In 1986, Nancy Daugherty’s life was stolen, leaving behind a haunting mystery that stretched on for decades. With no leads and DNA testing providing no matches, her case went cold—until an unexpected forensic breakthrough in 2020 changed everything. Investigators finally had a name, but now, years after his conviction, the man accused of her murder is fighting for a fair trial.

Join us as we dive into the details of Nancy’s case, the groundbreaking role of genetic genealogy, and the legal battle that could alter the course of justice. This is a story of loss, resilience, and the relentless pursuit of the truth.

Thanks to our sponsor: 

ShipSkis: Right now, ShipSkis is offering Crime Salad listeners 20% off your first shipment. Just go to ShipSkis.com and use the code CRIMESALAD.

On the evening of August 2, 2015, at a Speedway gas station near Columbus, Ohio, life changed forever for 31-year-old Judy Malinowski. What started as an ordinary summer night ended in horror when her then-boyfriend, Michael Slager, committed an unthinkable act of violence.

This episode dives deep into the chilling events of that night, the devastating impact of domestic violence, Judy’s courageous fight for justice, and the inception of Ohio’s “Judy’s Law,” which enforces harsher penalties for those who commit such heinous crimes.

Join Crime Salad as they explore the details of Judy’s heartbreaking yet inspiring journey and the legacy she left behind in the battle against intimate partner violence.

Please be advised that this episode comes with a few trigger warnings. This narration includes descriptions of domestic violence, substance abuse, disfigurement, and death.


Domestic Violence: Ways to Get Help
National Domestic Violence Hotline: 800-799-7233
SMS: Text  “START” to 88788
National Resource Center on Domestic Violence: www.nrcdv.org
Warning Signs of Domestic Violence: www.wadvocates.org
Recognizing the Patterns of Domestic Violence: www.mayoclinic.org
Common Questions About Sexual Assault: https://florinroebig.com/sexual-assault-guide/


Struggling with addiction? Help is available  
SAMHSA Helpline:
1-800-662-HELP (4357)
You can also text your ZIP code to 435748 to find treatment resources near you.
Visit their website at samhsa.gov for more information.

This helpline is available 24/7, 365 days a year, offering free and confidential assistance for individuals and families facing substance use disorders. They can connect you with treatment centers, support groups, and other local resources.


Struggling with Mental Health
If you or someone you know is struggling with mental health, help is available. In the U.S., you can call or text 988, the Suicide & Crisis Lifeline, for free, confidential support 24/7.

For more resources, visit 988lifeline.org to chat with a trained counselor and find additional support options.


Thanks to our sponsors for this week:

Shopify: The best time to start your new business is right now! Go to shopify.com/crimesalad to start selling with Shopify today.

In this chilling episode, we unravel the infamous Sharon Nelson murder case, a tale of deceit, betrayal, and fatal ambition set in Trinidad, Colorado. After the crushed remnants of Perry Nelson’s VW are discovered, questions about his disappearance lead to shocking revelations and even another victim. Sharon Nelson, caught in a tangled web of lies and an affair with Gary Adams, becomes the center of a Colorado love triangle murder investigation. Was this a case of insurance fraud and murder plot, or a deadly game of control? Whatever the case may be, one thing is for sure, stay away from a black widow murderer. 


Thanks to our sponsor for this episode!


Miracle Made: Sheets that are amazing and inspired by NASA technology.

In Part 1 we dive into the chilling case of Sharon Nelson Harrelson, infamously known as the "Black Widow." Sharon's story is one of manipulation, betrayal, and murder, as she left a trail of broken hearts baiting new lovers in with her seductive behavior but with deadly intentions in her wake. From her tumultuous relationships to the shocking murders of her husbands, this case uncovers the darker side of a woman whose charm masked a sinister agenda. Tune in as we explore the twisted motives, shocking evidence, and courtroom drama that made Sharon Nelson Harrelson's crimes one of the most notorious in true crime history.

Thanks to our Sponsors!
Better Help: This episode is brought to you by BetterHelp. Give online therapy a try atbetterhelp.com/crimesalad and get on your way to being your best self.
Acorns: Head to acorns.com/crimesalad or download the Acorns app to start saving and investing for your future today!
ShipSkis: ShipSkis is offering our listeners 20% off your first shipment! Visit ShipSkis.com and use the code CRIMESALAD to claim your discount.


written and researched by Rasha Aly and Crime Salad

In February 2020, Sarah Boone made a chilling 911 call claiming to have found her boyfriend, Jorge Torres Jr., lifeless inside a suitcase after an innocent game of hide-and-seek turned deadly. According to Sarah, she had fallen asleep, leaving Jorge trapped and unable to escape—a horrific accident, or so she insisted.

But Sarah’s demeanor during the call was erratic, her words detached and cold. The pieces didn’t quite fit. Then, a damning video surfaced: Jorge, locked inside the suitcase, desperately gasping, “I can’t breathe,” and pleading for his life while Sarah mocked him.

That video turned the case upside down, transforming a supposed accident into something far more sinister. Sarah Boone was arrested and charged with second-degree murder, her chilling actions leading to a trial that left everyone questioning the dark side of human relationships.

Join us as we revisit this unforgettable case that still haunts true crime enthusiasts to this day.

Thanks to the sponsor of this episode.
Beam’s biggest Cyber Monday sale is here—get up to 50% off their best-selling Dream Powder at shopbeam.com/crimesalad with code crimesalad while supplies last!

Elisabeth Fritzl endured an unimaginable reality for years, trapped and tormented by the very person who was supposed to protect her—her father. Waking up every day in that dark, suffocating basement, being graped time and time again, questioning whether she would ever see the light of day again or if another one of her children would die in such a place. You would lose every bit of hope, thinking theres no way out; no one even knows your down there… 
The psychological weight she carried is unfathomable. Listen to this episode to hear the story.

*Listener discretion is advised due to the disturbing nature of this episode's content, which includes explicit descriptions of child sexual abuse and other disturbing details.


-Thanks for our sponsors for supporting this episode-


Ship Skis Go to Shipskis.com and use the code CRIMESALAD to get 20% off your first shipment and save yourself the hassle this ski season.

Apotstrope Get your first visit for only five dollars at Apostrophe.com/CRIMESALAD when you use our code: CRIMESALAD. 

Mark Twitchell was a film enthusiast with big ambitions, but those ambitions took a dark and disturbing turn. Beneath his passion for movies was something much more sinister, and it didn’t take long for those dark desires to surface. Wearing a hockey mask and armed with duct tape, a fake gun, and a taser baton, Mark set a trap in a garage he had rented to film a movie, prepared to look like a crime scene, complete with plastic sheeting, but it was actually a kill room.

Sponsors:

Apostrophe
Go to Apostrophe.com/CRIMESALAD, click “Get Started,” and use the code CRIMESALAD at sign-up. 

This episode contains discussions of sensitive topics, including sexual violence, child exploitation, psychological abuse, and relatable topics. We strongly advise listeners to exercise discretion.


Victims of exploitation aren’t always bound by physical restraints—they’re trapped by psychological abuse, fear, and manipulation, as perpetrators use our systemic failures to their advantage. In this special episode, we step away from our usual content to shed light on a devistating reality: the estimated 15 million children impacted by sexual exploitation in the U.S. In this episode we will look into Jessa Dillow Crisp’s story, who is now a co-founder of Bridge Hope, and a strong advocate for survivors and the many challenges many victims face.

Hotlines for Immediate Support

• 
  National Human Trafficking Hotline (U.S.):
  Call: 1-888-373-7888
  Text: 233733
  
  
• 
  National Sexual Assault Hotline (U.S.):
  Call: 1-800-656-HOPE (4673)
  
  

Survivor Story and Support

• 
  Jessa Dillow Crisp's Experience:
  YouTube Video
  
  
• 
  Jessa Dillow Crisp's Website:
  Bloomify Community
  
  

Government Resources

• 
  US Department of Justice on Human Trafficking:
  What is human trafficking?
  
  

Organizations Fighting Trafficking and Exploitation

• 
  Empower the Fight (Child Exploitation Awareness):
  What is child sex trafficking?
  
  

Training and Education

• 
  Training: Watchful Eye
  Title: Safeguarding Children from Sex Abuse & Exploitation
  Access Training Here: https://risingsteps.thinkific.com/courses/watch

SPONSORS

Apostrophe
Get your first visit for just five dollars at Apostrophe.com/CRIMESALAD when you use our code CRIMESALAD.

Beam's Dream Powder
Get up to 50% off while supplies last when you go to shopbeam.com/crimesalad and use code CRIMESALAD at checkout.

This episode contains graphic descriptions of violence and strong language that may not be suitable for all listeners. Listener discretion is strongly advised.

At 6:43 a.m. on Tuesday, May 5, 2009, Detective Justin Barlow’s phone rang. On the other end was his neighbor, Christopher Coleman sounding anxious. He had just returned from the gym and couldn’t get his wife, Sheri, to answer the phone. Something wasn’t right. That call would set off an investigation that would uncover one of the most chilling family tragedies in Columbia, Illinois. A small town located near St. Louis Missouri. The family of four: Chris Coleman Sheri,who were highschool sweet hearts and their two sons 9 year old Gavin and 11 year old Garrett were living in a two-story house located in a suburban neighborhood. 

Links to check out:

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK549867/#:~:text=Rigor%20mortis%20appears%20approximately%202,after%20death)%20and%20then%20disappears. 

If you or someone you know is struggling, please remember that help is available. You can reach out to the Suicide & Crisis Lifeline by calling or texting 988, or visiting 988lifeline.org for support. 

Kids can be cruel at a young age, and as we know even adults. It seems like over time, bullying has evolved, extending its reach beyond the schoolyard or around the local town to the world of online harassment where indivusals can hide behind their screen and really, say or do whatever, with out any real consequences. Statistics show that an estimated 160,000 children skip school every day because of fear—an alarming reminder of the emotional toll bullying takes.


Links you need to check out: 
https://www.change.org/p/tell-congress-to-enact-anti-bullying-legislation-in-honor-of-10-year-old-sammy-teusch

https://www.gofundme.com/f/the-wyatt-family-legal-fees

https://www.amandatoddlegacy.org/

How to navigate bullying: https://hside.org/connection-between-bullying-and-suicide/#Types

This story highlights the importance of taking domestic violence seriously. Please be warned of the graphic nature of this episode may be triggering, and if you feel like your in a situation similar, contact the domestic abuse hotline to get help. Text BEGIN to 88788.


On August 27, 2015, a horrifying act of violence shattered the peaceful, upscale planned community in St. Augustine, Florida. In this shocking true crime story, Amanda Cloaninger-Colley and Lindy Dobbins were tragically killed during a brutal shooting in Amanda’s home, leaving five young children motherless and a community reeling in disbelief.


This episode delves into the harrowing 911 call, where a desperate voice pleads for police as gunshots echo in the background. We explore the details of that tragic night, the fallout that tore two families apart, and the chilling reality that gripped the affluent World Golf Village community. Join us as we uncover the events that led to this unimaginable crime and the impact it left on St. Johns County.


The National Domestic Violence Hotline offers 24/7 confidential support for those affected by domestic violence. Trained advocates provide assistance with safety planning, resources, and local connections.


Call 1-800-799-7233  or text "begin" to 88788.  For more info, visit thehotline.org.


Amanda Cloaninger Family & Memorial (Go Fund Me) https://gofund.me/ce8ba28e