- 11 minutes 21 secondsPodcast Advice Is A Banquet. Stop Trying To Eat All Of It.
I built a tool that judges podcasts. I pointed it at my own show. It marked me down for following my own advice.
The free health check gave Podmastery seven and a half out of eight, and told me I had an issue with my feed settings. I didn't. So I went into my own code, and found my tool agreed with me and had just worded it badly. The half point went on my release rhythm and my episode lengths, which is awkward, because in episode 97 I told you to let the idea decide how long an episode should be.
So who's right, me or the tool I built? Both, and neither. Because it's guidance, not rules, and so is every bit of podcast advice you've ever been given, mine included. Think of it as a banquet: you pick what you actually want to feast on. But first you work out what's plumbing (the stuff that breaks if you ignore it) and what's taste. Then you let your gut pick what to try, and let the numbers decide, once there are enough of them. My "most engaged episode ever" on Spotify turned out to be three people.
Your one thing is at 09:55 if you want to skip straight to it.
Podmastery: Podcasting Insights is for people who already make a podcast and are sick of being told they're doing it wrong.
Chapters
00:00 My own tool marked me down
04:27 Podcast advice is a banquet
07:06 Your gut picks, the numbers decide
09:55 Your one thing
Links
The free podcast health check (score out of 8 for your feed, red, amber and green): https://podmastery.co/health-check
When it's bigger than one bit of advice: https://podmastery.co/need-podcasting-help
Free 7-day podcast makeover email course: https://podmastery.co
Listener survey (free download as a thank-you): https://podmastery.co/listener-survey
16 November 2026, 8:00 pm - 11 minutes 46 secondsStop Being So Fair With Your Podcast Content!
Every word of “it depends” is true. That’s exactly why nobody remembers it, and nobody recommends you for it.
Last week I said your show sentence needs three things. This week is about the one most of us leave out: the edge. And we leave it out for a really nice reason. We’re trying to be fair.
Fair feels professional. If you come from radio like I do, that caution gets drilled into you. But your podcast isn’t the six o’clock news. Nobody hit play for the both-sides version. They came for yours.
There’s some research behind this, sort of.
I'll explain.
Your one thing is at 10:02.
Been told something’s right and think it’s rubbish? Hedging on something and want me to pick a side for you?
Tell me at podmastery.co/get-in-touch and I might answer it on a future episode.
Podmastery: Podcasting Insights is for people who already make a podcast and are sick of being told they’re doing it wrong.
Chapters
00:00 Why Being Fair Is Boring
04:47 Fair to the Facts, Not the Ideas
08:17 What Taking a Side Sounds Like
10:02 Your One Thing: Find the Hedge
9 November 2026, 8:00 pm - 9 minutesNobody Has Ever Recommended Your Podcast Out Loud
Finish this sentence out loud: “You should listen to this podcast. It’s about…” If you hesitated, so does every listener you’ve got.
Last week, on episode 100, I failed my own check three. My last three titles sounded like three different shows sharing a microphone, and I promised we’d sort out theme this week. It turns out theme isn’t really about your titles. It comes down to one sentence, and that sentence is the only bit of marketing your listeners are ever going to do for you.
So meet Mary. She loves your show, she’s in the pub, her mate needs something for the drive to work, and she’s about to recommend you. Then she can’t tell anyone what you’re about, and her mate orders some crisps.
I go through the three things a sentence needs so somebody else can repeat it after a glass of wine. Then I hold my own show’s sentence up to the light (36 words, Mary’s got about 10) and cut it down to the pub version. I finish with the bit almost nobody does: saying it on every episode, in the same words, until it feels repetitive to you.
Podmastery: Podcasting Insights is for people who already make a podcast and are sick of being told they’re doing it wrong.
Chapters
00:00 Finish this sentence
00:32 Intro
01:12 Mary in the pub
02:01 Why it went nowhere
02:34 Word of mouth does work
03:06 A category isn’t a sentence
04:00 What the sentence needs
04:43 My show sentence
05:43 Back to last week’s titles
06:53 Say it every episode
07:58 Your one thing
08:22 Pass it on
Links
Ep 100, I audit podcasts for a living.
Rerun check three with the free health check.
When it’s bigger than one sentence.
Free 7-day podcast makeover email course.
Listener survey (free download as a thank-you)
2 November 2026, 7:45 pm - 13 minutes 33 secondsI Audit Podcasts For A Living. Let’s Do Yours.
Get your phone out. I’ve audited around 150 podcasts, and this time we’re auditing yours, together, while you listen.
It’s episode 100, so instead of a party I’m doing the thing people usually pay me for: the four checks I run on every show before I write a word of an audit. You pause me, check your own show, come back, and we score it.
Check one is how quickly your latest episode gets going, and how clean the edit is getting there. Check two is how your voice is recorded. Check three is your last three titles, and I fail that one on air. Check four is the bit of your description people see before it says “more”.
Checks three and four, a machine can do, so I built one. Paste your RSS feed or your show name into the free health check and you’ll get a score out of 10 in red, amber and green, the same standard I use in my paid audits. If you want me actually listening to your show, the Lite audit is at the end of your results.
Chapters
03:27 Check one: editing
04:56 Check two: your voice
06:16 Check three: titles
08:27 Check four: descriptions
09:11 The score
09:53 The free tool
11:35 Your one thing
12:31 Close
Links
Free podcast health check: podmastery.co/health-check
When it’s bigger than four checks: https://podmastery.co/need-podcasting-help/
Free 7-day podcast makeover email course: podmastery.co
Listener survey (free download as a thank-you): podmastery.co/listener-survey
26 October 2026, 6:15 pm - 10 minutes 39 secondsOpinion: They’re Telling Us There Are Too Many Ads
54.8% of podcast listeners say shows already carry too many ads. 8.6% say they’d put up with a few more to keep their favourite shows free. That’s roughly one in 12, and honestly, I’d quite like to check he’s okay.
Same week, Joe Rogan re-signs with Spotify (Podscribe reckons his recent episodes carried 15 ads), and audio fiction network Fable and Folly says it’s closing because podcast advertising changed under it. Bit of a week for ads.
And if you’re thinking “but Neal, I don’t run any ads”… I know. This is still your problem. Your listener’s patience for being sold to doesn’t belong to each show. It’s one tank, the big shows have been draining it all evening, and by the time they press play on yours, your rate and review ask sounds exactly like a mattress advert. The people who walk first aren’t the casuals, either. It’s Mary. Your best listener.
I also owe you an asterisk on something I said recently about empty sponsor slots, and Spotify’s relaunched Memberships has accidentally pointed at the one asset nobody can skip, and nobody can take 10% of. The one thing to change on your next episode is at 08:22.
Chapters
00:00 Listeners have filed a complaint
00:44 54.8% say too many ads
01:34 Rogan’s 15 ads and a network closing
02:19 But I don’t run ads
04:37 Mary skips you
05:47 The asterisk
06:53 Beyond the pre-roll
07:30 The tenant put the rent up
08:22 Your one action this week
09:45 The small print
Links
The Podcast Study 2026 on ad load: podnews.net/press-release/podcast-ad-load-2
Beyond the Preroll, the follow-up: podnews.net/press-release/new-revenue-opportunities
Fable and Folly to close: podnews.net/update/fable-and-folly-closes
Spotify Memberships: podnews.net/update/spotify-memberships
The landlord and tenants episode: podmastery.co/episodes/opinion-podcasters-youre-the-landlord-the-platforms-are-just-tenants
When it’s bigger than one episode: podmastery.co/need-podcasting-help
Free 7-day podcast makeover email course: podmastery.co
Listener survey (free download as a thank-you): podmastery.co/listener-survey
Got your own opinion on this? I’d love to hear it: podmastery.co/get-in-touch
24 October 2026, 6:00 am - 10 minutes 21 secondsHow to Read a Podcast Script Without Sounding Like You’re Reading
My script said “leave”. My mouth said “ditch out”. Nobody listening ever knew, and that’s exactly why your script is the problem, not your voice.
If you sound like you’re reading when you record, someone has probably told you it’s your voice. Smile more. Slow down. Warm it up. It’s very rarely your voice. It’s the page.
In this episode I play you the line I couldn’t get through last time, take Dennis (of imaginary biscuit tin fame) through the wrong fixes, and tell you what happened when I tried to say the same passage twice, word for word, with 30-odd years of practice and the script right in front of me. I couldn’t do it.
Most scripts are written to be looked at. Long sentences, the important bit buried mid-clause, words nobody says out loud. Your eyes can go back over a sentence. Your listeners’ ears can’t. Your mouth knows that, so it argues with the page the whole way through, and that argument is what people hear.
The fix takes one voice memo and a bit of humility. It’s at 07:57 if you want to skip straight to it.
Chapters
00:00 The line I couldn’t read
01:05 Dennis has a lovely voice
02:40 Scripts are written for eyes
04:30 One job: say it twice
06:22 Why good writers sound worse
07:57 The fix: let your mouth rewrite the page
Links
Ep 98, the quality floor episode: https://podmastery.co/episodes/heres-what-definitely-wont-make-your-podcast-sound-better/
When it’s bigger than how you sound reading: podmastery.co/need-podcasting-help
Free 7-day podcast makeover email course: podmastery.co
Listener survey (free download as a thank-you): podmastery.co/listener-survey
21 October 2026, 7:00 pm - 12 minutes 56 secondsHere's What Definitely Won’t Make Your Podcast Sound Better
I recorded this one on a USB mic at a hotel desk, next to a kettle and some UHT milk I’m going to regret. If you can’t hear much difference, that’s the whole episode.
There’s a quality floor in podcasting. Below it, people leave. Above it, something odd happens: nobody notices anything at all. Nobody has ever finished an episode, turned to their partner and said “lovely compression on that one.”
Most of us got over that floor years ago, thanks to Descript’s Studio Sound, Adobe’s free Enhance Speech button and Auphonic. Nobody told you. So we keep buying things our listeners can’t hear.
In this episode:
- The same hotel-room recording played twice, raw and cleaned up (try it in one earbud)
- Why I stopped swearing by iZotope RX 11
- Dennis, his vintage biscuit tin podcast, and the gear spiral that took the paint off his wall
- The £300 metal box still sitting in my loft
- Why February me was only half right about one-click audio tools
- The wardrobe test: a free check to do before you buy anything else
Chapters:
00:00 The same recording, played twice
02:24 The quality floor (and when you got over it)
05:23 Dennis, the biscuit tins and my £300 box in the loft
07:39 February me was half right
10:31 What actually makes a difference
11:28 Your one thing: the wardrobe test
Links:
The Podmastery community founding-members waitlist: podmastery.co/podcasting-community
Got a problem that’s bigger than your sound? podmastery.co/need-podcasting-help
Auphonic (free for 2 hours a month): auphonic.com
The February episode I mention, When Tools Make Bad Audio Sound ‘Good’, Who Loses?: https://podmastery.co/episodes/when-tools-make-bad-audio-sound-good-who-loses/
Descript (affiliate link: you get a bargain, I get a kickback, that’s how this works):
7 October 2026, 6:30 am - 6 minutes 1 secondHow Long Should A Podcast Episode Be? (The Honest Answer)
There's a moment about nineteen minutes into a lot of podcast episodes where you can hear the host has checked out.
They made their point at minute six. It was quite good. But there were eleven minutes of slot left, so they made it again, slightly differently, this time with a story about their brother-in-law's conservatory.
This one's about the clock. The one radio had, the one podcasting got rid of, and the brand new one we all built ourselves about five minutes later. It's short on purpose. You'll understand why.
In this episode:
— The radio news jingle, and the best podcast editor I ever had
— How we escaped the clock and built a new one immediately
— The dinner party and the single Twix
— Gareth (made up, but you've heard his show), his caravans, and 28 minutes of car park
— The question that'll make you wince. It made me wince. My last one was 26 minutes.
— The Post-it test
Six minutes of me, plus a podcast from one of our Podmastery Community members — which doesn't count, because it's theirs and they can make it as long as they like.
Want in on the Podmastery Community?
Doors open in October. Get on the waiting list at podmastery.co/podcasting-community
Stuck on something specific?
Come and get your next podcasting challenge solved one-to-one with me at podmastery.co
Podmastery: Podcasting Insights is my podcast for people who've actually had a go at this and are a bit sick of being told they're doing it wrong by people who've never properly done it at all. I'm Neal Veglio, the Podmaster.
28 September 2026, 6:00 pm - 26 minutes 5 secondsNeed Podcast Coaching? Have You Tried Dave Jackson? He's Three Stalls Down
I was minding my own business, about ten minutes into a podcast I listen to every week, when the host said my name out loud and told his audience to go and listen to my show.
Nobody asked him to. There was no deal, no swap, no "I'll do yours if you do mine."
Which is incredible, given that, on paper, the man is my competition.
This episode is about the one group of listeners the ideal listener exercise specifically tells you to ignore — and why they're the only people in your audience who arrive with an audience of their own.
There's a bit in here I don't soften, and it's aimed squarely at me as much as at you.
In this episode:
— The three approved British responses to being complimented in public
— Why a man with 1,000 episodes and a Hall of Fame induction owes you nothing, and said it anyway
— The Saturday morning cheese market, and why Trevor sends people to Maureen
— Same counter, different cheese: the reason "but they might not come back" is the wrong worry
— Bev, the Martins, and two allotment podcasts that have never spoken
— Why the promo swap is a hostage exchange, and what to do instead
— The column that isn't on anybody's connection spreadsheet
Mentioned in this episode
Dave Jackson — Attention vs. Connection, School of Podcasting (14 September 2026): https://www.schoolofpodcasting.com/connection-attention
School of Podcasting: https://www.schoolofpodcasting.com
Ask the Podcast Coach — Dave Jackson and Jim Collison, Saturday mornings: https://www.askthepodcastcoach.com
Podnews Weekly Review — James Cridland and Sam Sethi, every Friday: https://weekly.podnews.net
In & Around Podcasting — Rob Walch and Elsie Escobar (the "Rob and Elsie" I apologise to about seven minutes in): https://podnews.net/podcast/ic1o5
Building The Brand with James Burtt — two Ts, which I did not manage on air: https://podnews.net/podcast/i11l3c
David Hooper's Big Podcast: https://www.bigpodcast.com
Mark at Podcast Branding: https://podcastbranding.co
Switchy — Dave Jackson's affiliate link, not ours: https://www.supportthisshow.com/switchy
That's Dave's affiliate link, not mine. If you buy through it he gets the commission, which is entirely the point — it's the fastest thank-you I could think of. I've had it about five minutes, so treat this as a thing I bought, not a thing I'm recommending.
Want in on the Podmastery Community? The waiting list is open — come and be in a room with other indie podcasters being genuinely useful to each other: podmastery.co/podcasting-community
Stuck on something specific? Come and get your next podcasting challenge solved one-to-one with me at podmastery.co
Podmastery: Podcasting Insights is my podcast for people who've actually had a go at this and are a bit sick of being told they're doing it wrong by people who've never properly done it at all. I'm Neal Veglio, THE Podmaster. LOLZ
21 September 2026, 6:45 pm - 9 minutes 8 secondsHow Much Does A Podcast With 1,000 Listeners Make? (The Real Number)
A podcast with a thousand listeners makes about a hundred and forty-four dollars a month.
I checked that properly.
So then I say the second thing, which is the bit that makes people go quiet. You don't want a hundred and forty-four dollars a month. You want one thousand four hundred and forty-four. And the way you get there is by not doing ads.
In this episode:
— Why the hundred and forty-four dollar figure is right, and why that's the problem
— The only lever CPM gives you, and where it leads
— The arithmetic that made me laugh
— What renting your mid-roll actually costs you
— My affiliate disclosure, said out loud, because this episode demands it
— One thing to do this week that takes sixty seconds of 'tape'
Tools I use and get paid to mention.
I record on Boomcaster, edit in Descript most weeks, and Captivate hosts this show.
Affiliate links below — I earn a commission at no extra cost to you. I'm telling you because the whole episode is about people who don't.
— Boomcaster: https://www.boomcaster.com/?ref=AzyWVAUu8UgsoCAZT (free trial + 50% off first three months)
— Descript: https://descript.cello.so/Kct9xUy3ilR (50% off first two months)
— Captivate: https://www.captivate.fm/signup?ref=nealveglio
The Podmastery Community is open soon.
Come and join us: https://podmastery.co/podcasting-community
Stuck on something specific? Get your next podcasting challenge solved one-to-one at https://podmastery.co
Podmastery: Podcasting Insights is my podcast for people who've actually had a go at this and are a bit sick of being told they're doing it wrong by people who've never properly done it at all. I'm Neal Veglio, the Podmaster.
7 September 2026, 6:45 pm - 12 minutes 4 secondsI Told Them My Podcast Audience Wasn't For Sale... To THEM
About four years ago, a very popular remote recording platform offered me money to talk about them on this show. I'd been using it that week. It had also, that week, lost one of my recordings. Not glitched. Lost.
I said no. And I want to be clear that this wasn't a moral decision, because it wasn't. It was arithmetic.
This episode is about the thing you're holding and consistently failing to price. Because the belief is that sponsorship is a reward for volume — hit some magic download number and you're finally allowed. So you wait. And when someone eventually offers you something, you say yes very fast, because you've been told this is the gate opening.
Here's the problem with that. Only 7% of podcasts reach 5,000 downloads an episode. Two per cent reach 20,000. The benchmark show you've been measuring yourself against is a rounding error. You've been waiting for permission from a category that's almost entirely empty.
Meanwhile the advertising industry — not me, them — describes mid-tier and niche shows as underpriced. They're on record. And when you look at what they actually pay, business and B2B shows pull $40 to $80 CPM while the big broad comedy and lifestyle shows pull $15 to $35. Narrow is worth more per listener than popular.
So the question stops being will anyone ever pay me? and becomes what's the cheapest I'd take for it? Most podcasters have never answered that. Which is exactly how you end up saying yes to something you've never used.
There's an uncomfortable bit in here about what actually happens when you do. It isn't unsubscribes. Nobody storms off. It's quieter and considerably worse than that.
In this episode:
— Why the download benchmark you're chasing barely exists
— The word the ad industry uses for shows your size, and why it should annoy you
— Why a $50 CPM show can be a better buy than a $15 one
— What it actually costs you when you endorse something you haven't tested
— My entire sponsorship policy, which is one sentence long and slightly embarrassing
— One thing to write down today, on the back of a receipt
Tools mentioned in this episode. I record on Boomcaster, I edit in Descript most weeks, and Captivate hosts this show. I have affiliate links for all three, which means I earn a commission if you sign up through them at no extra cost to you. I'm telling you that because the whole episode is about people who don't. If I stopped using any of them, I'd stop talking about them.
— Boomcaster: https://www.boomcaster.com/?ref=AzyWVAUu8UgsoCAZT (Free trial, plus 50% off your first three months)
— Descript: https://descript.cello.so/Kct9xUy3ilR (50% off first two months)
— Captivate: https://www.captivate.fm/signup?ref=nealveglio
Want in on the Podmastery Community? We're opening the doors to the public soon. To join the founding members, go to https://podmastery.co/podcasting-community
Stuck on something specific? Come and get your next podcasting challenge solved one-to-one with me at https://podmastery.co
Podmastery: Podcasting Insights is my podcast for people who've actually had a go at this and are a bit sick of being told they're doing it wrong by people who've never properly done it at all. I'm Neal Veglio, the Podmaster.
31 August 2026, 4:00 pm - More Episodes? Get the App