- 1 hour 19 minutesThe Foremother of the Sexual Revolution with Anya Jabour
Katharine Bement Davis was the researcher responsible for the landmark 1929 study Factors in the Sex Life of Twenty-Two Hundred Women which surveyed a group of “normal” American women to learn the secret truth about their sexual lives. For this episode, our guest is Anya Jabour, a Professor of History at the University of Montana as well as the author of the new book Matters of Sex: Katharine Bement Davis and America's First Sexual Revolution. Anya is here to school us on this trailblazing “likely lesbian” who made it her mission to provide accurate information about sex, including around hot-button issues like masturbation, birth control, and homosexuality, proving that “normal” American women were anything but the passionless prudes they were expected to be.
Use the code NYUAU30 to get 30% off Anya's book at nyupress.org
Check out Anya's website here
Become a Patron to support our show and get early ad-free episodes and bonus content
Or subscribe to American Hysteria on Apple Podcasts
Get some of our new merch at americanhysteria.com, all profits this month go to The Sameer Project, a Palestinian-led mutual aid group in Gaza
Leave us a message on our Urban Legends Hotline at americanhysteria.com
Producer and Editor: Miranda Zickler
Associate Producer: Riley Swedelius-Smith
Associate Editor: Kaylee Jasperson
Hosted by Chelsey Weber-Smith
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
16 November 2026, 8:01 am - 54 minutes 13 secondsThe Great Bicycle Panic with Gabe Henry
There are few American symbols more seemingly innocent than the bicycle, but when this newfangled contraption was introduced during the Victorian era, it sparked a moral panic that linked the invention to decaying cultural virtues and even to the devil himself. For this episode, Gabe Henry, humorist and author of Enough is Enuf: Our Failed Attempts to Make English Easier to Spell, tells me the very American story of the bicycle and the changing reactions it sparked over a surprisingly short period of time.
Get a copy of Gabe's book
Check out Gabe's website
Become a Patron to support our show and get early ad-free episodes and bonus content
Or subscribe to American Hysteria on Apple Podcasts
Get some of our new merch at americanhysteria.com, all profits this month go to The Sameer Project, a Palestinian-led mutual aid group in Gaza
Leave us a message on our Urban Legends Hotline at americanhysteria.com
Producer and Editor: Miranda Zickler
Associate Producer: Riley Swedelius-Smith
Hosted by Chelsey Weber-Smith
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
9 November 2026, 8:01 am - 1 hour 14 minutesThe Damsel in Distress Problem with Daniel Peña
Daniel Peña is the author of HOW TO LOOK AWAY: On American Cruelty and the Refusal to Disappear, a collection of essays about his childhood as a Mexican-American kid in conspiracy-friendly Texas and the broader experiences of watching those fringe elements enter American popular culture and politics, helping to create the tolerance of human rights abuses against migrants from Latin America and elsewhere. For this episode, he tells me about Cynthia Ann Parker, a white girl in Texas who was captured by and then raised within a tribe of Comanche natives in the mid 1800s, and how her story, and the stories made up about her, were processed through the white American imagination. We discuss the narrative of the white damsel in distress and look at how girls and women have been used for centuries as an almost folkloric justification for cruelty and the consolidation of power.
Get a copy of HOW TO LOOK AWAY
Check out Daniel's other work here
Become a Patron to support our show and get early ad-free episodes and bonus content
Or subscribe to American Hysteria on Apple Podcasts
Get some of our new merch at americanhysteria.com, all profits this month go to The Sameer Project, a Palestinian-led mutual aid group in Gaza
Leave us a message on our Urban Legends Hotline at americanhysteria.com
Producer and Editor: Miranda Zickler
Associate Producer: Riley Swedelius-Smith
Associate Editor: Kaylee Jasperson
Hosted by Chelsey Weber-Smith
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
2 November 2026, 8:01 am - 1 hour 4 minutesBloody Mary (rewind)
This is a re-release of last year's Halloween special. Vote early! Here is a guide to help if you have any questions. Bloody Mary...Bloody Mary...Bloody Mary... for this episode, we are going to trace the history of the slumber party ritual known as Bloody Mary in which a young summoner stands in the dark in front of a mirror to call up a dangerous, blood-soaked witch-woman. By looking at the Victorian era occult divination games of girls, the many cemetery ghosts known as Mary, as well as humanity's supernatural history with the mirror itself, we'll try to figure out what this modern rite of passage might mean to those who dare go through with it.
Become a Patron to support our show and get early ad-free episodes and bonus content
Or subscribe to American Hysteria on Apple Podcasts
Listen to Magpie Cinema Club
Get some of our new merch at americanhysteria.com, all profits this month go to The Sameer Project, a Palestinian-led mutual aid group who are on the ground in Gaza delivering food, supplies, and cash envelops to displaced families.
Leave us a message on our Urban Legends Hotline at americanhysteria.com
Producer and Editor: Miranda Zickler
Sound Designer and Associate Producer: Riley Swedelius-Smith
Voice Actor: Will Rogers
Written, Produced, and Hosted by Chelsey Weber-Smith
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
26 October 2026, 7:01 am - 1 hour 6 minutesMYSTERY BLOOD
For this Halloween special, we are going to look at a handful of American cases in which mysterious blood suddenly appeared without a sensible source, as if by some kind of macabre magic, whether it be found all over the inside of a house, raining down from the sky alongside flesh and organs, dripping out of a centuries old tombstone, or oozing from an otherwise bloodless Puritan corpse. We'll see which of these events may have reasonable explanations and which remain inexplicable to this very day.
Become a Patron to support our show and get early ad-free episodes and bonus content
Or subscribe to American Hysteria on Apple Podcasts
Get some of our new merch at americanhysteria.com, all profits this month go to The Sameer Project, a Palestinian-led mutual aid group.
Leave us a message on our Urban Legends Hotline at americanhysteria.com
Producer and Editor: Miranda Zickler
Sound Designer and Associate Producer: Riley Swedelius-Smith
Voice Actor: Will Rogers
Written, Produced, and Hosted by Chelsey Weber-Smith
Young Hunting performed by Brian Peters
Rain Oh Rain performed by Dan D. Dirges
Subscribe now at https://subscription.lrb.co.uk/offers/october to try 3 months of the London Review of Books and get a free tote bag for just $6
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
19 October 2026, 7:01 am - 2 hours 17 secondsPennywise and the IT Girls (1990) with This Ends at Prom
Don’t you want a balloon? For this episode, the Wives Colangelo of the movie podcast This Ends at Prom join me to honor not only the 1990 horror miniseries Stephen King’s IT, but also its diabolical star, the late Tim Curry, whose transcendent version as Pennywise the Dancing Clown has terrified audiences for the last 26 years. Together, BJ, Harmony, and I go through the sweeping plot of IT and along the way tell stories from the making of the miniseries, give our thoughts on the meaning behind the story, and of course, wax poetic about perhaps the greatest character actor of our lifetimes (RIP).
Listen to This Ends at Prom wherever you get your podcasts
Become a Patron to support our show and get early ad-free episodes and bonus content
Or subscribe to American Hysteria on Apple Podcasts
Get some of our new merch at americanhysteria.com, all profits this month go to The Sameer Project, a Palestinian-led mutual aid group in Gaza
Leave us a message on our Urban Legends Hotline at americanhysteria.com
Producer and Editor: Miranda Zickler
Associate Producer: Riley Swedelius-Smith
Associate Editor: Kaylee Jasperson
Hosted by Chelsey Weber-Smith
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
12 October 2026, 7:01 am - 1 hour 35 minutesThe Cat in the Hat Serial Killer Panic with Guide to the Unknown
Breaking news, my dear friends, and this one’s a doozy,
an urban legend born from an uncanny movie.
Some of it’s silly, some of it’s serious,
it’s all happening now and the truth is mysterious.
The cat in the hat played by Mike Myers
burns through our Tiktoks like an uncanny fire.
Teens are using AI to make him even scarier
while the consequences are getting much hairier.
Threats against schools and threats against students
are leading to arrests from here to Saint Louis.
Will and Kristen join me from Guide to the Unknown
to cover a panic chilling parents to the bone
Is this a real problem or will kids just just be kids
who haven’t yet learned what a problem this is?
Listen to Guide to the Unknown wherever you get your podcasts
Become a Patron to support our show and get early ad-free episodes and bonus content
Or subscribe to American Hysteria on Apple Podcasts
Get some of our new merch at americanhysteria.com, all profits this month go to The Sameer Project, a Palestinian-led mutual aid group in Gaza
Leave us a message on our Urban Legends Hotline at americanhysteria.com
Producer and Editor: Miranda Zickler
Associate Producer: Riley Swedelius-Smith
Associate Editor: Kaylee Jasperson
Hosted by Chelsey Weber-Smith
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
5 October 2026, 7:01 am - 1 hour 22 minutesHalloween Newspapers.com Dive pt. 2 with Sarah Marshall
This is part two of our Halloween season kick off celebration with Sarah Marshall, host of the podcast You’re Wrong About. In this series, we use the newspapers.com archives to play our favorite game in which we give each other random words, this time Halloween related words, and see what kind of obscure, bizarre, spooky, stupid, and funny stories we can dig up from the last 200 years. For part one, I delivered my fiendish findings to Sarah, and now for part two, she will deliver her awful offerings to me, with many other tricks and treats along the way.
Become a Patron to support our show and get early ad-free episodes and bonus content
Or subscribe to American Hysteria on Apple Podcasts
Get some of our new merch at americanhysteria.com, all profits this month go to The Sameer Project, a Palestinian-led mutual aid group in Gaza
Leave us a message on our Urban Legends Hotline at americanhysteria.com
Producer and Editor: Miranda Zickler
Associate Producer: Riley Swedelius-Smith
Additional editing by Kaylee Jasperson
Hosted by Chelsey Weber-Smith
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
28 September 2026, 7:01 am - 1 hour 23 minutesHalloween Newspapers.com Dive pt. 1 with Sarah Marshall
It’s the beginning of Halloween season here at American Hysteria, and we are kicking it off with this two part episode cohosted by Sarah Marshall of You're Wrong About in which we play our favorite game, the newspapers.com Dive, using the keywords we give to each other to see what obscure bizarre, spooky, stupid, and funny articles we can pull up from the last 200 years. For part one, I will be presenting my haunted historical findings first and then next week Sarah will present hers.
Become a Patron to support our show and get early ad-free episodes and bonus content
Or subscribe to American Hysteria on Apple Podcasts
Get some of our new merch at americanhysteria.com, all profits this month go to The Sameer Project, a Palestinian-led mutual aid group in Gaza
Leave us a message on our Urban Legends Hotline at americanhysteria.com
Producer and Editor: Miranda Zickler
Associate Producer: Riley Swedelius-Smith
Additional editing by Kaylee Jasperson
Hosted by Chelsey Weber-Smith
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
21 September 2026, 7:01 am - 1 hour 30 minutesLet's Talk About Sex (Ed) with Margaret Grace Myers
For this Back to School episode, we are getting schooled in the history of sexual education by Margaret Grace Myers, author of The Fight for Sex Ed: The Century-Long Battle Between Truth and Doctrine. Through STI public health crises, sex work moral panics, eugenic visions, world wars, sexual revolutions, and the rise of the Christian right, sex ed has always been a potent cultural battleground that has remained remarkably similar decade over decade, a fight for the soul of a nation that has never quite known how to deal with S-E-X.
Get a copy of The Fight for Sex Ed
Out now in paperback!
Become a Patron to support our show and get early ad-free episodes and bonus content
Or subscribe to American Hysteria on Apple Podcasts
Get some of our new merch at americanhysteria.com, all profits this month go to The Sameer Project, a Palestinian-led mutual aid group in Gaza
Leave us a message on our Urban Legends Hotline at americanhysteria.com
Producer and Editor: Miranda Zickler
Associate Producer: Riley Swedelius-Smith
Additional editing by Kaylee Jasperson
Hosted by Chelsey Weber-Smith
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
14 September 2026, 7:01 am - 1 hour 27 minutesBaby Got Backstory with Heather Radke
For this episode, we are covering the storied history of the Butt, that humorous, salacious, anxiety-inducing part of the body, the shape and meaning of which has changed depending on the time period. Heather Radke is a reporter, essayist, RadioLab contributing editor, and the author of the book Butts: A Backstory, and she shares with me both the amusing and the darker aspects of this backstory, including its racialized history and the way that especially white culture has understood, appropriated, and exploited the body part on an ongoing basis. We’ll discuss why and how the butt has gone in and out of style over the centuries, what it has meant at different times to different types of people, and what may be the future of the butt as we know it.
Get a copy of Butts: A Backstory
Heather's Substack: Petite Patate
Become a Patron to support our show and get early ad-free episodes and bonus content
Or subscribe to American Hysteria on Apple Podcasts
Get some of our new merch at americanhysteria.com, all profits this month go to The Sameer Project, a Palestinian-led mutual aid group in Gaza
Leave us a message on our Urban Legends Hotline at americanhysteria.com
Producer and Editor: Miranda Zickler
Associate Producer: Riley Swedelius-Smith
Additional editing by Kaylee Jasperson
Hosted by Chelsey Weber-Smith
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
7 September 2026, 7:01 am - More Episodes? Get the App