- 48 minutes 21 secondsKILLED in Broad Daylight! A Locked House and Foreign DNA: The Mysterious Death of Brooke Hanlon
On a quiet Saturday afternoon, 35-year-old psychotherapist Brooke Hanlon was brutally stabbed to death inside her New Jersey home while her husband was out running a quick errand. Despite no signs of forced entry, police have kept the investigation incredibly secretive, recently returning to the house months later to extract large pieces of evidence while purposely blinding onlookers with vehicle high beams. Investigators are now analyzing a seized headboard, a laundry hamper, and newly discovered foreign DNA that could finally point to a killer. Joseph Scott Morgan and Dave Mack analyze the husband's frantic 911 call and break down the extreme police secrecy surrounding this case.
Highlights:
00:10.490 The Importance of Therapy
01:59.240 A Mysterious Murder in New Jersey
03:54.730 The 911 Call and Initial Investigation
10:57.880 Analyzing the Scene and Evidence
30:15.940 The Search Warrant and New Developments
31:28.140 A Summer Attack and Its Aftermath
33:35.400 The Husband's Lawyer and Police Secrecy
36:04.440 The Intensive Search of the Hanlon Home
37:00.830 Forensic Analysis and Speculation
41:31.320 The Mysterious Search Tactics
47:08.060 Closing Thoughts on the CaseSee omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.
18 November 2026, 9:00 pm - 40 minutes 17 secondsThe Tragic Senseless Murder of Brooklyn Jogger Katie Suarez
Katie Suarez, a 28-year-old competitive runner with a bright future, went for a routine evening jog along Brooklyn's Shore Parkway Greenway and never made it home. After she failed to meet her parents as planned, her father tracked her location and discovered his daughter lying under a tree, bleeding profusely from severe neck wounds at the end of a 150-foot blood trail. Despite rapid medical intervention and surviving for two days in the hospital, Katie succumbed to her injuries. The unprovoked attack was ultimately traced to Sayed Mohassib, a 27-year-old former NYPD academy recruit and teacher's assistant with a troubled history. On Tuesday, November 10, 2026, a Brooklyn grand jury indicted Mohassib on the top charge of second-degree murder. Joseph Scott Morgan and Dave Mack explain the forensics behind the blood trail and the physical damage of the neck injuries. They also look at the hard work detectives put into catching the suspect, which included searching through Staten Island trash barges.
Highlights:
00:01.400 Setting the Stage for Body Bags
00:10.730 The Jogger's Mindset
01:05.160 A Fateful Night in Brooklyn
02:59.580 The Discovery and Aftermath
11:05.280 The Perpetrator's Troubled Past
30:42.020 The Investigation UnfoldsSee omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.
16 November 2026, 9:00 pm - 42 minutes 5 secondsKiller of Polly Klaas Cheats Death, Gets Life
Polly Klaas, 12, was kidnapped from her home during a slumber party with her best friends in October 1993. Richard Allen Davis snuck into the house that night, and kidnapped Polly, leaving her friends bound and gagged. Joseph Scott Morgan and Dave Mack go back over the crimes committed that night and how Richard Allen Davis was sentenced to death. The Governor of California has now decided to change the sentence to "life", something Polly Klaas was not given by Richard Allen Davis.
Highlights:
00:01.400 Setting the Stage for a Shocking Case
00:07.250 The Impact of a High-Profile Case
02:01.280 A Governor's Controversial Decision
06:35.150 The Horrific Kidnapping of Polly Klaas
12:20.370 The Investigation Unfolds
30:48.470 The Aftermath and Davis' ConfessionSee omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.
13 November 2026, 9:00 pm - 46 minutes 45 secondsSusan Smith 32 Years Later: Inside Her Second Attempt at Parole
In 1994, Susan Smith shocked the nation when she murdered her two young sons, three-year-old Michael and 14-month-old Alex, by rolling her car into a South Carolina lake while they were strapped in their car seats. After initially launching a nationwide manhunt by blaming a fabricated carjacker, Smith was eventually convicted and sentenced to life in prison. Now, following a unanimous parole denial in November 2024, Smith is scheduled for her second parole hearing in November 2026. Joseph Scott Morgan and Dave Mack explore the details of the murders, Smith’s extensive disciplinary history behind bars, and the ongoing, fierce opposition from her ex-husband, David Smith, to ensure she remains incarcerated for the rest of her life.
Highlights:
00:01.400 Setting the Stage for a Tragic Tale
00:10.390 The Poolside Nightmare
01:07.970 A Mother's Deception
03:42.670 The Carjacking Hoax
05:47.510 The Father's Unending Suffering
27:20.350 The Autopsy and Drowning Process
33:38.900 Susan Smith's Prison Behavior
34:51.110 The Cycle of Incidents
36:43.450 Prison Misconduct and Consequences
39:24.430 The Parole Hearing and Public Opinion
43:23.530 Reflections on Susan Smith's Crimes
46:04.580 Closing Thoughts on an American TragedySee omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.
11 November 2026, 9:00 pm - 47 minutes 16 secondsPeople's Court Murder: The DEATH of Michelle Parker
Dale Smith Jr. convinces Michelle Parker to go on the TV show, People's Court, to settle the former couple's dispute over who is responsible for a lost engagement ring. The judge rules in Smith's favor and orders Michelle to pay Smith $2,500, half of the value of the engagement ring. On the day the show airs in the Orlando, Florida market, Michelle Parker vanishes into thin air. Joseph Scott Morgan and Dave Mack examine the facts of the case to determine if it is possible to convict Dale Smith Jr. of her murder without the body of Michelle Parker.
Highlights:
00:10.310 The Power of Film: Rain Man's Emotional Ending
01:50.250 People's Court and a Fateful Day
05:04.970 Michelle Parker's Disappearance
08:18.960 The Missing Vehicle and Its Clues
21:14.380 New Forensic Breakthroughs
29:58.680 Dale Smith Jr.'s Altered Timeline
31:18.730 The Investigation Begins
32:22.330 Defensive Injuries and Forensic Evidence
38:30.690 The Phone's Alibi
40:37.160 Dale Smith Jr.'s History of Violence
45:04.350 Prosecuting a Case Without a Body
46:28.239 Closing Thoughts on the CaseSee omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.
9 November 2026, 9:00 pm - 44 minutes 1 secondBlind Man In Wheelchair, GUILTY of Murder, Dismemberment
How can a headline be both "true" and "not true" at the same time? When the suspect is 74-year-old Robert Kessler. He is blind. He is in a wheelchair. And he is guilty of the murder and dismemberment of Stephanie Crone-Overholt. He also offered to chain his plea of "not guilty" to "guilty" in exchange for a Philly cheesesteak sandwich and a Pepsi. Joseph Scott Morgan and Dave Mack explain how the headline isn't the whole story, but the verdict is still, guilty!
Highlights:
00:01.420 Welcome to Body Bags
00:10.530 The Roast Beef Po' Boy Obsession
01:03.600 A Bizarre Murder Case Unfolds
03:53.600 The Suspect's Curious Transformation
11:46.650 A Homeless Woman's Tragic Fate
15:15.580 The Discovery in McKay Bay
28:39.090 The Investigation and Identification
36:02.020 The Shocking Request for a Cheesesteak
43:51.730 Closing Thoughts on the Case
See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.
6 November 2026, 9:00 pm - 47 minutes 15 secondsBabysitter Admits Killing Friend’s 6-week-old Baby, Sending His Twin to Hospital
Nicole Virzi travels from her home in San Diego to Pittsburgh to visit her best friend Savannah Roberts and her husband Ethan Katz after the couple welcomed twin boys, Leon and Ari. The twins are six weeks old when Virzi offers to watch the tots so Savannah and Ethan can have a much needed evening out. While Savannah and Ethan are at dinner, Nicole sends a picture of Ari that appears to show some kind of injury to the child. Savannah and Ethan are thankful Nicole is in town to help take care of Leon as they take Ari to the hospital. What Savannah Roberts and Ethan Katz don't kow is that Nicole Virzi is the one who injuried Ari, and she did it so she would be left alone to torture Leon Katz without fear of interruption. Joseph Scott Morgan and Dave Mack go up close and personal with a case that ends with a 6-week-old baby in the hospital, and his twin brother in the morgue.
Highlights:
00:01.400 Body Bags: A Shocking Case of Child Abuse
00:10.289 The Tragic Discovery
02:35.180 Nicole Virzi: Friend or Foe?
04:27.700 The First 911 Call
05:21.120 Ari's Injuries and the ER Response
05:35.810 Leon's Catastrophic Injuries
36:37.300 The Autopsy Results and Police Investigation
38:14.060 The Investigation Unfolds
40:02.800 The Shocking Confession
41:26.450 Nicole's Confession and Plea Deal
45:09.960 The Aftermath and Sentencing
47:05.590 Closing Thoughts on the CaseSee omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.
4 November 2026, 9:00 pm - 46 minutes 19 seconds50-Year Forensic Breakthrough! Ted Bundy and the Police Chief's Daughter
In October 1974, 17-year-old Melissa Ann Smith vanished after an evening out with friends in Utah. Because her father was the local police chief, a massive search began immediately, but nine agonizing days passed before two hunters discovered her body in a Summit County ditch. Now, 50 years later, investigators used the breakthrough DNA profile confirmed in Laura Ann Aime’s case to match biological evidence preserved from Melissa Ann Smith, officially closing the 50-year cold case and confirming Ted Bundy was her killer.
Joseph Scott Morgan and Dave Mack break down the autopsy findings and physical evidence, examining how pathologists determined Melissa was held captive alive for several days before she was killed.
Highlights:
Here are the extracted timestamps and titles separated by double line breaks so they will not squish together when you copy and paste them.
00:01.410 Setting the Stage for a Dark Tale
00:10.570 The Power of "Iconic" in Crime
00:35.300 Bundy's Legacy and Victim Erasure
01:27.940 A New Revelation: Melissa Ann Smith
03:25.900 Bundy's Death and Its Impact
06:23.830 Bundy's Crimes: A Pattern of Violence
07:48.280 The Melissa Ann Smith Case Unfolds
08:33.679 Bundy's Final Days and Confessions
14:30.490 The Search for Melissa Ann Smith
26:38.270 The Autopsy Report: A Graphic Account
27:58.770 Understanding Bilateral Subdural Hematoma
28:12.940 Bundy's Brutal Attack on Melissa Ann
39:55.480 The Importance of DNA Evidence
40:20.920 DNA Evidence Cracks the Case
46:00.239 Remembering the Victims
See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.
2 November 2026, 9:00 pm - 45 minutes 59 secondsMurdaugh Murder Trial Part 2 - Did Alex Murder His Wife & Son?
What if Alex Murdaugh didn't murder his wife, Maggie, and son, Paul? What if Alex Murdaugh was judged guilty because the jury was stunned by information of financial crimes and drug addiction and believed if a man could do all the things Murdaugh was accused of doing, murdering his wife and son seemed more than just possible. And what if a trusted clerk of court was putting ideas into the heads of some jury members that led them to believe Murdaugh was a murderer. Alex Murdaugh’s double-murder conviction was officially overturned on May 13, 2026. The South Carolina Supreme Court unanimously reversed his 2023 convictions and ordered a new trial. Joseph Scott Morgan and Dave Mack review the evidence that led to his conviction the first time to determine if a second guilty verdict is likely...or was an innocent man convicted for all the wrong reasons?
Highlights:
00:01.400 Money and Motivation
01:02.140 The Murdaugh Murders Unfold
01:25.280 Greed and Expert Testimony
04:22.920 The Murdaugh Family's Dark Legacy
14:44.410 The Crime Scene and Forensic Evidence
16:49.940 The Shocking Double Homicide
32:31.860 Maggie's Fatal Shooting
33:07.310 The Crime Scene Analysis
33:53.170 The Brutal Murder of Maggie
35:27.150 Legal Developments and New Trial
35:41.260 Ballistic Evidence and Gun Types
37:59.760 The Fatal Shooting of Maggie
44:12.040 New Trial and DNA Evidence
45:49.250 Closing Thoughts on the CaseSee omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.
30 October 2026, 8:00 pm - 47 minutes 34 seconds5 Dead in 10 Months Along One Mile Trail: The Lansing Serial Killer
The Police Chief of Lansing Michigan says the recent attacks along a one mile stretch of the Lansing River Trail leading to the deaths of five men raises the possibility that this area of Michigan might have a serial killer in their midst. Joseph Scott Morgan and Dave Mack discuss all five deaths to determine what happened in each case, and compare all of the cases to determine areas of similarity that could lead to one killer being responsible for all of the attacks.
Highlights:
00:10.289 The Art of Pattern Recognition in Forensics
00:49.110 A Potential Serial Killer in Lansing,
01:33.220 Investigating Homeless Homicides
05:45.430 The Unique Nature of Homeless Victim Patterns
07:32.600 Task Forces and Big-Picture Investigations
15:07.320 The First Victim: Gino Chouinard
20:46.950 The Second Victim: Dennis Dunback
25:43.359 The Third Victim: Robert Smith
29:18.400 The Fourth Victim: Daniel Lusk
31:51.550 The Fifth Victim: Louis Woodruff
33:52.650 Analyzing the Evidence and Suspicions
35:24.650 The Nature of the Attacks
35:51.680 Investigating the Victims and Injuries
41:24.060 The Location and Modus Operandi
46:43.550 Closing Thoughts and Future CoverageSee omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.
28 October 2026, 8:00 pm - 55 minutes 12 secondsMurder of UNC Student Faith Hedgepeth: A Rum Bottle, Genetic Genealogy, and a Guilty Verdict
In 2012, 19-year-old UNC student Faith Hedgepeth was found murdered in her apartment following a savage sexual assault and blunt-force attack. The bloody crime scene yielded bizarre clues: a heavy rum bottle used as a weapon and a cryptic message written on a takeout bag. The case went cold for nearly a decade until genetic genealogy traced the killer's DNA to Miguel Salguero Olivares. Following a 2021 traffic stop that secured a matching DNA sample, a jury recently found him guilty on all counts, sentencing him to life in prison.
Joseph Scott Morgan and Dave Mack break down the physical evidence left at the scene and analyze the complex blood deposition on Faith's bed, explain the devastating impact of a thick liquor bottle as a weapon, and discuss how the mysterious takeout bag served as a confusing red herring.
Highlights:
00:01.420 Welcome to Body Bags with Joseph Scott Morgan
00:10.630 Jimmy Buffett and Rum
02:59.280 The Faith Hedgepeth Case Begins
06:02.540 The Brutal Discovery
07:41.350 The Challenges of Blood Evidence
13:37.590 The 911 Call and Initial Scene
18:20.619 The Investigation Unfolds
31:18.890 The Rum Bottle and DNA Evidence
34:38.840 The Role of Blood in Investigations
39:27.070 The Suspect and the Crime Scene
41:11.200 The Challenges of Identifying Blood
43:10.660 A Violent Attack Unfolds
44:06.390 The Investigation Begins
49:13.270 The Role of DNA Evidence
52:48.610 The Trial and Its Challenges
55:02.580 Closing Thoughts on Forensic ScienceSee omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.
26 October 2026, 8:00 pm - More Episodes? Get the App