• 1 hour 2 minutes
    It's Been a Challenge

    Zack and T.J. discuss the Guardians' continued struggles in challenging balls and strikes and how burning through them helped push them toward a bullpen meltdown against Boston, how the offense continues to be limited by Jose Ramirez's league average contributions and the overall lack of team power in recent series, and Mike Aviles' calves.

    We hope you’ll consider joining our exclusive Guardians community of fans in our Discord, you’ll get an ADDITIONAL episode per week, all for supporting the show for $5 per month at Patreon.com/SelbyIsGodcast

    Listeners get $20 off their first ticket purchase at SEATGEEK with the promo code: SELBY.

    1 June 2026, 2:34 pm
  • 57 minutes 43 seconds
    Bazzana: Fun To Watch

    Zack and T.J. discuss what makes the perfect leadoff hitter in today's game ... is Travis Bazzana it? Cleveland wins a series in Philly which saw them play very mature, lead by strong outings by Parker Messick and Gavin Williams. The bullpen is rounding into form. Also, what's been the biggest difference for Brayan Rocchio?

    We hope you’ll consider joining our exclusive Guardians community of fans in our Discord, you’ll get an ADDITIONAL episode per week, all for supporting the show for $5 per month at Patreon.com/SelbyIsGodcast

    Listeners get $20 off their first ticket purchase at SEATGEEK with the promo code: SELBY.

    25 May 2026, 3:13 pm
  • 1 hour 2 minutes
    Angelic Performance

    Zack and T.J. talk about the offense sparking to life against the Reds, led by Angel Martinez's 4 homers this week. What did José Ramírez know when he said he'd be a star several years ago? We also talk about Kyle Manzardo emerging from his slump and the exciting young pieces of this offense showing more of the ingredients for run-scoring. Finally, the guys discuss memories from the 2016 Indians.

    We hope you’ll consider joining our exclusive Guardians community of fans in our Discord, you’ll get an ADDITIONAL episode per week, all for supporting the show for $5 per month at Patreon.com/SelbyIsGodcast

    Listeners get $20 off their first ticket purchase at SEATGEEK with the promo code: SELBY.

    18 May 2026, 2:27 pm
  • 47 minutes 16 seconds
    Well, That Was Annoying...

    We discuss a series loss to the Twins that saw the Guardians strand 25 runners and not produce with the bases loaded on multiple occasions in the final two games, then Zack and T.J. reflect further on Steven Kwan's struggles in the leadoff spot, Travis Bazzana's on-base ability in front of the wrong hitters and why a change seems necessary at the top of the lineup.

    We also discuss additional thoughts on the Patrick Bailey trade and how it seems to unlock the best usage of David Fry.We hope you’ll consider joining our exclusive Guardians community of fans in our Discord, you’ll get an ADDITIONAL episode per week, all for supporting the show for $5 per month at Patreon.com/SelbyIsGodcast

    11 May 2026, 2:07 pm
  • 27 minutes 15 seconds
    EMERGENCY: Guardians Trade for MLB's Best Defensive Catcher

    This is the audio version of our live stream from Saturday after the Guardians traded for Patrick Bailey from the Giants and optioned Bo Naylor to Triple-A.

    Zack offers his perspective from Progressive Field.

    9 May 2026, 9:27 pm
  • 1 hour 2 minutes
    Reshuffle Needed?

    Zack and T.J. talk discuss the good and bad of Cleveland's .500 record, including a possible need for a reshuffle of the lineup and the bullpen. Also, which hitters have been thriving over the past two weeks? Which recent prospect promotion has you the most excited?

    We hope you’ll consider joining our exclusive Guardians community of fans in our Discord, you’ll get an ADDITIONAL episode per week, all for supporting the show for $5 per month at Patreon.com/SelbyIsGodcast

    5 May 2026, 3:00 pm
  • 27 minutes 15 seconds
    EMERGENCY: Guardians Calling Up Travis Bazzana

    Zack and T.J. react to the Guardians preparing to promote former No. 1 overall pick Travis Bazzana for his MLB debut.

    28 April 2026, 3:13 am
  • 1 hour 4 minutes
    Numbers That Help Define Guards' First Month

    Zack and T.J. discuss the Guardians not taking a promising start to the series in Toronto into a series win, then Meisel hits Zuppe with 7 numbers that help define the first month of the season for Cleveland

    We hope you’ll consider joining our exclusive Guardians community of fans in our Discord, you’ll get an ADDITIONAL episode per week, all for supporting the show for $5 per month at Patreon.com/SelbyIsGodcast

    27 April 2026, 2:50 pm
  • 1 hour 8 minutes
    Is Jose Trying To Lead Baseball In Steals?

    Zack Meisel and T.J. Zuppe recap an impressive series win against the Orioles and overcoming a brutal loss on Friday night in the process, chat about Parker Messick's near no-hitter, Jose Ramirez's great weekend, Cade Smith showing some of the Cade we remember, Brayan Rocchio's solid April numbers and Daniel Schneemann carving out an important role. Also, do we need to have Travis Bazzana's expectations set in stone before he ever debuts?

    ___

    We hope you’ll consider joining our exclusive Guardians community of fans in our Discord, you’ll get an ADDITIONAL episode per week, all for supporting the show for $5 per month at Patreon.com/SelbyIsGodcast

    Listeners get $20 off their first ticket purchase at SEATGEEK with the promo code: SELBY.

    20 April 2026, 3:16 pm
  • 55 minutes 27 seconds
    Changing (or Confirming) Their Outlook

    Zack Meisel and T.J. Zuppe discuss Cleveland dropping their first series of the season to Atlanta, chat about which players have done the most to confirm or change their outlook for the year so far, unlucky hitters, the rotation -- Joey Cantillo, Parker Messick and Tanner Bibee in particular -- and Angel Martinez's hard-hit increase.

    We hope you’ll consider joining our exclusive Guardians community of fans in our Discord, you’ll get an ADDITIONAL episode per week, all for supporting the show for $5 per month at Patreon.com/SelbyIsGodcast

    Listeners get $20 off their first ticket purchase at SEATGEEK with the promo code: SELBY.

    13 April 2026, 2:33 pm
  • 55 minutes 28 seconds
    Good Early Guards Vibes Against Baseball's Best

    Guardians are off to a 6-4 start despite playing some of baseball's best teams to begin the year. Zack Meisel and T.J. Zuppe talk about the good vibes that come from unexpected contributions -- Gabriel Arias, Austin Hedges and C.J. Kayfus on Sunday in particular -- while pondering when the best players on the roster, like Kyle Manzardo and Jose Ramirez, will begin to pick it up. Then, the guys talk about Ramirez reaching another Cleveland milestone, Rhys Hoskins' increased early bat speed and the implementation of the ABS system.

    We hope you’ll consider joining our exclusive Guardians community of fans in our Discord, you’ll get an ADDITIONAL episode per week, all for supporting the show for $5 per month at Patreon.com/SelbyIsGodcast

    Listeners get $20 off their first ticket purchase at SEATGEEK with the promo code: SELBY.

    6 April 2026, 2:54 pm
  • More Episodes? Get the App