<p>The Webby Award-winning “<a href="https://www.theboxofoddities.com/">Box of Oddities</a>" is a podcast that delves into the strange and mysterious aspects of our world, exploring topics ranging from bizarre medical conditions to unsolved mysteries, and from paranormal phenomena to strange cultural practices from around the world. With a focus on oddities, curiosities, and the macabre, each episode is a journey into the unknown, where hosts Kat and Jethro Gilligan Toth share their love for unusual stories and inject their humor and commentary. From the strange history of medical practices to chilling true crime stories, to natural (and unnatural) events, "The Box of Oddities" satisfies your thirst for the weird and the unusual, offering an informative and entertaining look into the dark and mysterious corners of our world.</p><p><strong>JIMMY KIMMEL, ABC-TV says, "</strong>Should you be the type who has an interest in weird stuff, this is a fun thing to allow in your head!" </p><p><br></p><p>“Truth is stranger than fiction, and the Box of Oddities is the strangest of all!” <strong>-SLUGGO, SIRIUS XM LITHIUM</strong></p><p><br></p><p>“Kat & Jethro wring humor from bizarre, macabre and perplexing places.” <strong>-BOSTON MAGAZINE</strong></p>
In this episode of The Box of Oddities, Kat and Jethro wander into one of the strangest phrases ever to appear in official U.S. government records: “Unexplained human presence detected.” Buried inside real Freedom of Information Act documents, this calm, clinical line appears again and again across decades of federal incident reports—acknowledging signs of human movement, interaction, and intention… without ever finding a human being. What does it mean when trained professionals confirm a presence, rule out mechanical causes, and then simply stop writing? The conversation drifts through surveillance systems, human perception, AI pattern recognition, and that deeply familiar feeling that someone was just there—close enough to leave a trace—before vanishing.
From there, the episode plunges (sometimes literally) into Devil’s Hole, Nevada: a narrow limestone fissure hiding a warm surface pool, a bottomless-seeming abyss, and the only natural habitat of the critically endangered Devil’s Hole pupfish. The hosts explore how this unassuming opening drops more than 1,200 feet into darkness, has claimed multiple divers, reacts to earthquakes thousands of miles away, and even attracted the obsessive attention of Charles Manson. With stories of vanished bodies, seismic sloshing, baffling depths, and fragile life clinging to a single rocky shelf, this episode blends government mystery, geological terror, and existential unease—plus a brief, emotional detour involving a rescued monarch butterfly named Crumplewing. As always, it’s strange, funny, unsettling, and just grounded enough in real documentation to make it linger long after the episode ends.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Could ancient Romans really talk to the dead—and did they build a device to help them do it?
In this episode of The Box of Oddities, Kat and Jethro tumble headfirst into one of archaeology’s strangest unsolved mysteries: the Roman dodecahedron. These small bronze objects—covered in holes, studded with knobs, and found almost exclusively in frontier regions of the Roman Empire—have baffled historians for centuries. No instructions. No records. No explanation. Just geometry… and silence.
We explore a growing theory that these objects weren’t tools or toys at all, but ritual devices used for necromancy. Drawing from documented Roman practices—curse tablets, grave rituals, offerings to the dead—we examine how light, fire, human remains, and sacred geometry may have combined to create controlled states of altered perception. Not summoning ghosts exactly… but thinning the veil just enough.
From Plato’s cosmic geometry to the eerie absence of these artifacts in Rome itself, the clues point toward forbidden practices quietly carried out on the edges of empire—where Roman order collided with older Celtic beliefs about the dead being nearby, accessible, and occasionally helpful.
Along the way, the episode drifts (as it always does) into unexpected territory: midnight peanut-butter trauma, the strange comfort of reincarnated pets, and a surprisingly deep dive into how humans have measured time—from candle clocks and cow milkings to Planck time and absurdly large cosmic units. Because when you start talking about death, you inevitably end up talking about time… and how little of it we feel we have.
It’s a conversation about ancient fears, forbidden knowledge, and the unsettling possibility that some things were never written down because they worked just well enough to scare people into silence.
Fly your freak flag proudly—and maybe don’t peer too deeply into glowing bronze objects near a grave.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
The Inbox of Oddities is where the strange, the personal, and the unexplained land when listeners finally decide, “Okay… I should probably tell someone about this.”
This episode —stories of disconnected intercoms that answer anyway, phone numbers that refuse to stay in the past, quiet paranormal moments, accidental synchronicities, emotional confessions, and deeply human encounters with the bizarre.
Some messages are funny. Some are tender. Some sit uncomfortably in that space where coincidence starts to feel like something more. From subtle “boo effects” and lifelong oddities to moments of connection, curiosity, and unease, Inbox of Oddities captures the voices of listeners who aren’t claiming answers—just sharing what happened.
This is not loud paranormal storytelling. These are believable accounts, told plainly, often without conclusions. Just the kind of stories that linger after you turn the lights off.
If you’ve ever hesitated before pressing a button, answering a call, or admitting something strange happened to you—this inbox is already familiar.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
When Bureaucracy Kills You on Paper and the 1906 exorcism of Clara Germana Cele.
What if you woke up one morning and discovered the government had already buried you—on paper?
In this episode of The Box of Oddities, Kat and Jethro explore the quietly terrifying phenomenon of bureaucratic death: real cases in which living people were officially declared dead due to clerical errors, missing-person rulings, or database failures—and then found it nearly impossible to prove they were alive again. Bank accounts frozen. Benefits canceled. Identities erased. All because a system designed for finality has no process for resurrection.
From Social Security records that spread like digital wildfire to court rulings that insist you missed the deadline to object to your own death, this story exposes the absurd and Kafkaesque consequences of modern bureaucracy. We look at documented cases including men who stood in court, breathing and speaking, while judges acknowledged their physical existence—yet refused to reverse their legal death.
Then, just when you think reality has regained its footing, we pivot into one of the most chilling possession cases on record: the 1906 exorcism of Clara Germana Cele, a young orphan raised in a South African mission school. Accounts describe violent behavior, alleged levitation, sudden fluency in multiple languages, and a prolonged exorcism sanctioned by the Catholic Church. But viewed through a modern lens, the story raises unsettling questions about trauma, power, colonialism, and what happens when fear becomes doctrine.
Is possession supernatural—or is it what happens when vulnerable people are given no language for their suffering?
As always, we separate documented facts from speculation, explore credible historical sources, and sit comfortably in the discomfort where certainty breaks down. Also included: dangerously compassionate lizard-warming strategies, the unexpected poetry of snowplow names, and the reminder that sometimes the scariest thing in the room isn’t a demon—it’s a system that refuses to see you.
Because being alive, it turns out, is not always enough.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Why did Henry David Thoreau care so much about pencils—and why did some phone numbers keep ringing long after they were disconnected?
In this episode of The Box of Oddities, Kat and Jethro wander into two stories that shouldn’t be connected… but somehow are.
First, we look at the surprising industrial legacy of Henry David Thoreau, long before Walden Pond. As a young man working in his family’s pencil business, Thoreau applied chemistry, precision, and quiet rebellion to fix America’s worst pencils—changing how graphite was processed, how pencils were graded, and why most pencils are still yellow today. It’s a story about innovation, independence, and how financial stability made room for deep thinking… and eventually, deliberate living.
Then, the episode takes a darker turn.
During the 1960s and 70s, people across the U.S. reported receiving phone calls from businesses that had been closed—sometimes for decades. Funeral homes. Pharmacies. Local shops. Callers insisted they had just spoken to someone on the line. Engineers found nothing. Phone companies found no active service. The FCC investigated. No explanation stuck.
What emerged instead was something stranger: the idea of telecom afterimages—echoes of human habit lingering in old copper wire. Conversations without ghosts. Voices without intent. Systems that didn’t quite know how to forget.
This episode explores how infrastructure remembers, how absence isn’t always clean, and why the most unsettling stories are often the quietest ones—ordinary conversations that shouldn’t exist, but somehow do.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
The Inbox of Oddities is back, and this one is packed wall-to-wall with listener stories that refuse to sit quietly in the corner.
From strange family rules that outlive their original reasons, to rooms that seem to rearrange themselves when no one is looking, this episode drifts through the liminal spaces where memory, coincidence, and something else overlap. You’ll hear about a sealed bedroom no one ever used, estate-sale finds that may have come with unexpected passengers, familiar landscapes that suddenly no longer exist, and the unsettling moment when reality feels just slightly… misaligned.
There are haunted ashes, unexplained footsteps, missing trees, objects found hidden inside walls, and those deeply unnerving childhood moments when kids say things they absolutely should not know. Along the way, we also share stories of medically fragile rescue animals, odd family traditions, and the quiet, human instinct to notice when the world doesn’t behave the way it’s supposed to.
These aren’t big, flashy hauntings. They’re the subtle ones—the kind that linger. The kind that make you pause in a doorway and wonder if something shifted while you weren’t paying attention.
All stories are shared by listeners, in their own words, because sometimes the strangest things happen to perfectly ordinary people.
Welcome to the Inbox.
Fly that freak flag proudly.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
What happens when a military base shuts down… but the signals don’t?
In this episode of The Box of Oddities, Kat and Jethro dig into a strange, documented mystery tied to Camp Hero in Montauk, New York—a Cold War radar installation officially decommissioned in the early 1980s. Years after the gates were locked and the radar went dark, amateur ham radio operators began logging unexplained voice transmissions seemingly originating from the abandoned site.
These weren’t bursts of static or pirate radio chatter. Operators reported calm, procedural phrases—short, clipped, emotionally neutral language consistent with military communications. Even more unsettling: some transmissions appeared to echo Cold War–era radar terminology that had been out of use for decades. The reports were consistent, carefully logged, and compelling enough that they were forwarded to the FCC, which investigated and acknowledged the anomalies… but never provided a public explanation.
Kat and Jethro walk through what we know for certain about Camp Hero, the documented reports from experienced radio operators, and why Montauk’s long history of high strangeness makes this case especially unsettling. From theories involving atmospheric conditions and signal propagation to more speculative ideas about residual transmissions, time displacement, and non-intelligent “hauntings” of technology itself, this episode explores how systems built to listen may sometimes keep doing so long after we think they’ve stopped.
Along the way, the conversation veers—delightfully—into unexpected territory, including bizarre animal adoption names, Denmark’s most aggressively tasteless amusement park, and the thin line between serious investigation and the absurd places curiosity can take you.
As always, the story stays rooted in documented accounts, official records, and firsthand reports—leaving you to decide whether these voices were nothing more than interference… or echoes from something that never fully powered down.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
What happens when a wall hides more than it should?
In this episode of The Box of Oddities, Kat and Jethro explore two unsettling, very real stories where history was quietly sealed away—literally and figuratively.
First, we descend into the forgotten basement of Danvers State Hospital in Massachusetts, where renovation crews in the 1990s uncovered a bricked-over corridor that didn’t exist on any blueprints. Inside were intact treatment rooms, restraint fixtures, and medical equipment from an era psychiatric institutions would rather forget. No records. No documentation. And once discovered, the space was quietly sealed again.
Then we shift to a powerful and often overlooked chapter in American medical history: Freedom House Ambulance Service in Pittsburgh. In the 1960s, a group of Black paramedics—trained at an unprecedented level—quietly invented modern emergency medical care. They saved hundreds of lives, revolutionized on-scene treatment, and laid the foundation for today’s EMS systems… before being erased from history when the city took over the program.
Along the way, we talk about institutional amnesia, medical ethics, abandoned practices, historical erasure, and why the scariest stories are often the ones that actually happened.
Because sometimes the question isn’t what’s haunting a place—
It’s what was deliberately forgotten.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Inbox of Oddities returns with a collection of listener stories that live in the unsettling space between coincidence and something more. A clock that refuses to keep proper time after changing hands. An apartment with footsteps, furniture sounds, and faint classical music—despite being officially unoccupied. A sleep paralysis experience involving a towering shadow figure with blinding white eyes. A lone dress shoe appearing in a hospital elevator with no explanation. From strange childhood remarks about “dead people” in the yard to soft, familiar knocks heard years after a loved one’s passing, these stories aren’t about monsters or jump scares—they’re about the quiet moments that linger, the things people notice and then carry with them. This episode weaves listener emails, reflections on memory, grief, lucid dreaming, and the odd comfort found in unexplained experiences that don’t demand belief—only attention. Perfect listening for anyone who’s ever paused mid-dishwashing and wondered if the world is just a little stranger than we admit.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
In this episode of The Box of Oddities, Kat and Jethro explore how some mysteries don’t announce themselves with screaming headlines or dramatic hauntings—but instead settle in quietly and refuse to leave.
The episode slips into dark territory with the true and well-documented case of the Hexham Heads—two crude stone carvings unearthed by children in a backyard in 1970s England. What followed were subtle but persistent disturbances: unexplained knocking, moving objects, and a growing sense that the house itself was reacting to something that should never have been brought inside. Investigated by members of the Society for Psychical Research, the case raises an unsettling possibility—that some hauntings are tied not to places but to objects that carry history badly.
In the second half, the episode turns from the paranormal to forensic science with the decades-long mystery of Little Miss Lake Panasoffkee. Discovered murdered in Florida in 1971, she remained unidentified for over fifty years despite repeated exhumations, reconstructions, and scientific analysis. Advances in forensic technology finally restored her name—Maureen Lou Rowan—while also revealing how earlier scientific conclusions were quietly skewed by embalming practices of the era. The story becomes a sobering reminder that science evolves, truth is fragile, and identity can be lost far too easily.
Along the way, Kat and Jethro weave in observations about human behavior, survival instincts, and the strange overlap between curiosity, caution, and consequence. No jump scares. No neat endings. Just a lingering sense that some things—objects, histories, and unresolved lives—leave marks long after they’re buried.
If you’re fascinated by haunted objects, unsolved mysteries, forensic breakthroughs, and the quieter side of the unexplained, this episode delivers stories that stay with you well after the final sign-off
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
What happens when a town disappears—but the dead are left behind?
This episode begins with a familiar American disaster: Centralia, Pennsylvania, the coal town that has been burning underground since 1962. Most people know the story of the smoke, the buckling roads, and the evacuation. Far fewer know what happened after the living left—when the cemeteries remained, sitting directly above an active underground fire.
We explore how burial grounds like the Assumption of the Blessed Virgin Mary Cemetery slowly began to shift. Headstones tilted. Graves rotated. Steam vented from the soil. Over decades, officials were forced to make an unthinkable series of decisions: which graves to exhume, which to leave behind, and how to negotiate with families when the ground itself could no longer be trusted to stay still. Some remains were relocated. Many were not. And today, the fire still burns beneath them—possibly for centuries to come.
It’s not a ghost story. There are no apparitions or legends. And somehow, that makes it worse.
In the second half of the episode, we turn to a very different kind of quiet revolution: Florence Nightingale, the woman often reduced to a single image—the “Lady with the Lamp.” We dig past the myth to uncover her real legacy as a pioneer of sanitation, hospital reform, and statistical analysis. From filthy Crimean War hospitals to the invention of the coxcomb chart, Nightingale used data, discipline, and relentless attention to detail to save lives—and permanently change modern medicine.
Along the way: strange facts about snow, burning earth, shifting assumptions about permanence, and the unsettling realization that even the most basic promises—like the ground holding still—can fail.
Because sometimes the oddest stories aren’t about what rises from the grave…
They’re about what refuses to stay buried.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices