- 40 minutes 8 secondsWhy Most Loan Officers Get ZERO ROI From Social Media
You’ve been sold a lie: that if you just post enough content, the business will come.
It won’t. And in this guest-host takeover of Mortgage Marketing Radio, Michelle Mikel and Jennifer Butcher prove it with real numbers.
Jen is a 25-year mortgage veteran and host of the She Talks Money podcast. She was doing what all the gurus tell you to do — five videos a week, a polished feed, all of it. And she was still stuck on the question that haunts every originator: “When am I actually going to make money from this?”
So guest host Michelle Mikel put her through a 30-day challenge built on one rule that sounds too simple to work: one message a day, to one person you don’t know.
Inside this episode, you’ll hear:
• Why the $5,000/month social media manager is rarely
the answer (and what Jen pays instead)• The difference between content that gets 20,000 views and content that gets paid
• The exact 4-part message framework that took Jen’s “yes” rate from ~30% to nearly 50%
• The “ick” prospecting lines you’re probably still using, and what to say instead
• How 30 messages turned into 5 podcasts, 6 agent meetings, and a calendar booked into July
If you’re tired of pouring time and money into content that doesn’t pay you back, this is the episode.
Hit play. Then send one message today.
———
Connect with Jennifer Butcher on Instagram: @JenniferButcherOfficial
Listen to Jennifer’s podcast:
Apple: https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/she-talks-money/id1805894710
Spotify: https://open.spotify.com/show/2tVr8kAQv8L3xbhdOoWpvg?si=c915dc1f09e94139
Connect with Michelle Mikel on Instagram: @BermanMediaSocial18 June 2026, 5:00 pm - 17 minutes 35 secondsThe 2026 LinkedIn Algorithm (Quick Hit)
I studied two new research reports covering 260,000+ LinkedIn posts — and in this quick-hit episode, I break down exactly what's working on LinkedIn in 2026, specifically for loan officers and mortgage pros who want to get seen, build a personal brand, and attract referral partners.
Just the data, and what to actually do with it.
You'll learn:
✅ Whether links really hurt your reach (the answer surprised me)
✅ The format with an 11X interaction boost most LOs never use
✅ Why horizontal video beats vertical by 36% on LinkedIn
✅ The post length that performs 31% better in 2026
✅ The hashtag habit that drops performance 70%
✅ The 741% rule the top 1% of creators live by
✅ The lead magnet quietly crushing it right now (it's not a PDF)
🔗 RESOURCES & LINKS
Build your personal brand voice with Katie Shive → https://www.KatieShive.com
Want in on the next agent class cohort? It opens in September and fills fast. CLICK HERE to RSVP: https://tinyurl.com/arxcohort
1 June 2026, 11:27 pm - 10 minutes 55 secondsStop Trying to Beat the Algorithm.
You feel it, don't you? That constant pressure to post more, create more, be more online — just to keep up. Meanwhile, your pipeline isn't moving the way it should.
Here's what nobody's telling you: the top-producing loan officers I work with aren't stressing about their next post going viral. They're doing something different. Something that's been working since before social media existed. And it's making a massive comeback.
In this episode, I'm going off-script to challenge the "post more" narrative that the gurus keep pushing. I'll share why IRL — in real life — local influence is outperforming the algorithm for the loan officers I coach. And I'll give you real stories from real LOs who've added $20M, $30M, even doubled their production — not by becoming influencers, but by becoming the go-to lender in their local market.
You'll hear:
→ Why the "content creator" pressure is burning you out (and what to do instead)
→ The strategy that's landing LOs in front of 20-30 agents at a time
→ How one LO turned a single workshop into a spot on a national sales training call with 400+ agents
→ Why direct mail is working (yes, even with millennials)
→ Jeff Bezos's question that should change how you think about your business
→ Details on the Agent Referral Accelerator cohort launching May 21st
If you're tired of feeding the algorithm and ready to build real relationships that generate real referrals — this one's for you.
🔗 Learn more: https:www.getmoreagents.com
📩 DM me on Instagram or LinkedIn with questions
13 May 2026, 10:48 pm - 16 minutesCancer, AI, and What's Next
Six weeks ago, I went silent. No episodes. No posts. No noise.
I was fighting cancer.
Squamous cell carcinoma of the tonsil and tongue. Two rounds of chemo. Thirty rounds of radiation. And a whole lot of time to think.
Today, I'm back. And I'm not just picking up where I left off — I'm coming back with new clarity, new energy, and some powerful insights I can't wait to share with you.
In this episode:
What the last 6 weeks looked like (the real version, not the polished one)
A huge thank-you to the guest hosts who kept this show alive while I was down
What I've been studying about AI, marketing, and visibility is about to change the game for mortgage professionals
HubSpot's new AEO tool and why "Answer Engine Optimization" should be on every LO's radar right now
A tease of a pivotal change coming soon to Mortgage Marketing Radio and MMI
This is a personal one. It's also one of the most important episodes I've ever recorded. If you've ever been knocked down and had to figure out how to get back up — this one's for you.
Episode Resources:Hubspot AEO Tool: https://www.hubspot.com/products/aeo
Connect with Geoff:
Instagram: @GeoffZimpfer
LinkedIn: linkedin.com/in/geoffzimpfer
YouTube: Subscribe to Mortgage Marketing Radio
1 May 2026, 10:53 pm - 37 minutes 37 secondsThe AI Mistake Killing Loan Officers in 2026
Mike Faraci (founder of Red Button Media) sat down with James Duncan (former mortgage marketing exec, now advising at Calum Advisors) to tackle the question every loan officer is quietly asking right now:
"With so many new AI tools dropping every week... what the heck am I actually supposed to be doing?"
Here's what you'll walk away with:
→ The one question to ask yourself before adopting ANY new tool, platform, or AI "solution" (miss this and you'll burn months chasing shiny objects)
→ Why "prompt engineering" is a skill — not a position — and the exact move James uses to get AI to prompt ITSELF on your behalf
→ The "story vs. point of view" distinction that separates forgettable loan officers from the ones clients actively seek out
→ Mike's 24-hour video challenge that got one broker TWO extra referrals in a single week (spoiler: it takes less time than typing the text)
→ The "Domino's Pizza Tracker" trick one mortgage company stole to boost loan process engagement
→ Why AI avatars are going to be the downfall of loan officers who lean too hard into them — and what to do instead
→ The truth about niching down that most LOs are getting wrong
Whether you're a producing LO, a marketing director, or a CEO trying to figure out how to stay human in an AI-saturated market — this one's for you.
Mentioned in this episode:
Red Button Media → hittheredbutton.com
Connect with Mike: LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/mikefaraci/
Connect with James: LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/jamesduncan-caelum/
16 April 2026, 10:42 pm - 37 minutes 49 secondsThe Real Reason Next Gen Buyers Won't Call You
Most loan officers are solving the wrong problem.
They think next-gen buyers need lower rates. Or bigger down payment assistance programs. Or easier qualifying standards.
The data disagrees.
Kristin Messerli, Co-Founder of First Home IQ, has spent six years surveying 9,000-plus respondents to study exactly what is holding millennials and Gen Z back from buying their first home. And what she found is that the biggest barriers have nothing to do with money.
They have everything to do with trust, overwhelm, and misinformation.
In this episode of Mortgage Marketing Radio, guest host Katie Shive and Kristin break down the 2026 NextGen Homebuyer Report -- what the data reveals, what it means for your business, and what you can do about it right now.
Links and Resources:
NextGen Homebuyer Report 2026: https://nextgenhomebuyer.com/reports/2026
First Home IQ: https://firsthomeiq.com/
First Home IQ Monday Workshop (Free): https://firsthomeiq.com/workshop/
Geoff Zimpfer Lunch and Learn Resources: https://join.goagentrx.com/webinar
Connect With Katie Shive: https://katieshive.com/
8 April 2026, 7:53 pm - 39 minutes 1 second$4 BILLION in Mortgages (Before Age 40) Here's EXACTLY How He Did It
He's closed over $4 billion in mortgage production. He's not yet 40. And there's a good chance you've never heard of him.
That changes today.
In this power-packed episode, NFM Lending Managing Director Greg Sher steps in to guest host and sits down with one of the most quietly elite loan originators in the country, Oleg Tkach. Born in Ukraine, started in mortgage at 18, and built a $4 billion career without a major social media presence, without cold calling, and without ever chasing business the "old school" way.
This is the kind of interview you stop what you're doing to listen to. Twice.
Here's what Oleg breaks down in this episode:
→ The "Agent Programming" strategy — why most LOs are accidentally training their agents NOT to send them business (and how to flip the script)
→ The #1 conversion killer in your business right now (hint: it has nothing to do with your rate or your product)
→ Why trying to be an agent's PRIMARY lender may be the biggest mistake you're making — and what to go for instead
→ The 3-level agent relationship framework: Business Level, Backup Level, and Program Level
→ Why "the friend zone" is killing your referral pipeline and how to escape it
→ Oleg's Zoom + PowerPoint presentation strategy that gets agent meetings from anywhere — no drive-bys, no donut runs
→ How one of his coaching students went from $93 million to on pace for $240 million in one year
→ The 3-part formula behind "your best year ever" — simple enough to execute, powerful enough to break COVID-era refi numbers with purchases
→ Impact Elite Coaching's "The LAB" event — April 22–23 in Newport Beach at the Pendry Hotel
Learn More About The Lab Event: https://www.impactelitecoaching.com/the-lab
Thanks to Greg Sher for guest-hosting the podcast again. Let Greg know if you liked this episode.Connect with Greg on LinkedIn here: https://www.linkedin.com/in/greg-sher/
Ready to scale your agent referrals without chasing or cold-calling? New cohort opening in April.
Get on the waitlist here: https://go.myagentclasses.com/home2 April 2026, 5:57 pm - 52 minutes 32 secondsHow Loan Officers Are Losing Deals To A $20/Month Chatbot
A borrower you've closed loans for before just photographed your Loan Estimate and dropped it into ChatGPT.
The AI told them you're overcharging.
You're not. But they believed it anyway — and the deal went somewhere else.
This is not a hypothetical. It happened to one of Trevor York's clients last week. And according to a stat dropped in this conversation, 77% of consumers now trust AI as much as a human expert. That number was lower a year ago. It will be higher next year.
So here's the real question: when your client runs your deal through a chatbot tonight — and some of them will — is the trust you've built strong enough to survive it?
In this episode of Mortgage Marketing Radio, I sit down with Trevor York — loan officer, founder of LinkSpot, and one of the most forward-thinking minds in the mortgage industry — to break down exactly what is happening to loan officers who haven't figured this out yet. And more importantly, what the ones who have figured it out are doing differently.
This is not a feel-good conversation. It is a wake-up call.
CONNECT WITH TREVOR YORK:
LinkSpot: https://www.linkspot.com
Instagram: @trevoryork
Connect With Katie Shive:
LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/katieshive/Website: https://katieshive.com/
26 March 2026, 9:43 pm - 53 minutes 7 secondsWhy This LO Refuses to Quote a Rate
What if the loan officers who are struggling most to grow their business are asking the wrong question — and one loan officer from Fargo, North Dakota figured out the right one?
In this episode, guest host Katie Shive sits down with Kayla Kallander — a top-producing loan officer, LinkedIn powerhouse, and first-time home buyer advocate who's built a referral machine in one of the most overlooked markets in the country.
If you think first-time home buyers are too much work for too little payoff, this episode is going to flip that script entirely.
Here's what we get into:
"Prescription Without Diagnosis Is Malpractice" — Why Kayla refuses to quote a rate before she knows the full picture, and how this one mindset shift positions her as a trusted advisor instead of a commodity.
The Realtor "Three Card" Problem — What Kayla says to realtors who still give out multiple lender cards, and the exact script she uses to get exclusive referrals.
Social Media Without a Marketing Team — She's active on LinkedIn, Instagram, Facebook, and TikTok — with just a VA and a Canva account. She breaks down exactly how she does it and why stories are where the real magic happens.
Why LinkedIn is the Most Underrated Platform for Loan Officers — How one LinkedIn post led to a group of financial advisors sending her 30% of her annual business — from a state she'd never even worked in.
The Real Cost of Rate Shopping — The client who called comparing rates from a Minnesota credit union and what Kayla said that turned it around on the spot.
The Magic of First-Time Buyers — Why the clients most loan officers avoid are the ones building Kayla's most loyal referral base.
The Viral Carousel Post — How a contrarian Saturday morning post about interest rates triggered more DMs, new followers, and a cross-state referral relationship than anything she'd posted before.
Plus — how she's using AI (specifically Claude) with a custom brand book to write content that actually sounds like her, not a robot.
Whether you're a veteran loan officer looking to reignite your pipeline or a newer LO trying to figure out where to start, this conversation is loaded with real, repeatable strategies that are working right now.
Listen. Take notes. Then go post something.
Show Notes / Resources Mentioned:
Connect with Kayla on LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/kayla-kallander/
Connect with Kayla on Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/kaylakallandermortgage/
First Home IQ: https://www.firsthomeiq.com/
LenderCrate: https://lendercrate.com/
Coffee and Contracts: https://coffeecontracts.com/
Claude AI: https://claude.ai/
Connect with Katie on LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/katieshive/
19 March 2026, 9:34 pm - 56 minutes 19 seconds121 Units. Half the Team. One AI System
What does it actually look like when a top-producing loan officer stops dabbling with AI and fully embeds it into every layer of his mortgage business?
In this episode of Mortgage Marketing Radio, guest host Katie Shive sits down with Abdel Khawatmi — Area Manager and founder of Got Mortgages with PRMG — to break down the exact system behind 121 units, $40M in personal production, and 210% net revenue growth year over year.
This is not a conversation about generating social media captions with ChatGPT. This is a ground-level look at how a working originator rebuilt his operations, client experience, and team structure around AI — and what that means for every loan officer trying to compete right now.
What you'll learn:
Why Abdel cut his offshore team from 7 to 3 — and what AI does instead
How he uses ChatGPT to calculate Schedule C & E income, build SOPs, and draft compliant letters of explanation
Why he’s on the phone with clients MORE since implementing AI — not less
The hyperlocal event strategy that his referral partners can't stop talking about
His ROI framework: Relevance, Omnipresence & Intimacy
The 4-step client experience model that keeps his pipeline full without him being the first touch
The one thing he tells every loan officer who asks, "where do I start?"
If you are a loan officer grinding in a tough market and wondering how to build a smarter, leaner, more profitable business — this is the episode you have been waiting for.
Connect with Abdel on LinkedIn
https://www.linkedin.com/in/abdel-khawatmi-79a511144/
Connect with Abdel on Instagram:
https://www.instagram.com/got_mortgages/
Connect with Katie Shive on LinkedIn:
https://www.linkedin.com/in/katieshive/11 March 2026, 5:14 pm - 40 minutes 16 seconds10 Loans per Month, 30-Hr Work Week. Here's the System
What if 10 loans a month — not 30 — was actually the goal?
Sam Abazari has coached over 120 loan officers. His LOs average doubling their business every three months. His top producer closes 30 loans a month. And his branch does $250 million a year.
But his argument? The sweet spot is 10 loans a month, one assistant, 25-35 hours a week, and 200-300 bps margin.
That's the formula for financial freedom, time freedom, and mental bandwidth — all three at once.
In this episode of Mortgage Marketing Radio, Sam fills in for Geoff Zimpfer (who is battling cancer and asked his friends to keep the show going) and delivers a complete, step-by-step operating system for loan officers who want to build a business that works — without working themselves into the ground.
Connect With Sam On LinkedIn:
https://www.linkedin.com/in/samabazari/
Join Sam’s Skool Community:
https://www.skool.com/level-up-lo/about?ref=699a37257d224cf5b321e24964b6be646 March 2026, 5:20 pm - More Episodes? Get the App