    Bonus - A Few Good Man: A Tribute to Rob Reiner

    Hey Oscar WWTT? Fans — as we all know, Rob Reiner and his wife Michelle were brutally taken from us on Dec. 14th, 2025.  This episode is a tribute to the amazing films & legendary career he left behind. We mostly concentrate on his first 10 films — 9 of which range from very good to excellent.  And while Mr. Reiner never seemed to get the love he deserved from The Academy, his films stand the test of time by being some of our all-time favorite films.  From Spinal Tap to The Princess Bride to Harry Met Sally & A Few Good Men - Rob Reiner’s work was imbued with his love of humor, relatability and character of conviction.  And while he might not have an Oscar — he has our enduring love and admiration. He will be missed.  As always, thanks for listening.


    Films Mentioned 

    (*)Recommended

    *This is Spinal Tap

    *The Princess Bride

    *When Harry Met Sally

    *Misery

    *Stand By Me

    *A Few Good Men

    *Best in Show

    *Waiting for Guffman

    *For Your Consideration

    *The Sure Thing

    Porky’s

    *The Shawshank Redemption

    *Apt Pupil

    *The Green Mile

    Winter People

    *Just Friends

    *Carrie

    *The Dead Zone

    Cujo

    *Goodfellas

    *Dances With Wolves

    *12 Angry Men

    *Witness For the Prosecution

    *Unforgiven

    *The Crying Game

    *Howard’s End

    Scent of a Woman

    The Player

    Enchanted April

    A River Runs Through It

    North

    *The American President

    *Mr. Smith Goes to Washington

    *Ghosts of Mississippi

    The Bucket List

    *LBJ

    Spinal Tap 2:  The End Continues


    Contact us: [email protected]

    Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

    5 January 2026, 5:00 am
  • 1 hour 31 minutes
    1958 - Oscar on the River Kwai

    Hey Oscar fans, Bruce is back and we’re taking on one of the greatest, unsung years in movie history.  The nominees are mostly great.  The non-nominees are also pretty great.  And the test of time needs to be graded on a curve because so many of these films continue to resonate today. This episode is a treat for anyone who loves and appreciates truly classic films.  And if you’re not already a classic film lover, these are the films that will make you one!  And with two of the greatest courtroom dramas in movie history vying for best picture against one of the all-time greatest war epics — one could deliberate for years to try and get it right. Luckily we rest our case in just over an hour!  Enjoy and as always, thanks for listening!  


    Films Mentioned

    (* Recommended)


    1/2* Sayonara

    1/2* Peyton Place

    **Bridge on the River Kwai

    **12 Angry Men

    **Witness for the Prosecution

    The Teahouse of the August Moon

    *Viva Zapata

    *The King and I

    Return to Peyton Place

    **A Face in the Crowd

    **Paths of Glory

    *The Sweet Smell of Success

    *The Seventh Seal

    *What’s Up Tiger Lily?

    *A Hatful of Rain

    *The Cranes are Flying

    *Wild is the Wind

    Raintree County

    *Gone With the Wind

    *A Place in the Sun

    *Valley of the Dolls

    *Lawrence of Arabia

    *Oliver Twist

    *Great Expectations

    *Brief Encounter

    *Summertime

    **Double Indemnity

    *The Lost Weekend

    **Stalag 17

    *Sabrina 

    **Sunset Boulevard

    *The Spirit of St. Louis

    *Love in the Afternoon

    *The Tin Star

    *3:10 to Yuma

    *Forty Guns

    *Gunfight at the OK Coral

    **Star Wars

    *The Great Escape

    Man of a Thousand Faces

    *Jamaica Inn

    Heaven Knows Mr. Allison

    September

    Where Love Has Gone

    The Rose Tattoo

    *The Three Faces of Eve

    *Kind Hearts and Coronets

    *Rome, Open City

    *Funny Face

    Nights of Cabiria 

    **The Bicycle Thieves

    *The Bachelor Party

    A Farewell to Arms

    For Whom the Bell Tolls

    Designing Woman

    *I, Vitelloni

    *The Gunfighter

    *Duel in the Sun

    *Gentleman’s Agreement

    *To Kill a Mockingbird

    *The Omen

    *The Enemy Below

    *The Little Foxes

    *The Turning Point

    *The Color Purple

    The Joker is Wild

    *The Bride of Frankenstein

    Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

    29 December 2025, 6:29 am
  • 54 minutes 32 seconds
    Encore: Holiday Movie Special

    Happy Holidays Oscar fans! This week's episode is an encore performance of our previous holiday episode -- where Bruce and "Tex" discuss their favorite holiday movies and explore which ones got some holiday cheer from The Academy and which ones received a lump of coal. Enjoy!

    Movies mentioned:

    Just Friends (written by "Tex")

    It Nearly Wasn't Christmas (starring Bruce!)

    White Christmas

    A Christmas Story

    Gremlins

    Krampus

    Bad Santa

    Trading Places

    Silent Night, Deadly Night

    Black Christmas

    Die Hard

    (*Deck the Halls-referenced)

    Jingle All the Way

    Christmas with the Kranks

    It's a Wonderful Life

    Miracle on 34th Street

    Holiday Land 

    The Night Before Christmas

    Toy Tinkers

    Scrooge

    Scrooged

    Home Alone

    The Nightmare Before Christmas

    The Preacher's Wife

    The Bishop's Wife

    How the Grinch Stole Christmas

    The Polar Express

    The Holdovers

    8 Crazy Nights

    An American Tail

    The Night Before

    Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

    22 December 2025, 7:01 am
  • 1 hour 22 minutes
    Bonus - You Talking To Me, Oscar?

    Hey Oscar fans, this week’s bonus episode covers the Director nearest & dearest to our hearts — Mr. Martin Scorsese!  After discussing his breakthrough Oscar win (finally!) on the previous show (The 2007 Oscars) — we're looking back at Scorsese’s film career prior to The Departed and discussing which of his films could’ve/should’ve been nominated or won.  Along the way we give our thoughts, recommendations and disclaimers on tons of Scorsese films as well as behind the scenes stories, including the time Adam’s wife shoved Scorsese at the premiere of The Aviator.  If you love pure cinema — you will love this episode!  As always thanks for listening!

    Films Mentioned

    (*Recommended)  

    *The Big Shave (short)

    Who’s That Knocking at my Door?

    *American Boy (Doc)

    *Pulp Fiction

    Boxcar Bertha

    Bonnie & Clyde

    Obsessions (on Youtube)

    *Mean Streets

    *Blackmail!

    *Murder!

    *Alice Doesn’t Live Here Anymore

    *Mr. Scorsese (Doc)

    *Taxi Driver

    *Rocky

    *All the President’s Men

    *Network

    Face to Face

    Seven Beauties

    *Pickpocket

    New York, New York

    *Cabaret

    One From the Heart

    *Raging Bull

    *The King of Comedy

    *Tootsie 

    *ET

    *Missing

    *Das Boot

    Gandhi

    *After Hours

    *The Color of Money

    *The Hustler

    *The Last Temptation of Christ

    *Goodfellas

    *Dances With Wolves

    *Cape Fear

    *Cape Fear (1962)

    The Age of Innocence

    *Casino

    *Bugsy

    The Last Emperor

    Empire of the Sun

    Kundun

    Seven Years in Tibet

    Bringing Out the Dead

    Light Sleeper

    American Gigolo

    Gangs of New York

    *Titanic

    The Aviator

    *The Departed

    *Shutter Island

    *Wolf of Wall Street

    The Irishman

    *Killers of the Flower Moon

    *Hugo

    12 Years a Slave

    *Silence

    *Oppenheimer

    *The Last Waltz


    Contact us at: [email protected]

    Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

    15 December 2025, 5:00 am
  • 1 hour 22 minutes
    2007 — Departing with an Oscar, Finally!

    Finally!  After leaving empty handed with 5 Best Director (and 4 Best Picture) nominations… one of the greatest film directors of all-time, the God of pure cinema, Martin Scorsese, finally gets to go home with Oscars for Best Picture and Best Director.  The Departed, his 2006 crime epic starring half of Hollywood seemed like the perfect vehicle to get him to the finish line… But at the same time, it’s a little bittersweet because in many people’s minds because The Departed might not have been the best movie of the year — and is nowhere near the best film Scorsese has ever made over his long and storied career.  In fact, as we inspect this year’s Oscar awards — we discover a lot of nominations rewarding good people for their not best work.  (And a few who deliver career benchmark performances!)  Join us as we hash through a year that is equal parts rewarding and confounding and try to discover whether there was a ‘rat’ in the Academy who had it in the bag for a legend.  As always, thanks for listening and supporting the show!


    Movies Mentioned  

    (*Recommended)

    Pirates of the Caribbean: Dead Man’s Chest

    *Night at the Museum

    Cars

    X-Men: The Last Stand

    The DaVinci Code

    Superman Returns

    Happy Feet

    Ice Age: The Meltdown

    *Casino Royale

    *The Pursuit of Happiness

    *Dreamgirls

    Babel 

    *Pan’s Labyrinth

    *The Queen

    Blood Diamond

    *The Departed

    *Letters From Iwo Jima

    *Little Miss Sunshine

    *Notes on a Scandal

    *Flags of Our Fathers

    **Children of Men

    *Apocalypto

    *Inside Man

    *The Prestige

    The Illusionist

    *United 93

    *Little Children

    *Volver

    *The Last King of Scotland

    Half Nelson

    *Venus

    *The Devil Wears Prada

    *Borat

    *An Inconvenient Truth

    *1917

    **The Lives of Others


    Contact us at: [email protected]

    Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

    8 December 2025, 7:00 am
  • More Episodes? Get the App