Woody Overton closes out September with a trip through true-crime history, beginning with John Billington, the Mayflower passenger executed for murder in 1630. He also revisits Jack the Ripper's infamous Double Event of September 30, 1888, and the Nuremberg war-crimes verdicts of 1946.

In Family Matters, a New Jersey mother is accused of hiding her missing teenage son in a crawl space, while a Memphis woman receives 30 years in prison for murdering Church's Chicken employee Anitra West following an argument over an order. Woody also covers the drowning of a three-year-old Indiana boy whose mother allegedly passed out while responsible for watching him.

Worldwide Crime takes us to Greece, where an argument over beach loungers turns fatal. Then, in F'd Up Professionals, a shooting at a North Carolina Zaxby's leaves a 19-year-old employee dead.

Finally, a significant development in Oregon: Jesse Calhoun, already facing murder charges involving five women, has been indicted on a first-degree manslaughter charge in connection with the disappearance and presumed death of a sixth woman, Elizabeth “Libby” Gibson.

Woody draws parallels to the ongoing searches for Madison Renee Allen and Stephanie Hevia, reminding listeners that every tip matters and every victim deserves answers.

Never give up. Never surrender.

True Crime Time For, Woody Overton, Real Life Real Crime, September 30, Jack the Ripper, Double Event, Elizabeth Stride, Catherine Eddowes, John Billington, Nuremberg Trials, Anitra West, Monaca Williams, Amy Joe Farber, Otis Johnson, Quinteris Elliott, Jesse Calhoun, Elizabeth Gibson, Libby Gibson, Oregon missing women, Justice for Madison, Justice for Stephanie, Justice for Hailey, true crime

• John Billington and the 1630 Plymouth murder
• Jack the Ripper's Double Event
• September 1946 Nuremberg verdicts
• New Jersey missing-teen investigation
• Anitra West's murder at Church's Chicken
• Indiana child-drowning investigation
• Fatal beach-lounger dispute in Greece
• Zaxby's employee shooting in North Carolina
• Jesse Calhoun's sixth indictment
• Elizabeth “Libby” Gibson
• #JusticeForMadison and #JusticeForStephanie
• #JusticeForHailey and continued appeals for information

The Oregon development provides the episode's central contemporary investigative story. Calhoun faces charges connected to six women's deaths, but the newest indictment involving Libby Gibson is for first-degree manslaughter, not murder. Her remains have not been recovered. The charges remain allegations, not convictions.

Woody closes by emphasizing that an investigation does not end simply because remains have not been located—and encourages Lifers to continue submitting information in the Madison, Stephanie, Hailey and other unresolved cases. 

Our Sponsors:
* Check out BetterHelp: https://www.betterhelp.com
* Check out Progressive: https://www.progressive.com


Advertising Inquiries: https://redcircle.com/brands

Privacy & Opt-Out: https://redcircle.com/privacy

Woody Overton opens with updates on #JusticeForHailey, #JusticeForMadison and #JusticeForStephanie, encouraging anyone with information to come forward and reminding Lifers that investigations continue even when developments cannot yet be made public.

Then, a possible new lead emerges in one of America's most notorious unsolved cases: the 1982 Chicago Tylenol Murders. Seven people died after taking cyanide-laced capsules, forever changing consumer packaging. Now, investigators are examining information concerning a man found dead in an Idaho church in 1982 and his possible connection to the killings. The case remains unsolved.

Woody also covers a Carnival cruise passenger reported overboard during a family anniversary trip and a Minnesota driver accused of fatally striking a pedestrian before proceeding through a McDonald's drive-thru.

In Family Matters, a Kentucky couple faces disturbing allegations of prolonged child abuse. Then, in F'd Up Professionals, a Detroit family discovers the woman prepared for their mother's funeral isn't their mother—and learns a devastating cremation mix-up may have occurred.

Woody closes with a reminder to never give up, never surrender, and keep the tips coming.

True Crime Time For, Woody Overton, Real Life Real Crime, Chicago Tylenol Murders, 1982 Tylenol poisonings, Mathew Francis Betkouski, Unknown Wanderer, James Lewis, cyanide poisoning, Alex Ray Kisch, Minnesota hit and run, Kyle Reynolds, Phyllis Culp, Kimberly Moore, Detroit funeral home, Family Matters, F'd Up Professionals, Justice for Madison, Justice for Stephanie, Justice for Hailey, Hailey Johnson

• #JusticeForHailey and #JusticeForMadison updates
• A possible new lead in the 1982 Tylenol Murders
• Identification of the Unknown Wanderer
• James Lewis and the original Tylenol investigation
• Carnival Panorama passenger reported overboard
• Minnesota fatal hit-and-run and McDonald's drive-thru
• Kentucky child-abuse allegations
• Detroit funeral home and cremation mix-up

The central development is the identification of Dr. Mathew Francis Betkouski, formerly known as Boise's Unknown Wanderer. Idaho investigators have shared information suggesting a possible connection to the Chicago Tylenol Murders, but Betkouski has not been officially named a suspect, and the seven killings remain unsolved.

Our Sponsors:
* Check out BetterHelp: https://www.betterhelp.com
* Check out Progressive: https://www.progressive.com


Advertising Inquiries: https://redcircle.com/brands

Privacy & Opt-Out: https://redcircle.com/privacy

Cyndi Overton takes over True Crime Time For with a story she intended to cover quickly—but couldn't. On September 28, 1953, six-year-old Robert “Bobby” Greenlease Jr. was taken from his Kansas City school by a woman claiming his mother had suffered a heart attack. Bonnie Heady and Carl Hall demanded $600,000 for Bobby's return, even though they had already killed him. The FBI investigation ended with Bobby's body recovered, Hall and Heady executed less than three months later, and more than half of the ransom money never recovered. Pasted text The FBI's records confirm the names and major details of Cyndi's account. FBI

Then it's Family Matters. In Arizona, Gary Crawford receives life plus 21 years for murdering his 91-year-old stepfather and attempting to murder his mother. In Missouri, Mariah Thomas is sentenced to 13 years after pleading guilty to child endangerment resulting in the death of her one-month-old daughter, whom she told investigators she accidentally placed in an oven instead of a crib. Pasted text Pasted text Us

Cyndi also covers the extraordinary Florida case against plastic surgeon Tomasz Kosowski, convicted of murdering attorney Steven Cozzi despite Cozzi's body never being recovered, along with a Colorado woman accused of killing and dismembering her husband. Pasted text Pasted text

Later, an armed Airbnb break-in ends with one alleged intruder shot by the renter; Florida MRI technician Gabriel Cruz is accused of sexually assaulting a sedated patient; and Stephen Gress pleads guilty to first-degree murder in the brutal death of 16-year-old Miranda Corsett. Pasted text Cruz has been charged, and the allegation remains pending. NBC Miami

Cyndi closes with #JusticeForHailey, sending love to Hailey Johnson's mother, Barbara, and asking Lifers to continue supporting her fight for answers. Pasted text

True Crime Time For, Cyndi Overton, Real Life Real Crime, Bobby Greenlease, Robert Greenlease Jr, Bonnie Heady, Carl Hall, Greenlease kidnapping, Steven Cozzi, Tomasz Kosowski, Gary Crawford, Mariah Thomas, Za'Riah Thomas, Gabriel Cruz, Miranda Corsett, Stephen Gress, Family Matters, Justice for Hailey, Hailey Johnson, Barbara Johnson, true crime

• Bobby Greenlease kidnapping and murder
• Bonnie Heady and Carl Hall
• $600,000 ransom and missing money
• Gary Crawford family murder case
• Steven Cozzi murder without a recovered body
• Tomasz Kosowski conviction
• Mariah Thomas and the death of infant Za'Riah
• Colorado dismemberment case
• Florida Airbnb self-defense investigation
• Gabriel Cruz MRI sexual-battery allegation
• Stephen Gress and Miranda Corsett
• #JusticeForHailey

The centerpiece of Episode 288 is clearly Bobby Greenlease. Cyndi begins with what was supposed to be a quick “On This Day” story and ends up telling the full FBI account—from Bobby walking out of school holding his kidnapper's hand through the executions of Hall and Heady. Pasted text

A couple of transcript spellings are worth correcting before publication: Bonnie Heady, Carl Austin Hall, Robert Cosgrove Greenlease Jr., Steven Cozzi, Tomasz Kosowski, and Gabriel Cruz. The Missouri infant's name is reported as Za'Riah Mae. 

Our Sponsors:
* Check out BetterHelp: https://www.betterhelp.com
* Check out Progressive: https://www.progressive.com


Advertising Inquiries: https://redcircle.com/brands

Privacy & Opt-Out: https://redcircle.com/privacy

Woody Overton opens with #JusticeForMadison and #JusticeForStephanie, thanking listeners for the tips coming in following the newly announced reward and urging anyone with firsthand information to contact investigators. Pasted text

On this day in 2022, 19-year-old Tamir Jones was shot and killed outside his Philadelphia home. Woody follows the case beyond the original unsolved murder and explains how investigators eventually connected suspects to both Tamir's killing and another deadly shooting. Pasted text

Then, a horrifying developing case out of Pennsylvania: Dr. Idris Evans, a 46-year-old pediatric critical-care physician at UPMC Children's Hospital of Pittsburgh, was fatally stabbed after an intruder allegedly entered his home and attacked Evans and his wife while they slept. Their two children escaped unharmed. Elijah Hemingway, 32, has been charged with criminal homicide, aggravated assault, burglary and criminal trespass. CBS News

Woody also travels through true-crime history with Machine Gun Kelly, the Johnny Lewis case, the Charles Sherman Ross kidnapping, the Alabama cell-phone murders, mob boss Albert Anastasia, the Indiana State Prison escape and the Phil Spector murder trial. Pasted text

In Worldwide Crime, Woody covers a deadly stabbing attack at a monastery in Poland before turning to Tennessee death row inmate Christa Pike, who is scheduled for execution September 30 for the 1995 murder of Colleen Slemmer. Pike's attorneys have sought clemency and raised objections concerning the execution protocol; Tennessee currently has her execution scheduled for 10 a.m. CDT at Riverbend Maximum Security Institution. Pasted text Tennessee State Government

Woody closes with a look at recent and upcoming executions around the country and his thoughts on capital punishment. Pasted text

True Crime Time For, Woody Overton, Real Life Real Crime, Justice for Madison, Justice for Stephanie, Madison Renee Allen, Stephanie Hevia, Thomas Morris, Tamir Jones, Idris Evans, Elijah Hemingway, Christa Pike, Colleen Slemmer, Tennessee death row, Machine Gun Kelly, Johnny Lewis, Albert Anastasia, Phil Spector, death penalty, capital punishment, true crime

• #JusticeForMadison and #JusticeForStephanie
• New tips following the reward announcement
• Tamir Jones murder investigation
• Murder of Dr. Idris Evans
• Elijah Hemingway charges
• Machine Gun Kelly
• Johnny Lewis and Catherine Davis
• Albert Anastasia and Murder Inc.
• Phil Spector
• Poland monastery stabbing
• Christa Pike and Colleen Slemmer
• Upcoming U.S. executions
• Death penalty and capital punishment

The Pittsburgh case is still developing. Police say Elijah Hemingway is accused of entering the Evans home and attacking Dr. Idris Evans and his wife while they slept; Hemingway has been charged, not convicted. WPXI

And one important correction from the transcript: the Tennessee death-row inmate's name is Christa Gail Pike, and her victim was Colleen Slemmer. Tennessee officially lists Pike's execution for September 30, 2026. 

Our Sponsors:
* Check out BetterHelp: https://www.betterhelp.com
* Check out Progressive: https://www.progressive.com


Advertising Inquiries: https://redcircle.com/brands

Privacy & Opt-Out: https://redcircle.com/privacy

Woody Overton opens with an important #JusticeForMadison and #JusticeForStephanie update: the West Feliciana Parish Sheriff’s Office and Capital Region Crime Stoppers are offering a reward for information that could help resolve the disappearances of Madison Allen and Stephanie Hevia. The reward is temporarily increased to $10,000, and tipsters can remain anonymous. Pasted text WBRZ independently confirms the reward announcement and that Thomas Morris remains a person of interest after his July arrest on unrelated kidnapping allegations. WBRZ

Woody also marks the National Day of Remembrance for Murder Victims before revisiting several crimes from September 25, including the Woodman “Ninja Murders,” the 1953 FBI shootout with John Elgin Johnson, and the 1987 Elkland massacre. Pasted text

Then comes long-awaited news in the disappearance of Jason Landry, the Texas State University student who vanished after crashing his car in December 2020. Nearly six years later, remains discovered approximately five miles from the crash site have been identified as Jason. Woody reflects on what finally bringing him home means to his family—and why families searching for Madison, Stephanie and other missing loved ones can never give up. Pasted text

There’s also a much lighter Dum Dum in the Court involving bank robbers who believed lemon juice would make their faces invisible to surveillance cameras, followed by a Florida hidden-camera investigation involving Shawn Michael Krause. Pasted text

Finally, Woody turns to the deaths of two University of Mississippi students and growing concern surrounding kratom. Packaged kratom was found during both death investigations, but authorities have emphasized that the deaths are separate and have not determined that kratom caused either death; toxicology results remain pending. https://www.actionnews5.com Woody closes with a warning about the risks of easily accessible substances with opioid-like effects. Pasted text

True Crime Time For, Woody Overton, Real Life Real Crime, Justice for Madison, Justice for Stephanie, Madison Allen, Stephanie Hevia, Thomas Morris, Brian Spillman, West Feliciana Parish, Capital Region Crime Stoppers, Jason Landry, Texas State University, National Day of Remembrance for Murder Victims, Woodman murders, Ninja murders, James Schnick, Elkland massacre, Dunning Kruger effect, kratom, Ole Miss, University of Mississippi, missing persons, true crime

• $10,000 #JusticeForMadison and #JusticeForStephanie reward
• Anonymous Crime Stoppers tips
• National Day of Remembrance for Murder Victims
• Woodman/Ninja Murders
• Elkland massacre
• Jason Landry’s remains identified
• Why missing-person investigations should never be abandoned
• Lemon-juice bank robbers and the Dunning-Kruger effect
• Shawn Michael Krause hidden-camera investigation
• Two University of Mississippi student deaths
• Kratom and public-safety concerns
• Importance of separating confirmed findings from speculation

Takeaways

The biggest current developments are the $10,000 reward in the Madison and Stephanie investigation and the identification of Jason Landry after almost six years. In the Ole Miss story, it is especially important that the show notes not say kratom killed the students. Packaged kratom was recovered during both investigations, but as of September 24, toxicology results were still pending and authorities had not established either cause of death or a connection between the two deaths.

Our Sponsors:
* Check out BetterHelp: https://www.betterhelp.com
* Check out Progressive: https://www.progressive.com


Advertising Inquiries: https://redcircle.com/brands

Privacy & Opt-Out: https://redcircle.com/privacy

This special Real Life Real Crime episode is devoted to #JusticeForMadison and #JusticeForStephanie. Woody Overton accompanies Lynn Rollins, Madison Renee Allen’s mother, to a private meeting with Sheriff Brian Spillman and members of the multi-agency task force investigating the disappearances of Madison and Stephanie Hevia.

Investigators explain just how exhaustive the search of the 15-acre Morris Road property was. Teams used specialized technology, searched more than two dozen areas of disturbed ground and collected numerous items that have been sent to the FBI laboratory in Quantico and the Louisiana State Police Crime Lab for testing. No human remains were recovered, but Sheriff Spillman made the message clear: the investigation is not over. Public reporting also confirms that investigators collected items they believe could be associated with the disappearances.

One moment changes the tone of the entire meeting. Investigators present Lynn with a large photograph of Madison that had hung at the search site each day. On the back were signatures from members of the many agencies that searched for her. For Lynn, it meant one thing: her daughter mattered.

Woody also addresses the search of the former Morris residence on Ash Street in Zachary, the last place Madison was known to have lived. He discusses what Lynn and investigators say was incorrect public information about whether items were collected there, while emphasizing that testing is still underway and those items should not be characterized as evidence connected to Madison or Stephanie unless forensic testing establishes that connection.

Most importantly, investigators are asking people with information to come forward now. Woody says tips from Lifers and the public have already contributed to the investigation, and investigators continue interviewing witnesses and pursuing leads.

The episode closes in Lynn’s own words as she thanks the people searching for Madison and Stephanie and asks anyone carrying information to finally speak.

Madison mattered. Stephanie matters. And this investigation is not over.

Real Life Real Crime, Woody Overton, Justice for Madison, #JusticeForMadison, Justice for Stephanie, Madison Renee Allen, Madison Allen, Stephanie Hevia, Lynn Rollins, Thomas Morris, Brian Spillman, West Feliciana Parish, Morris Road, Ash Street, Zachary Louisiana, St Francisville Louisiana, FBI Quantico, Louisiana State Police, missing women Louisiana, missing persons, 313 RLRC TIP, RLRC

• #JusticeForMadison and #JusticeForStephanie
• Lynn Rollins’ private meeting with investigators
• Sheriff Brian Spillman and the multi-agency investigation
• Exhaustive search of the Morris Road property
• No human remains recovered
• Items sent for forensic testing
• FBI and Louisiana State Police involvement
• Ash Street search in Zachary
• Continuing interviews and active leads
• Public tips and information provided by Lifers
• Photograph of Madison displayed at the search site
• Investigators’ signatures for Lynn
• “Madison mattered”
• Renewed call for witnesses and information
• 313-RLRC-TIP

The biggest development is not that the search ended. It is that investigators told Lynn and Woody the case is continuing aggressively: investigators were still in the field conducting interviews during the family meeting, and Woody says they were told an FBI agent had been assigned to the case full-time.

It is also important not to call the collected items evidence tying Thomas Morris to Madison or Stephanie yet. Lynn herself makes that distinction: items were collected and sent for analysis, but their significance will depend on testing. Morris has publicly been identified as a person of interest/prime suspect in the disappearances and remains jailed on unrelated kidnapping and false-imprisonment allegations; he has not been charged with killing Madison or Stephanie.

And the emotional center of Episode 285 is Lynn receiving that signed photograph. Her response—“my daughter mattered”—is why I used “Madison Mattered” as the title hook. 

Our Sponsors:
* Check out BetterHelp: https://www.betterhelp.com
* Check out Progressive: https://www.progressive.com


Advertising Inquiries: https://redcircle.com/brands

Privacy & Opt-Out: https://redcircle.com/privacy

Cyndi Overton takes over True Crime Time For and begins with one of Cleveland's most disturbing unsolved mysteries: the Cleveland Torso Murders. Between 1935 and 1938, a series of dismembered victims were discovered around Kingsbury Run, many of whom were never identified. Cyndi follows the investigation through Eliot Ness, the controversial destruction of the Kingsbury Run encampments, the disputed confession of Frank Dolezal, and Ness's suspicions surrounding Dr. Francis Sweeney. The murders remain officially unsolved.

Then Cyndi turns to three difficult cases involving children. In Kentucky, 19-year-old Elijah Mayes is charged with murder and other offenses after 11-month-old Grayson Walton was found dead inside a couch. Mayes has pleaded not guilty.

In Belle Rose, Louisiana, Bernard JR Fleander, 26, faces a first-degree murder charge in the death of a 3-year-old girl he had been caring for. The Assumption Parish Sheriff's Office says the child's death was ruled a homicide.

Finally, Cyndi shares the case of 17-month-old Jalen “JJ” Harding and Kassandra L. Bracewell, who pleaded guilty to neglect of a dependent resulting in death and received a 33-year sentence with three years suspended. The case leads Cyndi to share the deeply personal story of her younger brother and why crimes against defenseless children affect her so profoundly.

She closes with a simple challenge: when anger or frustration takes over, walk away, ask for help, and make a different choice.

True Crime Time For, Cyndi Overton, Real Life Real Crime, Cleveland Torso Murders, Cleveland Torso Murderer, Mad Butcher of Kingsbury Run, Eliot Ness, Florence Polillo, Edward Andrassy, Frank Dolezal, Francis Sweeney, Kingsbury Run, Elijah Mayes, Grayson Walton, Bernard JR Fleander, Kassandra Bracewell, Jalen JJ Harding, child abuse cases, unsolved serial killer, true crime

• Cleveland Torso Murders
• Mad Butcher of Kingsbury Run
• Florence Polillo and Edward Andrassy
• Unidentified victims
• Eliot Ness and the Kingsbury Run raid
• Frank Dolezal's disputed confession
• Dr. Francis Sweeney
• Elijah Mayes and Grayson Walton
• Bernard JR Fleander and the Belle Rose case
• Kassandra Bracewell and JJ Harding
• Cyndi's personal connection to childhood brain injury
• Recognizing when to walk away and seek help

Our Sponsors:
* Check out BetterHelp: https://www.betterhelp.com
* Check out Progressive: https://www.progressive.com


Advertising Inquiries: https://redcircle.com/brands

Privacy & Opt-Out: https://redcircle.com/privacy

Woody Overton opens with the 2006 murder of 16-year-old Cassie Jo Stoddart before turning to a major #JusticeForMadison update.

The intensive search of the Morris Road property connected to Thomas Morris has concluded without the recovery of the remains of Madison Renee Allen or Stephanie Hevia, but investigators say the case is far from over. Woody plays the latest WBRZ report, discusses what investigators collected during the search, and explains why evidence recovered from a property can remain significant even when no body is located.

Woody also revisits earlier incidents involving Morris and women who he says escaped violent or troubling encounters, including the Montana woman whose 911 call ultimately led to Morris's arrest. He discusses information he has received concerning additional missing women who may have had contact with Morris, while making clear he does not have direct evidence that Morris harmed them.

The episode ends with another important development: Madison's mother, Lynn Rollins, has been asked to meet privately with investigators, and Woody will accompany her. He promises to share whatever can be released without compromising the investigation.

True Crime Time For, Woody Overton, Real Life Real Crime, Justice for Madison, Justice for Stephanie, Madison Renee Allen, Stephanie Hevia, Thomas Morris, Lynn Rollins, Brian Spillman, Morris Road, West Feliciana Parish, St. Francisville, Zachary Louisiana, missing women, Louisiana missing persons, Cassie Jo Stoddart, 313 RLRC TIP

• #JusticeForMadison and #JusticeForStephanie
• Morris Road property search
• Madison Renee Allen and Stephanie Hevia
• Thomas Morris
• Evidence collected during the investigation
• Sheriff Brian Spillman and West Feliciana Parish investigators
• Previous alleged violent encounters involving Morris
• Montana kidnapping case
• Additional missing women Woody believes should be investigated
• Lynn Rollins' upcoming private meeting with investigators
• Cassie Jo Stoddart murder

Our Sponsors:
* Check out BetterHelp: https://www.betterhelp.com
* Check out Progressive: https://www.progressive.com


Advertising Inquiries: https://redcircle.com/brands

Privacy & Opt-Out: https://redcircle.com/privacy

On True Crime Time For September 21, 2026, Woody Overton opens with #JusticeForMadison, reacting to public social-media comments surrounding the ongoing search for Madison Renee Allen and Stephanie Hevia and reminding listeners that law enforcement has not publicly disclosed everything investigators know.

Then it's an episode Woody jokingly realizes could be called “Family Matters.”

In Russia, a mother was convicted as an accomplice after authorities determined she knew her husband was sexually abusing their daughters and encouraged the children to obey him. Another Russian case involves a convicted murderer and rapist released to fight in Ukraine who later returned and murdered his ex-wife and her 7-year-old daughter.

Woody also covers the extraordinary case of three Russian sisters accused of killing the father they said had sexually abused and terrorized them for years. Despite findings supporting their abuse allegations, the murder investigation against the sisters has now been reopened.

Back in the United States, Jenny King, 44, is accused of repeatedly stabbing her 14-year-old son inside their El Paso home while he was playing video games. His brother intervened, called 911 and helped control the bleeding until help arrived.

Finally, Woody turns to the death penalty: Alabama executed Jeffery James Lee for the 1998 murders of Jimmy Ellis and Elaine Thompson, while Texas executed LeJames Norman for the 2005 murders of Samuel Roberts, Tiffani Peacock and Celso Lopez. In Georgia, the scheduled execution of Stacey Humphreys was halted while a court considers whether Georgia's new Survivor Justice Act could entitle him to resentencing based on alleged childhood abuse.

Woody closes with updates on #JusticeForHailey and #JusticeForMadison.

True Crime Time For, Woody Overton, Real Life Real Crime, September 21 2026, Justice for Madison, Madison Renee Allen, Stephanie Hevia, Thomas Morris, Justice for Hailey, Hailey Johnson, Jenny King, El Paso stabbing, Jeffery James Lee, Jimmy Ellis, Elaine Thompson, LeJames Norman, Samuel Roberts, Tiffani Peacock, Celso Lopez, Stacey Humphreys, Cyndi Williams, Lori Brown, Georgia Survivor Justice Act, death penalty, Alabama execution, Texas execution, Russia crime, family crime, child abuse, true crime news, RLRC

• #JusticeForMadison update
• On This Day in true crime
• Glenn McCurley and Carla Walker
• International family-abuse cases
• Three Russian sisters and their father's death
• Jenny King and the El Paso stabbing
• Jeffery James Lee execution
• LeJames Norman execution
• Stacey Humphreys execution stay
• Georgia Survivor Justice Act
• #JusticeForHailey
• Hailey Johnson
• Death penalty and judicial override

Our Sponsors:
* Check out BetterHelp: https://www.betterhelp.com
* Check out Progressive: https://www.progressive.com


Advertising Inquiries: https://redcircle.com/brands

Privacy & Opt-Out: https://redcircle.com/privacy

In Part 2 of the Jacob Mansell case, Woody Overton takes listeners inside the West Feliciana Parish courtroom and recounts the roughly three-and-a-half-hour hearing he personally witnessed.

Woody describes testimony concerning the history of the allegations, repeated interviews of the child, the child's reported recantation, and the custody dispute surrounding Mansell. He also recounts testimony from Dr. Allen Taylor, the court-appointed evaluator whom Mansell's attorney has publicly said characterized the situation as the worst case of parental alienation he had encountered. That characterization has also been reported publicly as the basis cited by the defense for the earlier custody decision.

Woody then describes testimony from a West Feliciana Parish detective about her training and her involvement in multiple interviews, including an additional Child Advocacy Center interview that Woody says became a major moment in the hearing. According to Woody's recollection, the detective testified that the additional interview produced no new allegations requiring law-enforcement action.

A second mental-health professional also testified for the defense. Woody says she reviewed the case materials and likewise expressed serious concerns about parental alienation.

Throughout the hearing, District Attorney Sam D'Aquilla maintained that Louisiana law prohibited Mansell from having contact with the alleged victim while the criminal case was pending. Defense attorney Cy D'Aquila argued that removing the children from Mansell's custody would cause additional harm and urged the court to consider the evidence presented at the hearing.

Then came the ruling Woody didn't expect.

The judge allowed the children to remain with Mansell. Immediately afterward, Woody recalls D'Aquilla telling the court that he intended to return to the grand jury and seek a first-degree rape charge.

That happened. On September 14, a grand jury indicted Jacob Mansell on first-degree rape, and Mansell subsequently surrendered. His bond was set at $250,000.

In this episode, Woody gives listeners his firsthand account of what he heard in that courtroom—and explains why those hours left him with strong opinions about the investigation, prosecution and the justice system.

Mansell is accused of serious crimes, and the allegations against him remain pending. He has not been convicted of the first-degree rape charge.

Real Life Real Crime, Woody Overton, Jacob Mansell, Mansell case, West Feliciana Parish, Sam D'Aquilla, Cy D'Aquila, Dr Allen Taylor, parental alienation, Child Advocacy Center, CAC interview, forensic child interview, West Feliciana Parish court, first degree rape indictment, Louisiana criminal justice, child custody case, grand jury, Louisiana true crime, RLRC, courtroom testimony

• Jacob Mansell case, Part 2
• Woody Overton's firsthand courtroom observations
• District Attorney Sam D'Aquilla
• Defense attorney Cy D'Aquila
• Dr. Allen Taylor's testimony
• Parental-alienation testimony
• Child Advocacy Center interviews
• Detective training and investigative procedures
• Reported recantation by the child
• Mental-health expert testimony
• Heated prosecution and defense arguments
• Judge's custody ruling
• Grand-jury process
• First-degree rape indictment
• Presumption of innocence
• Justice and due process

Our Sponsors:
* Check out BetterHelp: https://www.betterhelp.com
* Check out Progressive: https://www.progressive.com


Advertising Inquiries: https://redcircle.com/brands

Privacy & Opt-Out: https://redcircle.com/privacy

In this episode of Real Life Real Crime, Woody Overton takes a deep dive into the controversial Jacob Mansell case in West Feliciana Parish and explains why he believes there is far more to the story than the public has heard.

Mansell was arrested in March 2026 on sexual battery and second-degree rape charges involving his 13-year-old daughter. After posting bond, he was initially ordered to have no contact with her. That condition was later rescinded, and Judge Kathryn Jones awarded Mansell majority custody of his three children—a decision that generated significant public controversy and prompted District Attorney Sam D’Aquilla to seek the recusal of Judges Sydney Picou Walker and Kathryn Jones. This week, a grand jury indicted Mansell on the upgraded charge of first-degree rape.

But Woody has a perspective on this case that most people don't.

He previously worked for Mansell's defense attorney, Cy D'Aquila, as a defense consultant and polygraph examiner. In this episode, Woody explains what he reviewed before conducting the examination, his concerns about how the child was repeatedly interviewed, the importance of proper Child Advocacy Center protocols, and why he believes those investigative procedures matter regardless of whether an allegation is ultimately proven true or false.

Woody also reveals that he personally administered a polygraph examination to Mansell and says Mansell showed no deception indicated on the questions Woody asked. He explains how he conducts these examinations, the countermeasures he watches for, and why he says he approached Mansell's examination without assuming either guilt or innocence.

The episode also examines clinical psychologist Dr. Alan Taylor's involvement in the custody proceedings. Mansell's attorney has publicly said Taylor characterized the matter as the worst case of parental alienation he had encountered, although reporting notes that phrase did not appear in Taylor's written custody recommendations.

Woody's larger question is one at the heart of the criminal justice system: What happens when an accusation is horrifying, public reaction is immediate, but the underlying investigation is more complicated than a headline can convey?

And this isn't over.

Woody ends Episode 280 by setting up the next chapter: he recently sat through approximately three and a half hours of courtroom proceedings involving the Mansell case. In the next episode, he's going to explain what he personally witnessed as the prosecution and defense battled in court.

Woody Overton takes listeners inside the controversial Jacob Mansell case in West Feliciana Parish. Woody explains his own involvement as a defense consultant and polygraph examiner, his concerns about the investigative process and repeated interviews of the child, the custody decisions that ignited public controversy, and Mansell's new first-degree rape indictment. Then Woody previews what he personally witnessed during an extraordinary three-and-a-half-hour courtroom battle—and why the next episode may change how listeners view the case.

Real Life Real Crime, Woody Overton, Jacob Mansell, Mansell case, West Feliciana Parish, Cy D'Aquila, Sam D'Aquilla, Sydney Picou Walker, Kathryn Jones, Dr Alan Taylor, parental alienation, Child Advocacy Center, CAC interview, forensic child interview, polygraph examination, Louisiana criminal justice, first degree rape indictment, sexual battery, second degree rape, West Feliciana Parish court, Louisiana true crime, RLRC

• Jacob Mansell case
• Woody Overton's involvement in the investigation
• Cy D'Aquila and the defense
• District Attorney Sam D'Aquilla
• Child Advocacy Center interview protocols
• Repeated interviews of child witnesses
• Woody's polygraph examination of Mansell
• Polygraph countermeasures
• Dr. Alan Taylor's custody evaluation
• Parental-alienation claims
• Judges Sydney Picou Walker and Kathryn Jones
• No-contact order and custody controversy
• Grand-jury process
• First-degree rape indictment
• Presumption of innocence and due process
• Preview of Woody's firsthand courtroom observations

Our Sponsors:
* Check out BetterHelp: https://www.betterhelp.com
* Check out Progressive: https://www.progressive.com


Advertising Inquiries: https://redcircle.com/brands

Privacy & Opt-Out: https://redcircle.com/privacy