Elysia and Luke wrap up their 2024 winter holiday miniseries on A Christmas Carol with a look at seven adaptations that offer twists on the original tale, from meta storytelling (00:04:36), to gender-swapped Scrooges (00:43:02), to trippy musicals that have landed on the favorites end of our lists (01:37:20).

We'll be spoiling these films (see list below), but don't worry if you haven't watched any of them – we'll make sure you know the basic plots and key moments, and of course how they compare to the original tale.

I – Start with the opening notes episode, if you haven't yet, for the background on this series.

II – The sheet music (novella and earlier story) episode is available to Book Club members in Supercast (Silozens or Storyzens)/Patreon.

III – And also join the chorus to discuss some of the most classic classic Christmas Carol adaptations.

IV – Then pause for an intermezzo on Dickens' life and the creation of this tale.

V – With this episode (the verse), our 2024 A Christmas Carol coverage is completed! Expect a reprise with more of the most beloved adaptations next year.

Films covered this episode:

1. Scrooged (1988, 1h41)
2. Flintstone’s Christmas Carol (1994, 1h9)
3. A Diva’s Christmas Carol (2000, 1h24)
4. A New Diva’s Christmas Carol (2022 remake, 1h24)
5. It’s Christmas, Carol (2012, 1h30)
6. Scrooge: A Christmas Carol (2022, animated, loose remake of the 1970 Finney musical, sci-fi twist, 1h41 – Netflix)
7. Spirited (2022, musical, 2h7 – Apple TV+)

2023 holiday special: The It's a Wonderful Life / Knife multiverse

Join the Book Club

On Supercast: https://woolshiftdustbookclub.supercast.com/ (Recommended – the Silozen level is equivalent to Patreon benefits)

Or Patreon: https://patreon.com/WoolShiftDust (note: subscription model here is changing soon to match Supercast due to new Patreon rules)

Email us: [email protected]

Find us on Bluesky: @elysiacb & @lukemiddup

Or on the Lorehounds Discord: https://discord.gg/gM5VhTea2T

Find us also on the podcasts... 

The Lorehounds (Elysia)

The Star Wars Canon Timeline Podcast (Elysia)

It Could Be Said (Luke)

Produced by Elysia Brenner

Published by The Lorehounds

Explore the Lorehounds network for more book / film / TV / game / music podcasts

Intro & outro music: "Land of Ice and Snow" by HygieusMusic

Additional SFX from Freesound.org

Elysia and Luke gather around the mics once more to continue their winter tale with this briefer interlude looking at one specific film – about Charles Dickens' life and writing A Christmas Carol.

We use that as a jumping-off point to discuss the real man: How much of the film's story is true? What else should you know about him? And, perhaps most importantly for this series... Did he actually invent Christmas? And if not, who did?

Watch out for the final episode in our 2024 A Christmas Carol haunt, where Luke and Elysia watch some of the silliest and most beloved twists on the tale, and find out which ones we think are worth your time.

The Man Who Invented Christmas (2017) is available in most countries on Disney+ or Hulu.

I – Start with the opening notes episode, if you haven't yet, for the background on this series.

II – The sheet music (novella and earlier story) episode is available to Book Club members in Supercast (Silozens or Storyzens)/Patreon.

III – And also join the chorus to discuss some of the most classic classic Christmas Carol adaptations.

2023 holiday special: The It's a Wonderful Life / Knife multiverse

Join the Book Club

On Supercast: https://woolshiftdustbookclub.supercast.com/ (Recommended – the Silozen level is equivalent to Patreon benefits)

Or Patreon: https://patreon.com/WoolShiftDust (note: subscription model here is changing soon to match Supercast due to new Patreon rules)

Email us: [email protected]

Find us on Bluesky: @elysiacb & @lukemiddup

Or on the Lorehounds Discord: https://discord.gg/gM5VhTea2T

Find us also on the podcasts... 

The Lorehounds (Elysia)

The Star Wars Canon Timeline Podcast (Elysia)

It Could Be Said (Luke)

Produced by Elysia Brenner

Published by The Lorehounds

Explore the Lorehounds network for more book / film / TV / game / music podcasts

Intro & outro music: "Land of Ice and Snow" by HygieusMusic

Additional SFX from Freesound.org

After setting the stage in our intro and Book Club episodes, Elysia and Luke join the spirits in some of the most haunting classic adaptations of A Christmas Carol (see list of films covered below).

Join us for two more episodes, leading up to Christmas: the intermezzo – a brief look at the life of Dickens and creation of this book – and the verse – a collection of twists on the classic tale!

A comparison of the doorknocker scene across 100+ years of adaptations

Start with the opening notes episode, if you haven't yet, for the background on this series.

The sheet music episode is available to Book Club members in Supercast (Silozens or Storyzens)/Patreon.

Films covered this episode:

Shorts:

1. “Scrooge” (1901, first filmed adaptation, part is missing, 6 min) 
2. “A Christmas Carol” (1910, the first surviving complete adaptation, 13 min)
3. “A Christmas Carol” (1971, animated, Oscar winner, 25 min)
4. “Mickey’s Christmas Carol” (1983, 26 min) – available on Disney+ outside Europe

Features:

1. A Christmas Carol (1951, Alastair Sim, 1h26)
2. A Christmas Carol (1984, George C. Scott, 1h40)
3. A Christmas Carol (1999, Patrick Stewart, 1st w/ digital VFX, 1h35)
4. Scrooge (1970, Albert Finney, most popular musical, 1h53)
5. The Muppet Christmas Carol (1992, 1h25 – Disney+) – the Muppets full-length version w/ "When Love Is Gone" song (Extras tab)

2023 holiday special: The It's a Wonderful Life / Knife multiverse

Join the Book Club

On Supercast: https://woolshiftdustbookclub.supercast.com/ (Recommended – the Silozen level is equivalent to Patreon benefits)

Or Patreon: https://patreon.com/WoolShiftDust (note: subscription model here is changing soon to match Supercast due to new Patreon rules)

Email us: [email protected]

Find us on Bluesky: @elysiacb & @lukemiddup

Or on the Lorehounds Discord: https://discord.gg/gM5VhTea2T

Find us also on the podcasts... 

The Lorehounds (Elysia)

The Star Wars Canon Timeline Podcast (Elysia)

It Could Be Said (Luke)

Produced by Elysia Brenner

Published by The Lorehounds

Explore the Lorehounds network for more book / film / TV / game / music podcasts

Intro & outro music: "Land of Ice and Snow" by HygieusMusic

Additional SFX from Freesound.org

With "Barricades," episode 6 of season 2 of Silo, the twist Elysia has been waiting for has finally come – taking Luke by surprise! We talk about that, brewing tensions of multiple varieties, and all the small moments you might have missed. Plus, of course, a certain someone's suit-stealing ways.

Spoilers for all episodes aired to date, and any book elements related to what has already been aired.

No spoilers for any book elements that have not yet appeared on screen.

Join the Book Club

On Supercast: https://woolshiftdustbookclub.supercast.com/ (Recommended – the Silozen level is equivalent to Patreon benefits)

Or Patreon: https://patreon.com/WoolShiftDust (The price model is currently changing due to new Patreon regulations)

NEW! Silo Season Passes

https://siloseasonpasses.supercast.com/

Email us: [email protected]

Find us on Bluesky: @elysiacb & @lukemiddup

Or on the Lorehounds Discord: https://discord.gg/gM5VhTea2T

Find us also on the podcasts... 

The Lorehounds (Elysia)

The Star Wars Canon Timeline Podcast (Elysia)

It Could Be Said (Luke)

Produced by Elysia Brenner

Published by The Lorehounds

Explore the Lorehounds network for more book / film / TV / game / music podcasts

Intro & outro music: "Magnetic Universe" by Adrian Earnshaw & Benedict Roff-Marsh

Additional SFX from Freesound.org

Questions of shadows and allegiances take center stage in this round-up of community feedback focusing on especially episodes 4 and 5 of season 2 of Silo. Plus, a mini-dive into this series' excellent cinematography – particularly for episode 5!

Spoilers through S2-E5, and any book elements related to what has already been aired.

No spoilers for any book elements that have not yet appeared on screen.

Ed Moore's ep 5 cinematography videos

Adam Savage learns how the vault was built

Join the Book Club

On Supercast: https://woolshiftdustbookclub.supercast.com/ (Recommended – the Silozen level is equivalent to Patreon benefits)

Or Patreon: https://patreon.com/WoolShiftDust (note: subscription model here is changing soon to match Supercast due to new Patreon rules)

NEW! Silo Season Passes

https://siloseasonpasses.supercast.com/

Email us: [email protected]

Find us on Bluesky: @elysiacb & @lukemiddup

Or on the Lorehounds Discord: https://discord.gg/gM5VhTea2T

Find us also on the podcasts... 

The Lorehounds (Elysia)

The Star Wars Canon Timeline Podcast (Elysia)

It Could Be Said (Luke)

Produced by Elysia Brenner

Published by The Lorehounds

Explore the Lorehounds network for more book / film / TV / game / music podcasts

Intro & outro music: "Magnetic Universe" by Adrian Earnshaw & Benedict Roff-Marsh

Additional SFX from Freesound.org

Not content to stick to Silo content alone this holiday season, Elysia and Luke are exploring the many iterations of perhaps the greatest Christmas tale ever told: A Christmas Carol by Charles Dickens.

In this quick episode we get into how we came to this topic, and what exactly we'll be covering (this year).

2023 holiday special: The It's a Wonderful Life / Knife multiverse

A Christmas Carol 2024 miniseries – films covered:

I. Sheet music – "The Goblins Who Stole a Sexton" & A Christmas Carol: the novella (Book Club exclusive)

II. Chorus – Classic A Christmas Carol adaptations:

Shorts:

1. “Scrooge” (1901, first filmed adaptation, part is missing, 6 min) 
2. “A Christmas Carol” (1910, the first surviving complete adaptation, 13 min)
3. “A Christmas Carol” (1971, animated, Oscar winner, 25 min)
4. “Mickey’s Christmas Carol” (1983, 26 min) – available on Disney+ outside Europe

Features:

1. A Christmas Carol (1951, Alastair Sim, 1h26)
2. A Christmas Carol (1984, George C. Scott, 1h40)
3. A Christmas Carol (1999, Patrick Stewart, 1st w/ digital VFX, 1h35)
4. Scrooge (1970, Albert Finney, most popular musical, 1h53)
5. The Muppet Christmas Carol (1992, 1h25 – Disney+) – the Muppets full-length version w/ "When Love Is Gone" song

III. Intermezzo – The Man Who Invented Christmas (2017, 1h44 – Disney+) + Charles Dickens' life

IV. Verse – Twisted A Christmas Carol adaptations

1. Scrooged (1988, 1h41)
2. Flintstone’s Christmas Carol (1994, 1h9)
3. A Diva’s Christmas Carol (2000, 1h24)
4. A New Diva’s Christmas Carol (2022 remake, 1h24)
5. It’s Christmas, Carol (2012, 1h30)
6. Spirited (2022, musical, 2h7 – Apple TV+)
7. Scrooge: A Christmas Carol (2022, animated, loose remake of the 1970 Finney musical, sci-fi twist, 1h41 – Netflix)

Join the Book Club

On Supercast: https://woolshiftdustbookclub.supercast.com/ (Recommended – the Silozen level is equivalent to Patreon benefits)

Or Patreon: https://patreon.com/WoolShiftDust (note: subscription model here is changing soon to match Supercast due to new Patreon rules)

Email us: [email protected]

Find us on Bluesky: @elysiacb & @lukemiddup

Or on the Lorehounds Discord: https://discord.gg/gM5VhTea2T

Find us also on the podcasts... 

The Lorehounds (Elysia)

The Star Wars Canon Timeline Podcast (Elysia)

It Could Be Said (Luke)

Produced by Elysia Brenner

Published by The Lorehounds

Explore the Lorehounds network for more book / film / TV / game / music podcasts

Intro & outro music: "Land of Ice and Snow" by HygieusMusic

Additional SFX from Freesound.org

Luke and Elysia strap into Porter Dispatch's powered winch of their "Descent" into the depths of Silo S2 episode 5. We paused and wrote down all the details you might've missed, so that you don't have you – now sit back and let us tell you a tale of two silos.

Spoilers for all episodes aired to date, and any book elements related to what has already been aired.

No spoilers for any book elements that have not yet appeared on screen.

Join the Book Club

On Supercast: https://woolshiftdustbookclub.supercast.com/ (Recommended – the Silozen level is equivalent to Patreon benefits)

Or Patreon: https://patreon.com/WoolShiftDust (note: subscription model here is changing soon to match Supercast due to new Patreon rules)

NEW! Silo Season Passes

https://siloseasonpasses.supercast.com/

Email us: [email protected]

Find us on Bluesky: @elysiacb & @lukemiddup

Or on the Lorehounds Discord: https://discord.gg/gM5VhTea2T

Find us also on the podcasts... 

The Lorehounds (Elysia)

The Star Wars Canon Timeline Podcast (Elysia)

It Could Be Said (Luke)

Produced by Elysia Brenner

Published by The Lorehounds

Explore the Lorehounds network for more book / film / TV / game / music podcasts

Intro & outro music: "Magnetic Universe" by Adrian Earnshaw & Benedict Roff-Marsh

Additional SFX from Freesound.org

Elysia and Luke mourn, celebrate, and analyze the shocking twists and turns of Apple TV+'s Silo season 2, episode 4: "The Harmonium." What key clues were dropped while you were probably still reeling from these events, and what does this dramatic change in the status quo mean for the future?

Spoilers for all episodes aired to date, and any book elements related to what has already been aired.

No spoilers for any book elements that have not yet appeared on screen.

Join the Book Club

On Supercast: https://woolshiftdustbookclub.supercast.com/ (Recommended – the Silozen level is equivalent to Patreon benefits)

Or Patreon: https://patreon.com/WoolShiftDust (note: subscription model here is changing soon to match Supercast due to new Patreon rules)

NEW! Silo Season Passes

https://siloseasonpasses.supercast.com/

Email us: [email protected]

Find us on Bluesky: @elysiacb & @lukemiddup

Or on the Lorehounds Discord: https://discord.gg/gM5VhTea2T

Find us also on the podcasts... 

The Lorehounds (Elysia)

The Star Wars Canon Timeline Podcast (Elysia)

It Could Be Said (Luke)

Produced by Elysia Brenner

Published by The Lorehounds

Explore the Lorehounds network for more book / film / TV / game / music podcasts

Intro & outro music: "Magnetic Universe" by Adrian Earnshaw & Benedict Roff-Marsh

Additional SFX from Freesound.org

The Bernard and Mary Meadows theories go wild on the eve of ep 4!

And Elysia and Luke are back with reactions from the community to season 2 of Silo on Apple TV+, through episode 3. We get into questions, corrections, couple names, and plenty of clarifications – with more Silo Pez lore to boot.

Spoilers through S2-E3, and any book elements related to what has already been aired.

No spoilers for any book elements that have not yet appeared on screen.

Join the Book Club

On Supercast: https://woolshiftdustbookclub.supercast.com/ (Recommended – the Silozen level is equivalent to Patreon benefits)

Or Patreon: https://patreon.com/WoolShiftDust (note: subscription model here is changing soon to match Supercast due to new Patreon rules)

NEW! Silo Season Passes

https://siloseasonpasses.supercast.com/

Email us: [email protected]

Find us on Bluesky: @elysiacb & @lukemiddup

Or on the Lorehounds Discord: https://discord.gg/gM5VhTea2T

Find us also on the podcasts... 

The Lorehounds (Elysia)

The Star Wars Canon Timeline Podcast (Elysia)

It Could Be Said (Luke)

Produced by Elysia Brenner

Published by The Lorehounds

Explore the Lorehounds network for more book / film / TV / game / music podcasts

Intro & outro music: "Magnetic Universe" by Adrian Earnshaw & Benedict Roff-Marsh

Additional SFX from Freesound.org

Luke and Elysia unravel the reveals of episode 3 of Silo season 2: "Solo" – what do we learn about the man in the bunker, and what will come of the changes in dynamics when tragedy strikes in Juliette's home?

Spoilers for all episodes aired to date, and any book elements related to what has already been aired.

No spoilers for any book elements that have not yet appeared on screen.

Join the Book Club

On Supercast: https://woolshiftdustbookclub.supercast.com/ (Recommended – the Silozen level is equivalent to Patreon benefits)

Or Patreon: https://patreon.com/WoolShiftDust (note: subscription model here is changing soon to match Supercast due to new Patreon rules)

NEW! Silo Season Passes

https://siloseasonpasses.supercast.com/

Email us: [email protected]

Find us on Bluesky: @elysiacb & @lukemiddup

Or on the Lorehounds Discord: https://discord.gg/gM5VhTea2T

Find us also on the podcasts... 

The Lorehounds (Elysia)

The Star Wars Canon Timeline Podcast (Elysia)

It Could Be Said (Luke)

Produced by Elysia Brenner

Published by The Lorehounds

Explore the Lorehounds network for more book / film / TV / game / music podcasts

Intro & outro music: "Magnetic Universe" by Adrian Earnshaw & Benedict Roff-Marsh

Additional SFX from Freesound.org

Elysia and Luke check in on the people Juliette left behind, comparing the management strategies of Bernard and not-so-foxy-anymore Knoxy, pointing out new characters to keep an eye on, and talking about which of this episode's big reveals gave them the biggest gasps.

Spoilers for all episodes aired to date, news from Comic Con (see our Comic Con reaction episode), and any book elements related to what has already been aired.

No spoilers for any book elements that have not yet appeared on screen.

Join the Book Club

On Supercast: https://woolshiftdustbookclub.supercast.com/ (Recommended – the Silozen level is equivalent to Patreon benefits)

Or Patreon: https://patreon.com/WoolShiftDust (note: subscription model here is changing soon to match Supercast due to new Patreon rules)

NEW! Silo Season Passes

https://siloseasonpasses.supercast.com/

Email us: [email protected]

Find us on Bluesky: @elysiacb & @lukemiddup

Or on the Lorehounds Discord: https://discord.gg/gM5VhTea2T

Find us also on the podcasts... 

The Lorehounds (Elysia)

The Star Wars Canon Timeline Podcast (Elysia)

It Could Be Said (Luke)

Produced by Elysia Brenner

Published by The Lorehounds

Explore the Lorehounds network for more book / film / TV / game / music podcasts

Intro & outro music: "Magnetic Universe" by Adrian Earnshaw & Benedict Roff-Marsh

Additional SFX from Freesound.org